The contradiction between life and writing

Lisa 2022-01-12 08:01:31

Bergman’s autobiography "The Magic Lamp" mentioned how he stood by his mother’s bed after his mother’s death: “I sat next to my mother for a few hours. Until Heideweig Iliunola’s church knocked for morning prayers. The bell rang, the light and shadow moved, and the melodious sound of the piano came from a distance. I felt that I was not in grief. I was thinking, I was observing myself, and I was playing a role, which was determined by my occupational disease. Follow my life ruthlessly, often madly taking away and destroying my deepest experience." In "Still in the Mirror", isn't Bergman just arguing for the author? Due to the occupational illness of writing, his attitude towards his daughter's mental disorder is also the writer's attitude towards the plot of the characters in the novel, and the same is true for his wife's death. His sons and daughters express these in the form of drama, which is also a punishment for him, punishment in the same way. Perhaps Bergman is also guilty of his occupational disease. Life and writing are contradictory. When you are living, you cannot write. When you are writing, you will always write about past experiences. You will never be able to write about the present. When you are writing, your Life is passing.

View more about Through a Glass Darkly reviews

Extended Reading
  • Whitney 2022-03-28 09:01:08

    Nagging, there are too many lines, and there is an air of self-pity on the whole. There are also a few light and shadow designs for the treatment of my sister.

  • Sid 2022-03-17 09:01:06

    You can’t watch this film when you’re depressed, the pain value doubles, and it’s hard for your brain to not work, but you see, I don’t believe in God, this is the so-called concrete representation of love in the film. And the pain stems from the loss of the belief that allows us to take root in reality and face the darkness, and get into a vicious circle...I would rather believe in some spiritual sustenance beyond reality, but these are in the face of pure and true love How hypocritical and empty.

Through a Glass Darkly quotes

  • Martin: You're empty but capable. And now you're trying to fill your void with Karin's extinction. But how will God fit into that? It must make him more inscrutable than ever!

  • Fredrik: Father, I'm scared. When I was hugging Karin in the boat, reality was revealed. Do you know what I mean?

    David: I do.

    Fredrik: Reality was revealed, and I collapsed. It's like a dream. Anything can happen. Anything.

    David: I know.

    Fredrik: I can't live in this new world.

    David: Yes, you can. But you must have a support.

    Fredrik: What kind of support? You mean a God? Give me a proof of his existance. You can't.

    David: I can. But you gotta pay attention to what I say.

    Fredrik: Yes. I need to listen.

    David: I can only tell you a thought of my own hopes. It is to know that love exists for real in the human world.

    Fredrik: A sort of special love, I suppose?

    David: All kinds of it. The bigger and the smaller, the most absurd one and the most sublime one. All kinds of love.

    Fredrik: What about the desire for love?

    David: Desire and denying. Trust and distrust.

    Fredrik: Then love is the proof?

    David: I don't know if love is the proof of God's existance or if it's God itself.

    Fredrik: To you, love and God are the same thing.

    David: That thought makes me feel less empty; Makes my desperation less worse.

    Fredrik: Go on, dad.

    David: All of a sudden, emptiness turns into abundance, and desperation turns into life. It's like a temporary death's sentence strike.

    Fredrik: Dad... if it's like how you say it is, then God is all over Karin. We love her so much.

    David: Yes.

    Fredrik: Can't that help her?

    David: I think so.