The ending makes the movie unreasonable

Edyth 2022-04-21 09:02:59

After watching the ending of the movie, I always feel that the ending makes the movie fake, like a high school writing essay forcing a noble theme to be a good essay. Let me talk about my unreasonable doubts about the ending of the movie, and I hope someone can explain it.

1. First of all, the whole film is showing how secret the identity of Erica 's agent is, and even leaking the secret is treason, but it was leaked from the mouth of the 3- or 4-year-old daughter? Doesn't an agent know that it's impossible to keep a child a secret? He deliberately told his daughter that he was a special agent, so that he could make her proud? If it was unintentionally leaked, then she is also responsible for lax confidentiality

2. The heroine's choice seems to be deliberately to make herself look noble and great. First of all, before publishing the report, she must have expected how much harm it would bring to the family of the little girl who revealed her mother's identity as a secret agent. Reporting in Erika 's real identity, shouldn't the focus of this report be to expose the government's shady side? How did it later become a damage to Erica? So look at the end, the heroine seems to stick to the principle to protect the little girl, but the culprit who caused the little girl's harm is herself

3. Since her source of information is Erica 's daughter, why did the heroine take a hostile attitude with Erica in the first place? The child is innocent and incapable of judgment, but if Rachel privately told the truth to the child's guardian Erica (Anyway, Erica was also responsible for leaking her identity to her daughter, so let her shared commitment is also reasonable), can a better solution be found? And the final ending seems to be to highlight the sublime and greatness of the heroine. Erica killed, the two families were broken, and the two young children lost their mothers. Obviously there can be a better plan, it seems that for the theme of the composition, it is forced to choose the worst way.

That's where the ending makes the whole movie feel unreal, unreasonable for a moment. I don't know if other people have such doubts?

View more about Nothing But the Truth reviews

Extended Reading

Nothing But the Truth quotes

  • Ray Armstrong: [staring at his wife's new story] You made the top page!

  • Alan Burnside: [In front of the Supreme Court] In 1972 in Branzburg v. Hayes this Court ruled against the right of reporters to withhold the names of their sources before a grand jury, and it gave the power to the Government to imprison those reporters who did. It was a 5-4 decision, close. In his dissent in Branzburg, Justice Stewart said, 'As the years pass, power of Government becomes more and more pervasive. Those in power,' he said, 'whatever their politics, want only to perpetuate it, and the people are the victims.' Well, the years have passed, and that power is pervasive. Mrs. Armstrong could have buckled to the demands of the Government; she could've abandoned her promise of confidentiality; she could've simply gone home to her family. But to do so, would mean that no source would ever speak to her again, and no source would ever speak to her newspaper again. And then tomorrow when we lock up journalists from other newspapers we'll make those publications irrelevant as well, and thus we'll make the First Amendment irrelevant. And then how will we know if a President has covered up crimes or if an army officer has condoned torture? We as a nation will no longer be able to hold those in power accountable to those whom they have power over. And what then is the nature of Government when it has no fear of accountability? We should shudder at the thought. Imprisoning journalists? That's for other countries; that's for countries who fear their citizens - not countries that cherish and protect them. Some time ago, I began to feel the personal, human pressure on Rachel Armstrong and I told her that I was there to represent her and not her principle. And it was not until I met her that I realized that with great people there's no difference between principle and the person.