A short reply, right when my comment

Nyasia 2022-04-21 09:02:49

As for mainstream commercial films, the ideological task is clear, and it has to reconcile various mainstream values ​​and various political unconsciousness.

Some comments refer to feminist national narrative psychoanalysis of body politics. But at this time, it is impossible and unnecessary for you to ask Zhang Yimou to rely on Dai Jinhua. You don't need to push too hard. The New York Times film review, always pretending to be intellectuals, said that this film is not as good as "Nanjing Nanjing"; the implication is that Lu Chuan is more profound. I can't help thinking that Dai Jinhua came to give a lecture in New York at the beginning of the year and criticized Lu Chuan's "South", believing that the small humanitarian sentiments of the middle class easily catered to the mainstream Western morality. The New York Times thinks that Zhang Yimou didn't choose his position/perspective, but I think Zhang just wanted to be comprehensive and not offend anyone, so he didn't have a choice. We Chinese people/audiences do not have a political consensus on values, so our directors will naturally remain ambiguous. The ambiguity is round and meticulous, good-looking, and it is enough to have a catharsis effect. Good.

View more about The Flowers of War reviews

Extended Reading
  • Tobin 2021-12-25 08:01:29

    Angry, sad, depressed, sad, this is how I feel when I watch this movie

  • Jaron 2021-12-25 08:01:29

    The entry point is very small, which is really rare for Zhang Yimou. Before I watched the movie, I thought it was "Nanjing Nanjing" + "Assembly Number". After watching the movie, I had to praise this as China's "Pianist" + "Schindler's List". The thirteen hairpins said that "businessmen don't know the hatred of subjugation of the country, and they still sing the backyard flowers across the river", and they were full of emotion. The Nanjing story with a new perspective can be said to be Zhang Yimou's best work since "Hero".

The Flowers of War quotes

  • Yu Mo: Maybe with your help, I can save them.