The discrepancy between "Blood Battle on Hacksaw Ridge" and the incident of conscientious objection to military service in real history.

Wellington 2022-03-15 09:01:01

The director Mel Gibson, who has always been known for his realism and brutal masculinity, has brought us the adrenaline explosion of "Hacksaw Ridge" with adrenaline. Let the movie leave a lot of green background CGI technology. Take a solid picture of every explosion, and the spout after every blood vessel is cut off. The actual explosion and shooting, the most realistic show of the purgatory on earth of World War II. Using traditional old-fashioned shooting techniques and slowly spreading the plot, many people recalled the golden age of movie war films. The taste of the long-lost classic spirits! It's back again! "Blood Battle of Hacksaw Ridge" is adapted from real historical events. The story is very simple. It is about a devout Christian who refused to take weapons to the battlefield by a soldier named Des Montedos, who only saved people. So how much is the difference between the real Des Montedos and the Des Montedos under the lens of Mel Gibson. After collecting online and watching documentaries about Doss, I have listed some important parts for everyone.

1. Regarding "conscientious objector" (conscientious objector) To put it simply, "conscientious objector" is a "soldier" who goes to the battlefield without arms but saves people. Doss should be regarded as the first "conscientious objector" in the true sense. In fact, as early as the First World War, a man named Alvin York had already done it and refused to take a weapon, but then gave up midway. So Doss became the first person. Later, during the Vietnam War, two soldiers followed suit, namely Thomas Bennett and Joseph G Lapointe Jr. It is a pity that they died during the Vietnam War.

2. About Dos’s childhood shadow Doss’ childhood did have a shadow. His father was drunk. At that time, the United States was in the Great Depression, and the whole family was filled with horror. Finally one day Doss' father and Doss' little uncle (the younger brother of Doss mother) both had a drink. So Doss’ father almost killed Doss’ uncle with a gun, and Dos’s mother stepped forward to stop it (not that Dos stepped forward to stop), and then Dos’s mother called the police, Doss Only then did he return home and saw what happened in the later stage. His father was handcuffed away by the police. So Doss decided not to touch the weapon ever since. The movie dramatized this scene. Doss' father took a gun and wanted to fuck his mother... Doss stepped forward to stop it.

3. About Doss and his wife Doss are devout Christians, this is because of her mother's infection. When Doss was young, he went to church and met Dorothy, who was also young. So they came together because of the same belief and the same dream. In the movie, this scene was made into a traditional love acquaintance: a soldier fell in love with a nurse, and the nurse fell in love with a bloody soldier. But it was true that Dorothy became a nurse later, but that was because Doss was injured on the battlefield and was unable to work after he retired. Dorothy wanted to support his family and went to take the job title of nurse. And the wedding of Doss and Dorothy was held long before Doss went to serve in the military. In other words, Doss went to the military service after he got married, handled the wedding, and received the red envelopes. In the movie, Doss is unable to attend the wedding because he does not want to carry weapons, just to increase the drama conflict. In reality, he did have a two-week family leave before going to the battlefield, but he seemed to be rejected. In the end, only 3 days were given.

4. Regarding Hacksaw Ridge, you can watch a "Letter from Iwo Jima" directed by Eastwood. Inside, it shows in more detail the Pansi Caves that the Japanese dug on these cliffy islands. The Japanese did the same in Hacksaw Ridge. So when the Americans first came to the island, they had a headache for these cliffs. So Doss and two other soldiers used the cargo net to make a simple rock climbing prop. And this prop was already there when Doss arrived on the battlefield in the movie, and it was quite complete, but in reality, the props for this rock climbing are very crude.

5. Regarding comrades-in-arms, there is little difference between reality and the movie. At the beginning, the comrades-in-arms rejected Dos's practice of not holding weapons. I think he pretends, pretending to be God, who are you? ! So everyone laughed at him, pushed him out, and hit him with shoes and items. As for the fact that he was beaten all over to find teeth in the movie, it was also for theatrical needs. Being beaten like this in a military camp is subject to severe military regulations.

6. Pray for not working on Saturday. Doss is a devout Christian, so he really does not work on Saturday and prays devoutly. This was the case when I was in the barracks at first. Later, there was no other way to go to the battlefield, but to "go to work" on Saturday. But before going to work, he must also pray. That's why soldiers waited for his prayer before going to the battlefield in the movie.

7. His father came to the rescue in the movie about the court trial. Of course not in reality. It's just that Doss' father did contact the church's war committee in the field, which also played a positive role. Finally, after refusing the two-week family leave, Doss was given a three-day family leave again.

8. About the rescue of Japanese soldiers? There is a section in the movie where Doss rescues a Japanese soldier in a cave. This section is a description of Ridos's comrades in the documentary. Of course, because this comrade-in-arms is politically correct, he used his words very carefully and said very vaguely. One time it was said that the Japanese soldier threatened Doss, and the other time it was said that he had only seen a certain Japanese soldier with an American-style dressing. And Doss is because of love. Etc., etc. But as to whether there is such a thing, it is still a little secret.

9. It's true about Doss kicking the grenade, but it's not the Japanese soldiers surrendering and throwing the grenade. But one night, they passed a lair of the Japanese soldiers and were shocked by the grenade that was suddenly thrown over, saying that it was too late, and Doss kicked it away. Finally, the grenade exploded in the air, wounding Doss's leg. After that, Doss sat on the spot and waited for 5 hours on the stretcher before coming over, but within two steps, Doss found that his comrades were injured more seriously than him, so he decided to give the stretcher to his comrades and walked down by himself. At this time, he was beaten by a Japanese sniper. Middle arm. Wounded again.

