1. From a structural point of view: the two films only have the same main setting when they travel back to high school, and the others are not the same. place.
2. From the perspective of genre: "Peggy is going to get married" is actually not a commercial film in the strict sense, but a film with a certain literary temperament. The overall film is relatively plain, and the plot does not have strong dramatic conflicts, and there is no sense of joy. It's not strong either. "Charlotte Annoyance" has a typical comedy and commercial temperament. It can be seen from the back of the film that the first half of the film is full of laughter, and the overall dramatic conflict is also very strong. The peak of life, and then quickly fell to the bottom, thus realizing the preciousness of the people around him, the plot is rich and ups and downs.
3. From the perspective of characters: "Peggy Is Getting Married" lacks an empathetic character. As the heroine, Peggy is in the real world without worrying about food and clothing, and has her own career. Although her husband cheated, she obviously did not cause her any pain. After returning to the past, she had no clear purpose. In her daily interactions with Charlie, she didn't want to teach him some lessons because of his cheating. On the contrary, she couldn't help herself because of his derailment. She asked to have a relationship with him, but was rejected. After meeting Michael, he had a relationship with Michael that night. These actions make it difficult to see Peggy's personal emotional orientation, and the sympathy points brought by her previous husband's derailment are also greatly reduced.
And Charlotte was a dick who had no dignity at the beginning and was trampled by others. He lost face at the wedding. The character has fallen to the bottom. Although the audience can't agree with him 100% (eating soft rice), at least there is With a certain degree of understanding, he also had a certain expectation for his actions after crossing. Xia Luo returned to the past with a clear goal, that is, he must get his first love Qiuya. He took his first kiss when he saw Qiuya, then changed seats and successfully fell in love with Qiuya.
From the perspective of the identity of crossing, Peggy did not make full use of this. Although she told Richard her identity of crossing and talked about things that might be invented in the future, she went to the underwear store and found that pantyhose was not invented. I made one at home, but it was just a one-off. She wrote an eight song to Charlie (I don't know American music, it may be a popular golden song in the 1980s), but this song did not change Charlie's destiny. Before this branch had time to unfold, Peggy went back to the present, completely wasting the setting of crossing. And Charlotte used this stalk to the fullest. He preempted to sing the songs that the singers have not yet written, and became famous in one fell swoop. After the Spring Festival Gala, he became famous. All the people who stepped on him before were only under his feet and formed. In order to achieve a huge contrast with the previous stage, the audience's expectations were established in the early stage, and the audience's expectations were also responded to in the later stage.
In addition, the two films have different emphasis on the portrayal of the protagonist’s age in terms of character creation.
In "Peggy's Getting Married", the film focuses on shaping Peggy's behavior and personality characteristics as a middle-aged woman. For example, she will drink secretly, and she will not take her parents' reprimands seriously. She will face boys with a very mature attitude. , Will no longer worry about emotional gains and losses, smoking in front of them, proactively begging Charlie, hearing the late grandma's phone call can not help himself. The middle-aged woman has faded away from love, and she knows the value of family affection. She is no longer that little girl.
"Charlotte Troubles" focuses on Charlotte's release and arrogance after extreme depression. You said he behaves like a middle-aged man? Burn the curtains? Forcibly kiss female classmates in the classroom? Unlike him, his behavior is more exaggerated and caricature. Compared with him, "Peggy Is Getting Married" is more lifelike and realistic.
4. From the perspective of plot: the plots of the two films are completely different.
Peggy travels back to the past. She actually doesn’t want to change the world. She still leads her daily life at home, getting along with her parents, socializing with classmates at school, attending classes, participating in drum band rehearsals, participating in dances, and dating people. This story is completely established as she is a person who travels through.
Charlotte traveled back to the past, he wanted to change the world, he wanted to be famous (he did it), he wanted first love (he got it), and later he got AIDS, realized the importance of Ma Dongmei to him, and went back to the present. Charlotte has brought tremendous changes to this world, which cannot be done without crossing.
5. Regarding the theme
"Peggy is going to get married", the theme is actually very vague. In the beginning, we saw a couple who looked like a divorce. Although the husband cheated, the wife did not seem to be injured much. At the beginning, the audience did not expect much of these two people. Being together, and Peggy easily had a relationship with Michael after crossing, which makes people not expect the two to reunite. So after returning to the present, the two of them were relieved of their previous suspicion in the hospital bed, and they did not appear to be too moving.
