In the past two days, I saw a lot of black characters' remarks, and I was a little angry and a little anxious. The information density of Team 3 is too high. Three-dimensional partners have also come to ask me what the details are. So I will simply and rudely come up with a rumor post, and by the way, popularize the basic personality of the MCU captain.
[Misrepresentation 1] The captain was because the Winter Soldier was unwilling to sign the "Bill"
[Fact] The captain was unwilling to sign the "Act" and had nothing to do with the Winter Soldier.
Before the bombing in Vienna, that is, before the Winter Soldier was framed as the murderer of the bombing , The captain expressed his unwillingness to sign the bill. “People in the United Nations also have the motive. If they don’t let us go where we should go, what should we do if we go where we shouldn’t go.” “This bill is for us. The responsibility is shied away", "Tony, you did the right thing because you made the right choice. If we sign the bill, it will be equivalent to handing over our right to choose." The
Russell brothers said in the publicity. , US Team 3 has two lines, the bill line and the Winter Soldier line. The first half of the movie relies on the bill line to promote the development of the plot, and the second half relies on the Winter Soldier line to promote the plot. The two lines are actually completely independent.
In the movie, when Tony suggested, "Everything that happened up to now can be redeemed, we can turn this operation into a legal action and send the Winter Soldier back to the American mental hospital instead of Wakanda's prison", even The only time the captain almost signed the "Bill" in this movie.
Regarding why the captain is unwilling to sign the bill, this is also the point I want to talk about the most, because it is too long to say at the end.
[Misunderstanding 2] The captain recruited TeamCap to oppose the bill and defeat Iron Man.
[The truth] The captain recruited TeamCap to stop Zemo’s Westerly Project.
Team 3 first mentioned that the recruiting of TeamCap was the Winter Soldier. Tell the captain that there are five more in Siberia. "Winter Soldiers", and they are enough to subvert a country overnight. The captain asked Falcon if he could ask Tony to help stop the Westwind Project. The captain and Falcon judged that Tony might not be able to help under the law, so Falcon said, "I can find someone", that is, they can recruit ants. People come to help stop the Westwind Project.
When Hawkeye appeared at the airport, the captain said, I'm sorry, I didn't want to call you. When Hawkeye came to the Red Witch, he said that the captain needs help. If you want to redeem your sins, don't feel depressed like a high school student. "Help" and "atonement" actually refer to the hope that she will help prevent Zemo from hurting more people.
In fact, when the team leader and others discovered that the airport was evacuated and TeamIronman appeared at the airport, they were very surprised. The goal of the captain of the airport war is also to get on the plane to Siberia as soon as possible.
[Misrepresentation 3] The captain of the last big battle
killed Iron Man. [The truth] The captain didn’t want to kill Iron Man. He just wanted to prevent Iron Man from killing the Winter Soldier.
Let’s look back at the battle in the final battle from the perspective of the captain. The whole process:
1. The captain used the shield to hit Iron Man’s [foot lift device] and said to the Winter Soldier, [Run];
2. The captain again said to the Winter Soldier to run quickly, saying [Tony won’t stop] , And tried to stop Iron Man, the shield was knocked down;
3. Iron Man blasted off the exit, [The Winter Soldier lost the opportunity to escape], the captain began to fight Iron Man;
4. After the captain was knocked to the ground, Winter Bing wanted to cut off Iron Man’s power source, [I was interrupted by his arm and lost the ability to resist];
5. The captain attacked Iron Man with all his strength, and Friday analyzed the captain’s attack mode. Iron Man ordered a full attack on Friday, and the captain finally I smashed the power source with a shield;
thank you for reading such a long text review, what do I want to say?
From the very beginning, attacking Tony's foot lifter, the captain's purpose was to delay Tony's attack, so as to create a time gap so that the Winter Soldier could escape. When the exit was blasted off, the captain thought that Tony was vowing to take the Winter Soldier's life, so he played against Tony. When the Winter Soldier's arm was interrupted and lost all resistance, the captain chose to destroy Tony's power source. [Tony modified his energy source in "Iron Man 3". Losing the energy source will not harm Tony's life, but it will make Tony lose the combat effectiveness of the armor when he is in a rage. ]
Because this is the only way to prevent the death of the Winter Soldier.
In an interview between the Russell Brothers and producer Kevin Feggy, the creator described Tony was really vested in killing Bucky. In an interview with Collider Heroes, the Russell brothers described the final scene as one character trying to kill the other while the third trying to stop the murder.
