The scene is very exciting, some places are illogical

Abby 2021-12-13 08:01:04

The scene of the war is okay, but it feels illogical in some places.

The s33 submarine was sunk by a German battleship, and it seemed to be finished at once. When hitting u571, it was close at hand but unable to sink.

The s33 submarine was camouflaged, so how did the battleship recognize it from a long distance?

After the s33 submarine was sunk, the German submarine that came with the German battleship continued to attack the u571. Why did it do this? Does it know that u571 was hijacked? How did it know that u571 was hijacked?

Since the German reinforcement submarine knew that u571 was hijacked, why didn't the German battleship know? After u571 surfaced, there was no alert at all?

When a battleship is hit by a torpedo until it sinks, it should take a while. Part of the German crew should be able to escape. The torpedo in the movie destroys the battleship all at once.

View more about U-571 reviews

Extended Reading
  • Kathryne 2021-12-13 08:01:04

    Nearly halfway through the film, the sudden sinking of Mei Qian, pretending to be an enemy army, by a German torpedo is a shocking accident, but it seems reasonable. The cost is so tragic, it not only reflects the cruelty of the war, but also reflects the leftist philosophy: there is no perfect victory in which everything is under my control. But after the survivors return to U571, the plot will turn right to McConaughey’s personal show. Your luck and the strength of the Germans will also match up with each other? …It’s not that the plot cannot change with time and the theme cannot change from left to right, but the gap between the front and rear parts is too large. From the absolute accidental cost to the full control of my hands, it is imposed in order to underpin the protagonist’s rising star. The feeling is not very useful.

  • Oceane 2022-03-26 09:01:06

    "Greyhound" is a destroyer's perspective. This is a submarine's perspective. It is interesting to compare. Those who are interested can mix and edit a "Tom Hanks Sea Battle Matthew McConaughey". The problem of this is the problem of the anti-German drama. ,too fake

U-571 quotes

  • Chief Klough: Well, Mister Tyler, if you ever need a chief, I'll go to sea with you anytime.

  • Chief Klough: What the hell are those yardbirds doing to my boat?