First of all, this can only be called a personal afterthought. It is basically spoilers, and comics and movies are comparing spoilers. If you really don’t want to be spoiled and want to simply enjoy the work of this movie, There is really no need to open it. "The Shape of Voice" is a comic film, the original comics have a total of 62 chapters, this time the length of the film is 127 minutes. So let's calculate, divide this time according to TV animation, it is about the progress of about 6 episodes. Since the length of each chapter of the original manga is about 20 pages, under normal circumstances, the content of the first episode of the animation can be about the progress of 3 to 4 chapters in the manga. Even with the addition and deletion, the progress of 1 episode of the anime is equivalent to the 5th chapter of the manga. This calculation also requires at least 12 episodes of animation progress, which means that it takes 4 hours to be enough. So how to delete and modify half of the original work is very important. The manga in "The Shape of the Voice" tells the story of the male protagonist Ishida Masayoshi also encounters a female protagonist Nishinomiya Glass who is born with a hearing impairment in elementary school. He is also full of rejection of this speechless girl who has suddenly transferred to another school, and then begins to bully. she. Eventually it caused the glass to transfer to another school, and Mr. Jiang went from a bully to a bullied person. Five years later, the general who wanted to make atonement for himself also learned sign language and then met the glass again. Yes, if you want to make a positioning for this work. It cannot be said that this is a romance film, because there is actually a love element in it. But the main point of the work is to convey to people the story that people should understand each other through communication. Director Yamada said before that she would delete all the plots in the original that would make people feel very depressing. This can explain why so many parts of the content can be deleted. More than half of the content of the original comics is a group of neuroses hurting each other. In the film's narrative, most of the original content is deleted. Even if some quarrel scenes are kept, they are almost just passing by, and the rhythm is very fast. Why would the actor bully a girl with a physical defect? No matter how you think about it, you can only draw the conclusion that he is a wicked bear kid. However, look at this matter from another perspective. Because of the hearing impairment of Glass, her voice is very strange when she speaks. When reading the text aloud in class, her strange voice became a laughing stock for others to laugh at her. The failure of the singing competition is also attributed to the reason why Glass is obsessed with participating in the competition (although it is true). It started... The reincarnation of heaven will harm others and ultimately harm himself. Due to the excessive behavior of Jiang, he gradually changed from a bully to a bullied person. Friends who played well with him back then are now bullies. For him, this is a very painful thing. Because of some misunderstandings, I will also see the glass wiping his desk, but because the glass is not clear, some people are instigated to beat a girl. And the glass was finally so angry that it fought with the general, and the glass in the comics was really badly beaten. A lot of cuts have been made in this section of Fighting Together, because this is a scene that will be angry no matter who watches it. But I will know later that the glass is actually wiping the table for the bullied him (the content on the table is probably some, you bully bad boy is going to die). I have always felt that this paragraph must be kept, because in this way, the difference between humanity's kindness and ugliness can be more revealed. However, Supervisor Yamada may think that this kind of gentleness and kindness has brought more damage to the glass, so the paragraph about Jiang and the whistle has also been deleted. But if you have not seen the original work, the audience will be curious and why suddenly their attitude towards the glass has changed drastically, the deepening of self-blame, the gap of misunderstanding, and the lack of such an impactful fact, even if it is for people to watch. Afterwards, the unpleasant part should be preserved. If the plain narrative structure does not have a sudden impact, the impression will certainly not be more profound. Another thing that impressed me was that the protagonist was about to save a sum of money and then wanted to commit suicide to redeem his sins. His mother knew about it. In the original work, my mother was very angry and sad. Burn the money and tell Jiang, you should do your best to make money. Anyway, if you don’t earn XXX money, you will not be considered as completing the task. If you have not completed the task, you can’t die, and then you are not careful. The money was "disposed". The word "suicide" seems to have become a common occurrence here. If this tense atmosphere is relieved by this way of laughing and passing humor, then perhaps everyone's focus will shift from suicide to other places. There are many things to cut, such as the part where Ueno and Sawara quarreled in the movie, the part where Makiya beat Maiya...Yes, most of the tearing scenes in the comics were harmonized. Because these mutual harms are inexplicable in themselves, when I saw more than 40 words in the comics, I was almost at a loss. Why do they hurt each other? I really can't feel the benefits of doing so for them. In