If you lose your memory, would you guess you are a good person?

Elinor 2022-01-14 08:01:47

In a completely enclosed warehouse, five people who were in a coma due to accidental inhalation of toxic gas found that they had lost their memories after waking up, and could not even remember their names and what they were doing. Even more deadly, various clues indicated that three of the five people were criminals and the other two were kidnapped hostages, so a thrilling battle took place.

This is a very interesting setting, a bit like a real-life killing game, I thought it would be a good fight of wits. But the result was disappointing. This was not a reasoning question, but a memory question. In the end, the problem was solved by slowly recovering memory.

What’s interesting is that when several people are guessing their identities, they tend to believe that they are good people and accuse the other person of being bad. “You say you’re not a criminal, don’t act like a criminal”. However, in the circumstances at the time, it was obvious that the bad guys were in a more favorable situation. They only had to wait for their accomplices to come back and divide the money, while the good guys faced desperate lives. Ordinarily, at this time, the bad guys should have more psychological advantages. I hope that I am a bad guy to be more rational. The line should be like this: "You are a good guy, and you look like a good guy." I think the actions of the people in the play just show the screenwriter’s good desire for people to still uphold justice in critical situations.

Another thing that I don’t understand is that after the memory is restored, and after knowing his identity, the criminal chooses to cooperate with good people to deal with the upcoming accomplices. This is probably hard to explain as a temporary conscience discovery, but just the effect of the Stockholm effect. .

from my blog:
http://my.donews.com/bingblog/2007/01/24/pSmaywXtLDNGpZQsSTofKsUPpAqPITiYMvZk/

View more about Unknown reviews

Extended Reading
  • Nestor 2022-01-14 08:01:47

    This is actually a good reasoning film, with rigorous analysis, very good foreshadowing, the layout of the stormy villa, and the multiple reversals at the end, and the amnesia setting of the plot and the discussion of human nature are more classic. The only shortcoming is that the reasoning is not enough, and the memory will come back soon, without making the situation more complicated. The little tricks to withdraw money to dig holes, the hostage's analysis of the scene, and the women behind the scenes are all very good details.

  • Bridgette 2022-03-25 09:01:18

    I have seen the drama version of this story before "Memory Card"~

Unknown quotes

  • Jean Jacket: What's your name?

    Broken Nose: What's my name? Fuck your mother. That's my name

  • Jean Jacket: I'm not a criminal.

    Rancher Shirt: Stop acting like one, then.