CE said Bucky is Steve's best friend, his only connection to the past. He can't watch Bucky get beaten to death.
[Viewpoint 4] The captain throwing the shield is a scumbag, careful eye, not thinking about old feelings... (50 adjectives are omitted below)
[Truth]...
When I saw this sentence, I was a little dumbfounded and could not laugh or cry. The mental activities were very complicated. This is not a fact that can be rebutted to life and death, it is a person's evaluation of a character. Everyone's evaluation is different. This is not a misinformation, maybe it's just a different point of view.
But I still want to say, I think at the moment I throw away the shield, Steve must be in a very complicated mood. At first I thought it was a man’s self-esteem. When my teammates said "you are not worthy of the shield made by my dad", the first reaction of ordinary people like me is probably the same. If so, then I No more.
When I came back from the second brush, I thought about it carefully, but I felt that this might be the captain's inner apology to his teammates. Tony was right, the shield was indeed made by Howard, so after the battle with Howard's son, leaving the shield may be Steve's relief and explanation.
The captain said in a letter to Tony, "The Avengers may be more important to you than to me." This sentence seems to reflect the same mentality. For Steve Rogers, the words "Captain America" are nothing but the words. Is a false name. Steve Rogers became Captain America not because of that shield, but because he was himself. From this moment on, he returned from Captain America to Steve Rogers.
When Little Spider asked him where you came from, he replied Little Spider, I am from Brooklyn. He will always be the little guy from Brooklyn.
Even if history forgets our names. I can go wandering. I do not mind. Not enough.
———————— The following is the film review section——————————
As promised, the Russell brothers rejected a simple story of justice and villain, and rejected a story of pure right and wrong. . At the end, I realized that they didn't plan to tell you who chose the right or wrong choice. What they want to tell you is what they chose and why.
The director and editor used a lot of pen and ink to pave the way for Tony's choice, the parents who were killed, the mother who lost her son, and the TV footage of Sokovia. But I think there is a sentence that can summarize Tony's choice very well. The mother who lost her son said, "When a person feels guilty, he will be very generous."
Tony's guilt has continued from "Iron Man 1" to the present day. Knowing that the weapons he produced were used to cause a large number of civilians, it originated from Ultron and from the additional damage when the Avengers eliminated the enemy. In the past movies, he only relied on the decisions made by himself or the reunion, so he suspected that he made personal decisions. Whether the decision is really rational. This is related to his experience, which is a choice closely related to personal experience.
Of course, there are some more personal reasons, such as Pepper.
As a fan of the captain, I actually regret the lack of description of the captain's motivation in the movie. The captain said in the closing letter that I prefer to believe in individuals. When Captain America was born in "American Team 1", he was photographed by the government to perform a thigh dance. In the "American Team 2" war, he discovered that the S.H.I.E.L.D. Bureau he was maintaining had actually been completely corroded by Hydra. In "American Team 1", he chose to disobey the order to save people behind enemy lines. In "American Team 2", he chose to stand alone against the eroded Hydra. "Beautiful Team 3" is a sequel, and fans of these elements may be precious, but for passers-by who are watching a movie for the first time, it has to be said that the description of the captain’s motivation to choose is almost only between the words, which is too much. not enough.
Steve doesn't believe in governments and organizations. He has been deceived by governments and organizations too many times. He believes that governments and organizations are also made up of individuals, everyone has weaknesses and motives, and any supervision may be linked to political, capital, and even criminal colors. Instead of trusting others, it is better to trust yourself. This is also related to his experience, his past experience is part of his cognitive system.
Of course, there are also some more personal reasons, such as Bucky, which made him almost sign the bill.
You will see that in this war everyone has their own reasons for choosing, and the Russell brothers handled it very delicately. The widow sister sleekly hopes to smooth the friction between the Women’s Federation and the public. The little spider believes in the guidance of the stronger idol Iron Man. The Black Panther is because of the death of his father, and the Falcon is the trust in the captain...every My personal reasons are only related to myself, none of them are the same.
It is very interesting. When both sides of the civil war hope to make rational decisions, their decisions are actually based on personal experience. I am not saying that this is not good, it is good, personal experience is part of our self. As long as you are alone, you must have this weakness. You already have your own past, judgment, goals, and motivations. So so are the Avengers. The Avengers are not without their shortcomings. No one is absolutely right.
