Almost out of the cliché war film

Ephraim 2022-01-14 08:01:40

The First World War broke out in 1914. On a certain battlefield, France, Britain and Germany were at odds with each other. However, Christmas Eve is a wonderful night. There is a pastor in the British army who regards life itself more than anything else; the French army has a German wife under the command; and the German army, in addition to the French wife under the command, there is also a singer. Thus, when art, war, and the return of human nature were mixed together, a seemingly absurd miracle happened. German singers bravely stood up and sang amidst the sound of bagpipes from the Scottish trenches, so the French also came with them. The enemies who had killed each other blood-red, sat down side by side on Christmas Eve, prayed with the Scottish priest, moved to tears together in the voice of the beautiful German female singer, exchanged pictures of their wives and family, and shared Chocolate and champagne. This kind of warmth that has softened everyone still lingers in everyone's heart even when the tripartite generals announce the end of the ceasefire. So something more absurd happened. Ten minutes before the German air raid on the French trenches, the French-speaking general came out and asked them to enter their trenches to escape; and when the French returned in the second round of attack, the Germans were also invited to come to the enemy's trenches to escape. In the end, they peacefully buried their bodies in battle and played football on the battlefield.

This is what you think is absurd and the plot of the movie is still touched by the gestures of German and French communication. When the three generals sit on the battlefield and share the morning coffee, they will toast to each other. I was moved when I wished each other "good luck" in three languages. The sun on Christmas morning shone on different military uniforms. The faces with ragged beards and messed up faces were all living people looking at each other. There are mothers who are waiting to go back to make coffee at 10 o'clock; there are wives who are waiting to go back to share the joy of the birth of their son; there are life waiting to go back and continue.

However, the people who started the war would not understand, nor would they bother to understand this undercurrent of desire for peace and respect for humanity that is surging on the front line. The trilateral forces will eventually end up being transferred to other battlefields. The priest watched the speech of the successor who was instigating the killing, silently took off the cross and turned away; the news that his wife gave birth to a son named Henri was spread because of the help of the Germans, and the French captain burst into tears; the train gradually The line drifted away, but the singing of Germanic accent still came out of the carriage. Until the end of the film.

It is true that the shortcomings of this movie are obvious. When explaining how the three parties came together on Christmas Eve to dissolve their hostility, they were too eager and lacking presentation to appear abrupt, as if all emotions had been reversed by an aria. It was taken nearly a century later, which also made this movie lack a sense of heaviness and cruelty. But this is exactly what the movie wants to express. Once the distorted humanity in the war is released and restored, many warm emotions can also appear on the battlefield.

Diane Kruger's fluent German and excellent performance reminded me of her nationality and identity, and forgave her for being not stunning enough when she played Helen-as a Germanic woman, she was beautiful enough. Although this role is not divided into many dramas, it has a very crucial role. But all my attention was diverted from Daniel's appearance. Yes, that's right, goodbye to the young Alex in Lenin. Three years is enough time for him to grow his beard and put on his military uniform to issue combat orders in German. His face was serious and straight (he was a bit tired at first), he was the first to walk out of the trench and stretched out his hand to hold it, and he was the first to come out to remind the enemy of the bombing of the trench. He wears a coat and boots, and is fluent in German and French. . . . I don't want to be a nympho in such a serious movie, so I can only say that Daniel starred in my mind as the most kind and lovely German officer in history.

I only reject World War II or World War I movies because I don't want to be reminded of how cruel war is. I know it is bloody enough, so I don't want to be forced by Schindler's list to face the history of massive disappearance of lives. In such a long and dark war, I think there should be something else. I believe there should be something else that allows us to breathe, pray, be moved warmly, shake hands with each other bravely, and bless each other sincerely.

"I want to be on the streets of Paris one day, hoping to have a cup of coffee with you as a tourist." The German Jewish officer said goodbye in French.


ps. On the eve of Christmas Eve, only the Germans got the treatment of placing a Christmas tree every 5 meters in the trenches. It seems that their welfare is really better |||

View more about Joyeux Noel reviews

Extended Reading

Joyeux Noel quotes

  • [first lines]

    Enfant francais: Child, upon these maps do heed This black stain to be effaced Omitting it, you would proceed Yet better it in red to trace Later, whatever may come to pass Promise there to go you must To fetch the children of Alsace Reaching out their arms to us May in our fondest France Hope's green saplings to branch And in you, dear child, flower Grow, grow, France awaits its hour.

    Enfant anglais: To rid the map of every trace Of Germany and of the Hun We must exterminate that race We must not leave a single one Heed not their children's cries Best slay all now, the women, too Or else someday again they'll rise Which if they're dead, they cannot do.

    Enfant allemand: We have one and only enemy Who digs the grave of Germany Its heart replete with hatred, gall and envy We have one and only enemy The villain raises its murderous hand Its name, you know, is England.

  • Le Major: Everyone to their posts!

    Gordon: [a moment of indecision] Every man to his post!

    Le Major: Quickly!

    [the Scottish soldiers get in position along the trench wall]

    German Soldiers: [Someone in the German trench stands up and walks into No Man's Land] No, stay here! What're you doing? Come back!

    Le Major: Well, what the hell are you doing! Shoot the bloody Kraut!

    [the Scottish soldiers look at each other; they don't fire]

    Le Major: What are you waiting for? Shoot him, God damn it! Holidays are over!

    [the soldiers shoot in the air to warn the man in No Man's Land, who begins to run toward the French trench]

    Le Major: What the hell do you think you're playing at? Shoot him!

    [Again the soldiers look at each other, shake their heads, and don't fire]

    Le Major: Shoot him!

    [Jonathan shoots the man, who falls midway between the French and German trenches]

    Le Major: Stand down from your posts.

    [They do]

    Le Major: Shame on you, Gordon. Shame on you.

    [Ponchel's alarm clock rings in No Man's Land. Gordon looks out to see Lieutenant Audebert running to help the man Jonathan shot - Ponchel in a German uniform]

    Ponchel: Be silly to die disguised as a German, eh?

    Lieutenant Audebert: What the devil were you doing?

    Ponchel: I had a German help me. I saw my mother. We drank a coffee, just like before... You have a son.

    [Lieutenant Audebert can no longer keep from crying]

    Ponchel: His name is Henri.

    [Ponchel dies, and Lieutenant Audebert sobs even harder. Gordon and the Major look on from their trench, Gordon grave, the Major baffled]

Related Articles