the movie, the fight between Ueno and Mama Glass survives. Because this was also forced by the plot, everyone who watched the PV knew the scene where Glass jumped off the building. In fact, she was rescued by Jiang by accident, but Jiang was accidentally dropped into the river and unconscious. So Ueno played glass, and the part where glass's mother and Ueno had a fight was logically preserved. Speaking of the suicide of glass, I think maybe some people who haven't read the original will be a little confused. Jiang Ye obviously had already turned his back on the prodigal son, and then he finally merged into a circle with everyone. Why did he choose to commit suicide at this time? Isn't this weird? In fact, I have read the comics several times, and it is difficult to find an absolute standard answer. But my personal understanding is that a person's patience has reached the limit. When it comes to campus bullying, I can be considered to have had the same experience. People who have encountered this kind of thing when they were young generally develop in three directions. The first is to hate the world, want to avenge all those who have bullied him, and then gradually become a cynical person. The second type, because they have had the experience of being bullied, they know the pain deeply, so even if they are wounded all over, they are determined not to hurt anyone around them. The third is that because of the experience of being bullied, I always have a sad attitude towards the people and things around me. They don't believe in any feelings, they are not optimistic, and the worldly humanity only sees right and wrong, and the cognition that is related to me or has nothing to do with me. Obviously, glass belongs to the second kind of person. Because she has a profound experience of being bullied, she doesn't want to hurt anyone. Does some people think she has a little Stockholm syndrome? Why do you like a boy who was bullied so much that he wanted to commit suicide? In fact, the answer is really simple, and that is because Nishinomiya Glass, she is a good girl who is so kind that she can no longer be kind. She did not speak because of her hearing impairment since she was a child, and her sister, mother, and grandmother were treated as aliens excluded by others, and she was helpless. Jiang also had conflicts with her friends because of her own affairs, and she blamed herself. Coupled with the death of her grandmother, she was sad because she was missing a close relative who understood her. At this moment, I remembered the sentence of Teacher Jing in Chunwu, "It is always difficult for a gentle and correct person to survive, because the world is neither gentle nor correct." It was like the last straw that crushed the camel. Even if my sister took so many photos of death, she tried every means to prevent her from committing suicide, but it failed. Because she seems to have lost her motivation to live, and this time, she will also be saved. This rescue not only saved Glass's life, but also saved her heart. I want you to live, I want you to live, I will be happy if you live, and I will be happy if you are happy. So please continue to live with such a strong smile. Then speaking of the element of love, The paragraph where Ueno confessed to Jiangya was also deleted (no way, you are not the heroine) At first I wondered why this girl fell in love with the bear kid who bullied him back then? First of all, the person who bullied you when you were a child cared about your statement. I think you still have to consider the degree. Combined with the bear things that Jiang did when he was a child, this possibility should be very small. So, since when did Glass start to like the general? Maybe it was the encounter five years later. Maybe when I was a kid, I just wanted to be friends with others and didn't consider many other factors. But gradually I discovered that a boy did so much for herself (she hadn't thought about the issue of atonement at all), and at the same time, because she was also a person who had been bullied by school violence. They have the same vision. If I have encountered the bad things you have encountered, and have felt the feelings you don't want to feel, can we be closer together? (laugh) However, regarding the male protagonist, I think the one person I have to talk about is his mother. In fact, I have never been clear about whether human nature is good or evil in the first place. Things like the desire for survival, possessiveness, and sexual desire, which belong to human nature, may change from "good" to "evil" because of different positions. In the final analysis, why was Jiang Ye a bear kid when he was a child? Is it because of poor tutoring? Wrong! On the contrary, Jiang Ye's mother is also a very kind and responsible mother. When he learned that his son had caused a catastrophe and damaged millions of hearing aids, he immediately took money for compensation without saying anything, and then kept apologizing. Looking at such a gentle and kind-hearted person who grew up, isn't his nature evil? Certainly not! So why should he bully a disabled girl so much. Because of heresy, the whole Japanese society, I have never understood one thing, that is, you must remain the same as the public. If you are special, you may be targeted. As for what you will encounter after being targeted, that is determined by your abilities. Obviously, after experiencing his own experience of being bullied, he understood the harm he had done to Glass before, and he had considered apology with death, insisting that he was a great evil person. , This is also a bit far-fetched. After meeting