I thought about it for a long time. At a certain level, if there is real reason, absolute fairness, and perfect procedural justice in this world, I think I will probably stand on Iron Man’s side, on the other hand, the judgments made by the capable people based on personal experience. , One side is a rational, perfect, and procedural justice judgment, of course I would choose the latter. But is there really absolute rationality, fairness, and procedural justice in the world?
I feel sorry, but the answer is no. All decisions are made by people. Since they are made by people, they must be influenced by the person's past, judgment, goals, and motivations. Whether it is the avengers, ordinary people, or the so-called government supervision that sends heavy troops to arrest the avengers.
When the Winter Soldier was arrested, the captain asked the government, would you hire a lawyer for him? The government official smiled contemptuously. You see, he has made a judgment based on his own experience and experience. He has never tried to find out if I caught the wrong person out of reason. He didn't even bother to pretend that I was just and invulnerable from the program. It is not his fault, because he is an individual, any of us can be blindfolded.
We are weak because we are human beings.
In fact, this choice is very simple. Since the decision of the Avengers is irrational, the decision of government supervision is also irrational. So for me, I tend to choose a party with a greater probability of making a correct decision.
Although superheroes don’t really exist in this world, do you remember the first time every super hero put on a uniform and took up a weapon? Do you remember how he defeated the first enemy? Do you remember how he was hunted for the first time? Do you remember how he still appeared on the scene of protecting civilians after being hunted down? Yes, Steve Rogers has no selfish intentions. Steve Rogers is the most extreme person in this aspect of all superheroes. But almost all superheroes are like this. When he saves a person, he will laugh. When he sees a person being hurt, he will frown and he will cry.
Being a superhero does not bring any substantial benefits to people. reputation? Most superheroes wear masks, and fame comes not only with praise, but also with doubts. Safety? As long as you become a superhero, it means that you and your family have been targeted by criminal organizations. money? It seems that most superheroes don’t receive wages, and Chaoying, who is poor as a dog, grabs a lot...so why are they still protecting the world? Why did the captain and the Winter Soldier go to Siberia to stop Zemo from releasing the other five "Winter Soldiers" after being hunted down? They can pat their buttocks and walk away, and then after Zemo succeeded, they stood up and said, telling you that it was a conspiracy, you don't believe it, hahahaha, you idiots. But they didn't.
I think this sentence is very vulgar. But I can't find another better word to describe it. It's because of love.
Love is the purest and most beautiful emotion that human beings can have. Love gives people persistence, strength and confidence. Except for the love for this world, I can't think of any reason for them to decide to stand up and protect the world with their own ability. I can't think of any reason for them to stand up when they are conservatively questioning or even hunting down. Love exists in their deepest and most original place. Love is their essence.
We are strong because we are born as human beings and because we are born with love.
So I am willing to believe in them, I am willing to believe in their decision based on love, I am willing to believe that when Rocky swept New York with Pippi shrimp, Ultron took the robot to destroy the world, and Hydra pointed the sky warship at every ordinary person. They stood out.
They may be the two ends of the civil war, they may have different ideas and meet each other in battle, but in essence, they are all out of love for this world.
I don't want to believe in people who sit in the regulatory organization in a high-sounding manner, perhaps by economic power or political capital. I don't want to believe their motives after they have made so many mistakes.
I think that when Tony showed up in Siberia and said to the captain that maybe I was wrong, when Tony hung up the call asking him to deal with the prison robbery, he might have understood that government supervision could not help him avoid what he had committed. Mistakes, and even government supervision may make him make more mistakes he didn't intend to make.
If the story stays here, if it weren't for Zemo to release the videotape of the murder of Tony's parents, then I think the story of the Fulian family is Happy Ending. Then the follow-up development of the story can only be said to be the group of superheroes who have lost all blood. The Winter Soldier paid for the behavior that was completely out of self-will during the brainwashing, the captain fought to protect his friends, and Tony was defeated by the sudden truth. The Winter Soldier was out of guilt and self-blame, the captain was out of love for his friends, and Tony was out of love for his parents.
It's really a bloody mold that has lost fate for eight lifetimes.