10. The real shots behind Doss' later film are a sublimation of the film. After watching the movie, everyone stood up and applauded. The core of the real anti-war is the values ​​recognized by the world. In reality, Doss was awarded the Medal of Honor, received an interview from the President, and so on. But Doss' life was not easy after that. He was seriously injured and was deemed 90% disabled. Received nearly 5 and a half years of treatment. After 1976, he was completely deaf. In 1988, he received a cochlear implant surgery to restore his hearing.

Because of the war, Doss lost the ability to work, and his wife became a family member of the labor force. He went to get the title of nurse and worked full-time to increase family income. Doss exchanged the insurance provided by the government and bought a small house on four acres of land. He and his wife gave birth to a son. They usually plant some fruits and vegetables on the lawn of the small house, but in the end, in order to make a living, the lawn was used for farming. After health permit, Doss began to try to do some part-time jobs, such as maintenance worker, cabinetmaker and so on.

In 1991, Doss’s wife Dorothy contracted breast cancer and died in a car accident, which was on the way Doss drove Dorothy to the hospital.

In 1993, Doss remarried and won a second wife named Francis.

In 2006, Doss died.

If you support me, you can also pay attention to my official account: Da Cong Watching Movies

View more about Hacksaw Ridge reviews

Extended Reading
  • Robyn 2021-10-20 18:59:44

    Who told me where Garfield's brother ended up?

  • Humberto 2021-10-20 18:59:43

    The bullets rained, and the leaf did not touch the body. Faith has not changed the war, but it has not allowed the war to change itself. Mel Gibson’s religious fanaticism and personal heroism both make me think about BB, but because I have my life, I have to give five stars with my eyes closed~ (Only Garfield can face killing and violence with such a sunny face, five good The youth’s smile is so beautiful!!!)

Hacksaw Ridge quotes

  • Sgt Howell: This is a personal gift from the United States government to each and every one of you. A standard issue U.S. rifle, caliber .30, M1, a clip-fed, shoulder-fired, semi-automatic weapon designed to bring death and destruction to the enemy. This is to be your lover, your mistress, your concubine. Perhaps the only thing in life you will ever truly love. Fellas, let's dance.

    [the privates begin grabbing weapons]

    Sgt Howell: Grab a girl. Don't point your gun forward. I do not want to be shot today. No matter how much you are tempted. Place the weapon by your side. Pay attention.

    [Doss is the only one who has not picked up a rifle]

    Sgt Howell: Problem, Private Corn Stalk? Is there not one in your size or is it the color that is the issue?

    Desmond Doss: No, Sarge. I was... I was told I don't have to carry a weapon.

    Sgt Howell: Come again? Step forward, Private. I can't be hearing this right.

    Desmond Doss: Well, I'm sorry, Sergeant. I can't touch a gun.

    Captain Glover: What exactly is the problem?

    Desmond Doss: No problem, just a mistake, sir. I told the Army when I joined up.

    Captain Glover: That's not possible. Do you know why that's not possible, Private?

    Desmond Doss: No, sir.

    Captain Glover: Because the United States Army does not make mistakes. So if there's a problem, you must be that problem.

    Desmond Doss: I was just never supposed to be sent to a rifle company.

    Sgt Howell: He's a C.O., sir.

    Captain Glover: You're a conscientious objector, and you joined the Army?

    Desmond Doss: Well, no, sir, I'm a conscientious cooperator.

    Captain Glover: [bemused] Are you screwing with me, Doss?

    Desmond Doss: No. No, sir. I volunteered. I ain't got no problem with wearing my uniform, or saluting the flag and doing my duty. It's just carrying a gun and the taking of human life.

    Captain Glover: You don't kill? That's all?

    Desmond Doss: That's all. Yes, sir, that's all.

    Captain Glover: You know quite a bit of killing does occur in a war?

    Desmond Doss: Yes, sir.

    Captain Glover: I mean, that is the essential nature of war.

    Desmond Doss: Yes, sir.

    Captain Glover: All right. Do you have any other requirements of the United States Army? Is there anything else we can do to ensure that you have a comfortable stay here with us?

    Sgt Howell: He doesn't want to work on Saturdays, sir.

    Desmond Doss: Well, Saturdays... I'm a Seventh-Day Adventist. So, Saturday is my Sabbath, so I'm not allowed to work then.

    Captain Glover: I don't think that poses a problem, do you, Sergeant? We shall simply ask the enemy not to invade on the Sabbath, 'cause Private Doss here is at prayer. All right. Now we got that clear. Now let me tell you my requirements. They're not as complicated as yours. They're very simple. As long as you're in this company, under my command, you will obey my orders. Period. If you can't do it here, I can't trust you to do it in battle. I'm putting you in for a Section 8, psychiatric discharge. Dismissed.

  • Sgt Howell: Gentlemen! I want you to meet Private Desmond Doss. Apparently, Private Doss does not believe in violence. He does not practice violence. He will not even deign to touch a weapon. You see, Private Doss is a conscientious objector. So I plead with you, do not look to him to save you on the battlefield, because he will undoubtedly be too busy wrestling with his conscience to assist.

    Desmond Doss: Sarge, that's not true...

    Sgt Howell: PRIVATE, AS YOU WERE! Now I realize that some of you might have strong feelings about this. It is what we men fight for. To defend our rights, and to protect our women and children. Even if Private Doss' beliefs might cause women and children to die. So I will expect everyone in this company to give Private Doss the full measure of respect he is due for the short time that he will be with us.