The main thrust of "Charlotte's Annoyance" is obvious, that is, to cherish the person in front of you. Charlotte values face and first love, but doesn't value his wife who has worked so hard to feed herself every day. After returning to the past, he pursued his first love wholeheartedly, and did not put Ma Dongmei aside until he became famous and got everything he wanted. Knowing the sacrifice Ma Dongmei made for her, he felt empty and felt himself. The most important thing is lost. After tossing for a long time, I returned to the original point at the end of the story, but this original point made the audience (especially female audiences) extremely satisfied. When they saw Charlotte, they stuck to Ma Dongmei. They had long been expecting it. This moment has been a long time.
—————————————— This is the dividing line at the beginning of the pull film——————————————————
(Preliminary comparison is because the scene and the plot are still A little bit of comparability, there is almost no comparability after crossing, so I pulled it alone.)
"Pei" begins to explain that Peggy Su is wearing a shiny dress and her daughter is going to attend a class reunion together, explaining Pei through a mother-daughter dialogue Jisu finds out that her husband has a third party and is about to divorce her husband Charlie, but she has her own business and is an image of a strong woman. Her mood is not very depressed. It is difficult to establish the audience's deep sympathy and recognition for her through this scene. , Her character has not been displayed vividly and three-dimensionally.
"Xia" begins to show that Shen Teng is sitting in another's luxury car and has to go around the community, not only is full of joy, but also directly highlights the hero's face-loving character.
After "Pei" it tells that Peggy Su came to the party, greeted everyone, met many sisters, explained their relationship, danced with friend Richard, and told her girlfriend that Michael was the only boy she wanted to have sex with. Also because the shiny dress became the focus of the audience, she brought the crown on stage, and was pushed over the cake full of candles. She became more and more nervous until she fainted. In this scene, I still don't see what kind of personality Peggy Su is like, and she seems to be fainted because of her nervousness. The whole picture is in the dark, and the greetings between her and the people are like a pot of porridge, which does not leave a deep impression on people, such as who is an enemy or a friend.
In "Xia", Shen Teng came to the wedding and experienced a series of unlucky passages that made the audience sympathize with him. At the wedding, I first slapped my shirt with the emcee, then I was teased by my classmates writing limericks, and then I was humiliated by the teachers of the forces. Then his wife rushed to expose his poor family and the current situation of relying on his wife to support him. Shen Teng was so embarrassed that he fled to the bathroom and opened the door after being hit hard. In this passage, the audience fully sees the protagonist's face-saving character, his incompetence and the dilemma of life. Although I don't like the male protagonist, I have established a certain degree of emotional understanding of him. Many of the characters in the scene are also highly recognizable. The teacher's greed for petty and cheapness, Montagut's feminine, Yuan Hua's sleek and mean character, etc., their relationship with Shen Teng has basically been established.
"Pei" woke up in the school infirmary and was told that she had fainted because of blood donation. She woke up and saw her young classmates and found that she had returned to 1960. She didn't do anything, but in a dazed condition, she asked them how their hair style changed. Later, she came out of the infirmary and was taken home by classmates in a car. Throughout the process, the heroine was always in a dizzy passive state, and her classmates did not notice her abnormality, thinking that she just fainted by donating blood. The whole scene is bland and tasteless.
"Xia" takes the school play to the extreme. He came to the classroom, first kissed his first love, then beat the teacher, burned the classroom, and caused an uproar in the classroom. He thought that he was in a dream and could finally indulge without any scruples. Finally, the teacher could not bear to call him. mom. Charlotte hugged her mother, decided to end this perfect dream, and jumped downstairs. All of Charlotte's actions are extreme and full of dramatic tension.
The heroine of "Peace" returned home. Her mother thought she was tired and needed to go to bed. Peggy couldn't help but hug her mother and said that she missed her mother's perfume, and her mother asked her to go upstairs to sleep for a while. She went back to the room, saw her old things, saw her sister, and hugged them hard, but they were all confused because of her abnormal behavior, and her sister thought she was particularly strange. Peggy is eager to mend the bad relationship with her sister in the past, and wants to play games with her sister. Although this section was very excited, Peggy's return to the past did not give a strong visual impact.
In "Xia", Charlotte awoke from his sleep in the hospital bed. He asked the current US President whether it was Obama or not. He was full of joy. Then he ran out and saw the street scene in 1997. At this moment, he used the popular songs of that year to set off the atmosphere. Charlotte raised his hands in the crowd and closed his eyes, giving people a sense of ritual returning to that era. Afterwards, the dialogue between Ma Dongmei and Charlotte was also full of joy. Charlotte returned to the hospital and officially recognized that he had returned to the past.