Finally, I have to say that the image of the Winter Soldier is really an unlucky master, young, humorous, and handsome. In the first part, he was unlucky. He was shot off the train, his arm was broken, his brain was washed, and he was shot. Transformed into the Winter Soldier. Having been tortured in Hydra for decades, he didn't even have a labor fee for lunch, so he slapped him every moment to trick him into destroying the world. After finally getting acquainted with my friend, thinking about the starting point, I bought a plum at the market incognito. I didn’t want to buy too much, so I bought six. The plums hadn't been held in their hands, and they had become wanted all over the world without seeing them. In the end, it became clear that he didn't blow up the building, he didn't kill the man, and Zemo was caught again, his arm was gone, and the man was frozen in the freezer.
The war between the super-British countries is really just like the market owes whom. Who of you will return those six plums to him first.
————————— Finally, let’s popularize the basic human settings of some MCU captains————————
1. World War II veteran, [but never blindly follow the government]
Steve Rogers was originally just a sickly individual Being tall, he can't run or beat others, and he can't beat others. There are a lot of things, and he is often beaten to find teeth because of justice. His dream is to join the army to serve for the country, and eventually he was injected with serum, became the captain of the United States, and led the roaring assault squad to fight on the battlefield of World War II.
The night before the serum injection, Steve said in a conversation with the doctor, "I don't want to kill, I just hate people who bully others." The
doctor pointed his heart to his heart and said, "Never change."
Although Captain America The name sounds very patriotic, love the party and the people, until it is boring. But in fact, Steve Rogers never blindly follows the government. When the squadron leader of "Team 1" heard that his friend and an allied army were imprisoned behind the enemy, he did not hesitate to violate the order to save people alone. In "Team 2", the SHIELD where he worked was infiltrated by Hydra, and the captain chose to become the government's wanted man to fight against.
Steve once said to Peggy Carter in "Team 2", "I used to think I could obey orders to defend my country, but now I can't."
He is not an anti-government, nor a follower. He has never changed. The only thing he listens to is his belief and his heart, "I just hate people who bully others."
2. Stubborn, [but not knowing how to work]
Tony uses his palm cannon in "American Team 3" The prospective captain said that this is an ultimatum. The captain wobbled up from the ground and said, I can do it all day. Brother Russell may be using these words to pay tribute to the captain. Seventy years ago, when he was a small five-foot man, waving a trash can cover to protect himself, he was still beaten to find teeth, but he persisted. Stand up and protect yourself.
At that time he said that, I can do it all day.
Seventy years ago, he stubbornly pressed his small body on the top of the grenade, while waving his hand to make the people around him back, clumsy and firm; seventy years later, he was stubbornly chased by the government and criticized by the public. Next, he went to Siberia to stop Zemo at a battle with his friends.
You see, how stubborn he is. Except for his own chivalry and idealism, he couldn't listen to anything.
But the captain is not a standardized Wei Guangzheng. In "Team 1", he faked an unknown number of application materials to join the army. In "Team 2", he and his widow sister stole a car while fleeing. The widow sister asked him, "Where did Captain America learn to steal a car?" He replied without red heart, "This is not stealing, I have to return it."
If he can accommodate, his posture is soft like a vine.
If he persists, he will be invincible.
3. You can sacrifice yourself, [but not willing to sacrifice the interests of a few people] In
the ending of US Team 1, the captain chose to drive the plane into the glacier and fell asleep in the glacier in order to prevent the plane from hitting the populous city. year. In the ending of US Team 2, after successfully preventing the villain’s conspiracy, in order to wake up the brainwashed friends, the captain threw the shield down the sky battleship and still attacked. For Steve Rogers, sacrificing himself has never been a problem.
But this is the captain's requirement for himself. When this requirement is extended to more people, even to all ordinary people, he is willing to trade the interests of a few people for greater interests.
In Team 2, Fury once said to the captain, "As long as we sacrifice a small number of people, we can guarantee the freedom of all six billion people." The captain replied to Fury, "This is not freedom, this is fear." Yes, because You never know whether you will become a minority. If you do not defend the interests of the minority, when you become the minority, who will defend your interests?
Steve Rogers is not afraid to sacrifice his own interests and choose not to sign the bill. The captain’s concern may be that when he loses the right to choose, who can stand up to protect the people when they need to defend him?
4. [Why is he unwilling to sign the bill? 】
If you have watched "Captain America: The First Avenger" and "Captain America: The Winter Soldier", you will find that the image of Captain America is very complete and coherent in the "Captain America" series. I am very sorry that although the captain’s personal setting in this movie named "Captain America" is still consistent with the previous one, the description of this consistency is compressed by the huge group portrait. For those who are new to the role of Captain America, they may not be able to clearly understand the wishes and original intentions of the captain from the description of the film.
