There are no permanent friends and no permanent enemies

Rodolfo 2022-04-19 09:02:19

It is hard to imagine that Churchill and Britain, which was fighting against the Nazis, could oppress and bully the Irish so brutally at the same time. The reality is so complex that a person can be both a hero and a demon, and a nation can be both a rebel and an oppressor. The most cruel thing is not the persecution of the invaders, but the betrayal of the same clan and the separation of the companions. The whole film is cruel, real and conflicted, and the two scenes are wonderful: one is Damien's execution of Chris; the other is his brother's execution of Damian. History seemed to repeat itself when the army of the Irish Provisional Government searched Sina's hamlet, the former rebels became today's oppressors, when Sina's grandmother said: "We used to hide you here and feed you Yes, take care of you" how ironic and bleak. There are many good films about war, most of them focus on heroic deeds or glorious humanity in war, but this film shows how the war is won, and how the victory divides and disintegrates the former heroes, so that the partners who were born and died have become life and death. enemy. War movies based on this theme are more profound and realistic. The Irish military anthem played again at the end of the film means a long time.

View more about The Wind that Shakes the Barley reviews

Extended Reading
  • Cora 2022-04-23 07:02:53

    The foggy picture, revolutionary romanticism and cruelty at the same time. Although the filming is very plain, it has the taste of independent revolution too. Almost every scene has full kinetic energy, and the emotional rendering is extremely in place.

  • Carter 2022-03-24 09:02:24

    Think Land and Freedom. We must be overwhelmed by the complexity and brutality of politics. However, the film portrays the British army in such a bad way that it makes one wonder whether it is colonial rule or the lack of freedom under brutal rule that they cannot bear. Some people say that the compromise is just a change of the ruler's accent and flag colors, but are you sure that the result of the struggle is not just a change of the ruler's accent and flag colors?

The Wind that Shakes the Barley quotes

  • Damien: It's easy to know what you are against, but quite another to know what you are for.

  • Finbar: [the IRA have just gunned down several Black and Tans] Mercenaries! That were paid to come over here to make us crawl, and to wipe us out. We've just sent a message to the British cabinet that will echo and reverbarate around the world! If they bring their savagery over here, we will meet it with a savagery of our own!