【2021-mv18】- Shout and Whisper

Ellen 2022-04-22 07:01:45

Very nostalgic movie, but it gave me a strong feeling. The apparent calmness is actually covering up those rotten souls. The film is silent most of the time, and the impact of red, white and black brings a strong sense of emptiness.

Those anxious, distressed desires are large swaths of red. It's like seeing faces covered in red at the end of every scene. Like Maria, she has no self-consciousness, and she can only see her own lust and greed from the sharp words of the doctor and Karin. The white robe and the white bed curtain are the same pale face of Agnes and her inner world. Black leads to the darkness and subtlety of human nature. It is also Karin's disgust and discovery of herself.

The collision of the three colors turned into a gloomy and cold black after Agnes passed away, just like them.

The only one who comes close to divinity is Anna. Her plump body hides the purest tenderness. She neither shouts nor whispers, because there is neither the hypocrisy and fear in the shouting, nor the selfishness and coldness in the drizzle.

The most trembling thing in the whole film is the picture of Anna holding Agnes naked at the end, which perfectly reproduces the image of the Virgin Mary, so gentle and compassionate.

The pain, repression, relief, introspection, and holiness in the film are intertwined and shocking. The manor filled with morning mist, such a picture is still rippling like a swing that day.

View more about Cries & Whispers reviews

Extended Reading
  • Andre 2022-03-28 09:01:08

    If it were Bergman to write [Three Sisters], it would look like [Shouting and Whispering]. This incomparable masterpiece has such a pessimistic view of life, that happiness cannot be increased for a moment, and that loneliness and lies, pain and suffering are eternal. Every character lives a double life, a world they hoped for that no one could ever bring to reality, no matter their whispers or cries. Bergman responded with a pitying glance at this loneliness.

  • Alia 2022-03-14 14:12:26

    Viewing experience: The big string is noisy like rain, and the small string is like whispers. Noisy cut the miscellaneous bullets, the big beads and the small beads fall on the jade plate. Jian Guan Yingyu has a slippery bottom, and it's hard to get under the flowing ice of Youyanquan. Bingquan's cold and stringy strings are condensed, and Ning is absolutely silent for a while. Don't be sad and hateful, silence is better than sound at this time. Nothing like shouting and whispering.

Cries & Whispers quotes

  • Maria: I have no need of pardon.

  • Karin: Anna. You hear that?

    Anna: I hear only the wind and the ticking of the clocks.

    Karin: No. It's something else.

    Anna: I don't hear anything else.

    Karin: I'm freezing. Good night.