"Peace" Peggy and her sister watch TV together, evaluate the stars on TV, and don't let her sister eat red candy. The heroine secretly drinks, the sister asks what to eat tonight, and the father comes back and introduces them to the new car he bought. Dad found that his daughter was drunk and wanted to ban her. Peggy disagrees. Mother sent drunk Peggy to bed, and the mother and daughter had a warm conversation. ,
This paragraph is to show the warm and ordinary daily chores, there is no feeling of joy, and there is no drama conflict.
——————————— This is the underscore of the two films’ respective developments———————————————— The
following is the plot of "Peggy Is Getting Married":
No. The next morning, the family had breakfast, and his father warned Peggy not to get into bad habits. Peggy enjoys everyone's time together. Charlie honked his car horn outside. Peggy went out, and her mother asked her if she had quarreled with Charlie. Peggy said it was because of family expenses. (Taking fun at the present with what happened in the future, funny) When Charlie got into Charlie's car, Charlie wanted to kiss her, Peggy said that he had a headache and refused to kiss. Charlie drove like crazy. Charlie and Peggy talked about last week, but Peggy has no memory. Charlie said he hoped that the two could have a relationship with someone and get married later, Peggy directly proposed to break up.
(This paragraph is the mental contrast between Peggy and everyone. Everyone regards her as a little girl, but she is already a mature woman.)
People around me found it strange to sing devotedly in music class.
Peggy has to take the exam without knowing it, but she knows nothing but graffiti. The teacher questioned her grades, and she countered the teacher saying that algebra was useless in later life.
Peggy is in a literature class, Michael and the teacher are arguing about the old man and the sea, Peggy is deeply fascinated.
The classmates praised Peggy’s contradiction to the math teacher, but Peggy walked to Richard to congratulate him on winning the math competition, but was teased whether she was hanging Richard, Peggy retorted fiercely, but Richard Thinking that Peggy wanted to find herself as a tutor, Peggy invited him. During the process, Peggy kept silently watching Michael in the distance.
Peggy invited Richard to meet after school, and Charlie was jealous.
Peggy conducts the orchestra training. Charlie admits to Peggy the mistake of wanting to date someone before. He feels sad, and Peggy said it was right.
Peggy asked Charlie about the possibility of time travel. Charlie said it was possible. When she told Richard that she was from the future, Charlie didn't believe it. Peggy presented evidence to convince Charlie.
Richard asked Peggy to crash into the car to verify that he was dead, but Peggy finally refused.
Peggy received a call from her grandmother. In reality, her grandmother has passed away, so Peggy was so excited that she couldn't talk on the phone. , Mom thought that Peggy's recent abnormality was due to Charlie, and told Peggy not to have sex with Charlie.
Charlie came to pick up Peggy and cheered himself in the car outside the house.
Charlie talks to Peggy's father and expresses that he will marry Peggy in the future.
Peggy’s mother encouraged Peggy and Charlie to date and get along well.
Peggy and Charlie left home to go to the prom.
Peggy discovered Charlie’s singing ability and was very moved.
Peggy asked Charlie to have sex, because last week Charlie asked Peggy to refuse. Charlie was not angry. agree.
After breaking up with Charlie, Peggy finds that Michael is alone in the cafe.
Peggy enters the cafe to express his appreciation for Michael and smokes in front of Michael. Dolores sees Peggy getting on Michael's motorcycle
Peggy and Michael are talking about poetry in the wild.
Peggy came to Charlie in the video store where Charlie worked. Charlie expressed his apologies to Peggy last night.
Peggy and Richard study what money can be invented, Peggy discovers that pantyhose has not been invented yet.
Peggy’s friend learns that Peggy is having a relationship with Michael and asks her. Peggy tells them that it is impossible to be with Charlie, and the friend is very disappointed.
At night, Charlie sneaked into Peggy's house, trying to stuff her with a pillow, but found that she woke up and gave up. The two went to the basement together. Charlie questioned Peggy and Michael's relationship. Charlie tried to restore the relationship between the two, but Peggy disagreed. Peggy hopes that Charlie can go to college and not pursue useless dreams.
Michael said that after graduation, he hoped that Peggy would live a divorced life in Utah. Peggy refused. Peggy saw Charlie singing on stage and was fascinated by him.
After Charlie sang the song and asked the producer, the producer thought he could not become famous.
Peggy encouraged Charlie and wrote a song to Charlie and asked him to sing
Delores to tease Peggy. Peggy spilled ink on her chest because she told Charlie about the accident with Michael.
Peggy saw Richard and said that he had decided to say goodbye to Charlie. The next day was Peggy's birthday. She wanted to avoid getting pregnant and leave there as soon as possible. Richard proposed to her, but she refused.