As mentioned in the previous post, the government sent him to sell the national debt to dance the thigh dance out of financial interests; Fury concealed the facts of the mission from him out of the original intention of super-British management risk, and let the widow sister perform secret missions; Aegis Because the bureau was eroded by the Hydra, it targeted countless ordinary people without knowing it. If the government can be bought, S.H.I.E.L.D. can be eroded, and the people can be betrayed, then how can he believe that the UN supervision is flawless?
Governments and organizations are also made up of individuals. Everyone has weaknesses and motives. Any regulation may be linked to political, capital, and even criminal colors.
In "Team 2", when she found out that the S.H.I.E.L.D.E.L.D. for whom she was appointed was not S.H.I. The captain smiled and replied that people like you might not be suitable for this job. The widow sister said, you just learned that you had sacrificed for nothing, but you seem to be very happy. The captain said, Well, now we finally know who the opponent is.
He said to Fury, S.H.I.E.L.D., Hydra, not a single one. He never believed in the eyes of others.
What's more, the "Bill" and the United Nations regulatory organization revealed their shortcomings at the beginning of the film. The Winter Soldier was identified as the murderer of the Vienna bombing without any trial. The Red Witch was protected at the Avengers base without any trial. Chaoying, who had rescued the people, was thrown into a maritime prison without any procedures. Such "Act" and regulatory organizations are only operating in accordance with self-awareness and self-judgment.
Superheroes do need to be supervised, but must they be supervised by the government? Is the government's decision really right?
Instead of trusting the cognition and judgment of others, it is better to trust your own cognition and judgment. The captain might think so.
The same is true for Bucky. It is not that the trial is not allowed, but it cannot be lynched without trial. It's not that you can't go through procedures, but you need procedural justice. In the tunnel chase, the captain did not resist and handed Bucky to the government, making a gesture to appease the arrested Bucky. However, when the team leader asked the government staff that you would hire a lawyer for him, he only got a scornful smile.
I'm not saying that this is right, or that this is wrong, I'm saying that this is Steve Rogers's choice, he thinks this is correct, so he chose this way.
Because he is Captain America.
——————————
Of course fans have filters. I tried to explain the truth of the misinformation as neutrally as possible, and then describe a Captain America in my mind.
Steve Rogers is a man, a superhero, and Captain America. He may be too stubborn, a bit old-fashioned, most of the time he speaks without mercy, he is not perfect, nor is he a saint. But he is upright, brave, kind, and willing to give his life to protect the people.
Every superhero, every hero in the MCU world is like this.
This is what I want to say the most, you can dislike him, you can disagree with him.
But please don't abuse him with dirty language, please don't abuse any character with dirty language.
In fact, if you want to understand the MCU American team, all you need is to complete the Captain America movie series, rather than relying on other people's comments or words. Considering that Captain America only has two previous titles, it only takes one afternoon. So if you have not seen the first two movies of Captain America, if you are interested in the role of Captain America, all major video sites have genuine sources, welcome to watch!
(Some students have doubts about the sentence tony was really vested in killing bucky. Explain the source of the radio interview with the Russell brothers and Kevin Feggy. The dictation is:
Chris Hewitt: Fantastic. Okay. So now the big question is out of the way. As you know, we're going to be talking spoilers in this. I think it's very interesting where you end this movie, where you lead the characters. I think famously, Civil War, the comic book arc ends with the death of Cap. I think a few people thought that that's where you might be going with this movie. Was there ever any consideration about doing that?
Joe Russo: It just seemed like—frankly, it just seemed like an easy ending to this film, you know? We thought a more complicated ending would be ones that the characters had this very emotionally cathartic third act were Tony was really vested in killing Bucky. And Cap and he traded and put some pretty severe blows that would be more interesting to see how—what the ramifications of that would be moving forward on their relationship and killing Cap ends that conceptually. You know, suddenly there's a guilt factor in Tony's part and which we felt wasn't quite as complicated as these two characters having to deal with each other moving forward.
I briefly summarized it. The reporter asked that the end of the comic was the death of the captain. Russell replied that the ending of the captain's death was too simple, so they conceived another ending, that is, the ending of Iron Man wanting to kill Bar Hao, and the two of them fought each other. If the captain is really dead, Iron Man will feel guilty, it is better to let them progress under differences. )
View more about Captain America: Civil War reviews