with Glass again, he decided to make atonement. However, without knowing it, he was also saved by Glass. The final content of the movie is not in the comics, where two people walk hand in hand to the venue of the coming-of-age ceremony. Instead, he put down his hands and began to listen carefully to the voice of every face around him, the face that was originally painted with × and then disappeared. In other words, he finally walked out of the gloom and began to face life seriously. People should understand and be considerate of each other through heart-to-heart communication. People who are gentle, correct, and kind-hearted may indeed find it difficult to survive, but this does not become a reason for them not being gentle, not correct, or kind. Perhaps it is precisely because of this that they appear to be so great and noble. As Romain Roland said, “the only true heroism in the world is to recognize the essence of life and still love life.” Voice is a double-edged sword that can bring happiness to others and harm to others. . These are unavoidable! However, through heart-to-heart communication and friendly delivery of your truest thoughts, everyone will surely usher in the day of mutual understanding. This is what Mr. Yamada wants to pass on to us. As a comic change, because the big frame has been fixed, and the status of the work is relatively niche. Unlike original creation, which can suddenly give you a divine turn, "The Shape of Sound" can only be regarded as a good masterpiece. The limitation of space is always the biggest problem, and it cannot be regarded as a divine work. If it is said that even if this work is made into a season, the effect may be better than the theater version. After watching the whole movie, the people around me were laughing, and the sensational place would not cry like a tearful person. But what I have to say is-Hayami Saori is really great! I don't think she can be faulty about her dubbing ability. The sounds that people can understand but are not very clear have really restored those hearing-impaired speech sounds infinitely. Then I don’t know why the presence of bread is too high, freedom is also very hard! It's worthy of being the blue man of Cheng Ge Amway! In addition, Mizuho Bank probably spent a lot of money this time. The name in the movie simply doesn't need to play neta. Because the box office performance of "Your Name" is so good, some people are worried about whether the box office of "The Shape of Voice" will be affected. Actually, the good or bad of a work cannot be explained by the box office alone. But works with high box office are not necessarily excellent works, can't those with low box office be good works? The box office of "Tamako Love Story" is not high, but it is also an excellent work. It is inevitable to compare with other works, but emotions are only subjective after all. You may not think good when others feel good. If you are the same, others may not agree with you if you think good. But what do you want to do? Just go and enjoy the works you like. When your heart already agrees with it, you don't need to force Amway to those around you. Do not do to others what you don't want, do to others as you like. Don't cause all sorts of torn consequences because of things that should have been happy. Isn't the gain more than the loss? Finally, I hope people in this world can understand each other more and hurt each other less. Because the box office performance of "Your Name" is so good, some people are worried about whether the box office of "The Shape of Voice" will be affected. Actually, the good or bad of a work cannot be explained by the box office alone. But works with high box office are not necessarily excellent works, can't those with low box office be good works? The box office of "Tamako Love Story" is not high, but it is also an excellent work. It is inevitable to compare with other works, but emotions are only subjective after all. You may not think good when others feel good. If you are the same, others may not agree with you if you think good. But what do you want to do? Just go and enjoy the works you like. When your heart already agrees with it, you don't need to force Amway to those around you. Do not do to others what you don't want, do to others as you like. Don't cause all sorts of torn consequences because of things that should have been happy. Isn't the gain more than the loss? Finally, I hope people in this world can understand each other more and hurt each other less. Because the box office performance of "Your Name" is so good, some people are worried about whether the box office of "The Shape of Voice" will be affected. Actually, the good or bad of a work cannot be explained by the box office alone. But works with high box office are not necessarily excellent works, can't those with low box office be good works? The box office of "Tamako Love Story" is not high, but it is also an excellent work. It is inevitable to compare with other works, but emotions are only subjective after all. You may not think good when others feel good. If you are the same, others may not agree with you if you think good. But what do you want to do? Just go and enjoy the works you like. When your heart already agrees with it, you don't need to force Amway to those around you. Do not do to others what you don't want, do to others as you like. Don't cause all sorts of torn consequences because of things that should have been happy. Isn't the gain more than the loss? Finally, I hope people in this world can understand each other more and hurt each other less.
View more about A Silent Voice: The Movie reviews