Charlie told Peggy to celebrate her birthday, but Peggy refused.
Peggy took the bus to meet her grandpa and grandma's house.
Peggy returned to her grandpa and grandma's house, and grandpa and grandma came out to greet her.
Peggy talked with her grandpa and grandma and told about her journey through. Grandpa and grandma believed her.
Grandpa sent Peggy to the 18th birthday party, and the two said goodbye to grandma.
Grandpa decided to help Peggy return to the future.
Grandpa and everyone knew about Peggy and decided to help her go home together. Everyone performed strange rituals and wore strange costumes. The bishop led everyone to recite chants. The sky flashed and thundered, the candles were blown out, and it was dark. The lights came on and the heroine was looted by Charlie. Charlie decided to give up singing and propose to Peggy. Peggy refused. I gave Peggy a necklace as a gift, which was a photo of her and Charlie when they were young, and the two embraced and lingered together.
Peggy wakes up, the children and Charlie are surrounded by them, and the two apologize to each other. Charlie says that he has separated from the third party. Charlie asks Peggy to give him another chance. Peggy invites Charlie to take the children to dinner at home on the weekend, and the two hug tightly.
—————————————— This is the dividing line for the end of "Peggy
Is Getting Married "—————————The stupid big man was framed and caught smoking. Ma Dongmei feels good about herself and thinks Charlotte likes her, and Qiuya is in a bad mood because of being kissed.
The principal wants to expel Charlotte. Mother Charlotte pretends to be assaulted by the principal, and the principal is forced to keep Charlotte.
Charlotte gave a speech in front of all the students in the school. Ma Dongmei fainted on the playground when Ma Dongmei learned that Charlotte had kissed Qiuya.
When Xia Luo asked to change to Qiuya, Yuan Hua was forced to compromise. Ma Dongmei sat in the back seat of the two of them. Xia Luo sang to Qiuya. Ma Dongmei asked
to sing to her. Xia Luo sent Ma Dongmei out of her daughter-in-law.
A flamboyant performance under the background of a cut plum.
Mother Charlotte wanted to help Charlotte drive away evil spirits, so she asked Aunt Wang to find a mirror with charms. When Charlotte came back to play various jokes on the two people,
Charlotte could not find the tape of Pu Shu, suddenly realized that Pu Shu, Xu Wei and other celebrities were not hot yet, shouted that he wanted to fire, and immediately played and
sang the song
"Those Flowers ". "Huaer", showing the lives of the classmates, Qiuya is practicing piano, Meng Te is wearing skirts with female make-up, Dachun is watching Saint Seiya
cos Zilong, Long Hair is playing mahjong with his family, Yuan Hua is watching the yellow net and fast learning The webpage responded to her mother. Ma Dongmei was riding in the sunset and
Yuan Hua comforted Qiuya, saying that she had found someone to teach Charlotte. At the school radio station
, Xia Luo sang "You Once" to Qiu Ya. Qiu Ya and many students, passers-by, and Teacher Wang were all moved by the singing. Ma Dongmei was so angry that she rushed over and beat Xia Luo.
Wang criticized Ma Dongmei, while allowing Charlotte to participate in singing competitions
Charlotte sang "nunchaku", but only a third, but the first is a primary school, sang I offer oil for the motherland.
Charlotte tells herself how to warm Qiuya with ice soda with her chest, which impressed Qiuya, but Dachun came over and pierced Charlotte
's trick of removing the front wheel of Qiuya's bicycle . Charlotte wanted to take the opportunity to use her car to pick up Qiuya from school, but the car was locked. Ma Dongmei did it. She picked up Qiuya. Tai
Chun said Ma Dongmei look better, Charlotte asked the sentence was not like her now, Spring shy denied
Charlotte Spring chase Ma Dongmei teach, and teach him to get money to buy a house on the university. Several rascals came to Charlotte.
Chen Kai and his younger brothers beat Xia Luo to prevent him from chasing Qiuya. Xia Luo failed to spend money and Ma Dongmei came to rescue him, and Chen Kai took a fancy to him. Xia
Luo let her go to protect her. Ma Dongmei misunderstood that he was in the same group as the gang. When Ma Dongmei was about to be assaulted by Chen Kai, Xia Luo slapped Chen Kai
on the head with a brick. On the body. Teacher Wang worked hard to save them. Ma Dongmei asked if
Xia Luo liked Qiuya or hated herself. Xia Luo watched her cry and said that she did not hate her. Ma Dongmei was happy.
Ma Dongmei imitated Qiuya, but Qiuya laughed at
Yuan Hua's play but was robbed of the limelight by Charlotte's singing. Dachun learned Leslie Cheung to chase Ma Dongmei, but was slapped and failed. Charlotte mistakenly regarded Ma Dongmei
as Qiuya , catching up with the rooftop, severely damaging Dongmei, and being flattened by Dongmei.
Xiao Luo was taken away by the two men in black, and Ma Dongmei was rescued by a fight, but the sister was about to talk to Xiao Luo, and Xiao Luo shouted excitedly. Ma Dongmei thought
he was being bullied and knocked a brick on the head of the sister.
Xia Luo and Qiu Ya show affection, Ma Dongmei and Yuan Hua are both stimulated, Xia Luo participates in rehearsals and does not participate in the college entrance examination.
Ma Dongmei saw Charlotte to plot against the Yuan Hua and Chen Kai, begged them to let Charlotte, agreed with Chen Kai into the grove
Charolais with that chorus Xiangyuejiuba sister, Wang after seeing on TV to show off to family, mother Charlotte proudly tears, president accepted by all
kinds of interviews also show off, Charlotte has become a burning curtains attractions, Charlotte hung on the wall of famous celebrities, side by side with Newton
letter received Charlotte Dongmei, Dongmei home studies, Bless Charlotte
Qiuya refused to contact Yuan Hua for fear of Xia Luo's misunderstanding. Yuan Hua wailed in the song of a plum cut, and Meng Telai comforted the
student Zhou who had become popular in the Chinese Voice Show. Qiuya was angry and actively engaged in image public relations. She was rejected by calling Charlotte
and caught Charlotte on the cruise. Charlotte gave Liu Tianwang a song, and Qiuya praised him, but he asked if he could not write songs, he would love himself.
? Yuan Hua, who was fishing, ran into everyone.
Xia Luo asked Yuan Hua to compose poems for herself, Yuan Hua flattered, and Xia Luo wanted to invest money in Yuan Hua to run a magazine. Yuan Hua said that Dongmei was
insulted by Chen Kai back then , which shocked Charlotte.
Xia Luo meets Yuan Hua again, Yuan Hua tells that Chen Kai insulted Dongmei’s past,
Yuan Hua recalls that Dongmei resisted Chen Kai and insulted the past.
Everyone except Xia
Luo knew this, Xia Luo was angry, Xia Luo remembered Ma Dongmei alone, and Xia Luo
came to Ma Dongmei’s residence. asked the old man Ma Dongmei downstairs where
Charlotte knock on the wrong door, out of the bickering husband and wife, and finally met Ma Dongmei
Charlotte regret missed Ma Dongmei, and Spring has been found that Ma Dongmei married
Charlotte debauchery in ktv
Ma Dongmei to Spring cupping, burning the wrong Dachun was
drunk and returned home, and Charlotte found Qiuya and Yuan Hua had an affair.
Charlotte was
driving a sports car in KTV . Charlotte watched Dachun riding a bicycle and carrying Ma Dongmei. Shaluo’s
creation was unsuccessful
. Dachun gave the sleeping Ma Dongmeigai. quilt
Charlotte family playing mahjong disagree
Charlotte alone in the balcony drinking
Charolais announced its withdrawal from the music, burn their posters
Charlotte recalled Ma Dongmei had promised to give her a sunflower
Charlotte with his Ferrari car changed a sunflower
Charlotte Looking for Dachun to play together
Dachun chose the game arcade
Charlotte let the Spring Dongmei returned to his, Spring beat Charlotte
Charlotte was HIV
Spring sad walk in the rain
Charlotte mother and the good publicity, Charlotte rage
Ma Dongmei see Charlotte was hindered
Ma Dongmei climb the window to see Charlotte, told Charlotte's favorite song is just once, Charlotte died
Charlotte back through
Charlotte kiss Ma Dongmei
a student of Ma Dongmei and Charlotte kissing under the gaze of the students
Charlotte kiss Ma Dongmei
police Neixia Luo tight Ma Dongmei hold hold
police Neixia Luo tightly hug Ma Dongmei
Ma Dongmei in vegetable, Charlotte kneeling washboard hold Ma Dongmei
Ma Dongmei cycling with Charlotte, Charlotte hold Ma Dongmei
Charlotte tightly hug Ma Dongmei
Ma Dongmei playing mahjong, Charlotte Hold Ma Dongmei and don't let
Charlotte hold Ma Dongmei and don't let
Charlotte hold Ma Dongmei
View more about Peggy Sue Got Married reviews
