Life is individual, but identity is made up of "the collection of others"

Manuel 2022-04-19 09:02:30

Eileen Chang has a saying, to the effect that the deceased relatives will accompany you all your life, and die again when you die. These words are like the wisp of grandpa's cigarette smoked by Billi half-awake. They are the phantoms and representations of deceased relatives in everyone's dreams... These fragments of others constitute "I" and "I"'s perception of "I".

This film is definitely not about life education, it is more like the director's homeland complex, a journey to find his roots, intimacy, the collision of Eastern and Western cultures, and his identity as a Chinese... But what touched me the most was the reaction to the death of a loved one . When my grandmother died, my parents did the same thing as Billi's parents. They told me after the fact that I was about to take the high school entrance examination, and only met at the funeral home for the last time.

I can't say this is right or wrong. After all, I didn't visit her often when she was hospitalized. How meaningful is it to see her for the last time. But if you don't visit her, it's not that you don't love her, it's more that you don't know how to face it, how to face a person you love, who makes up your life, and who occupies your memories, is about to leave forever... I walked downstairs to my grandparents' house, "They won't be here either"...In fact, "don't tell her" is not because you are worried that "she" can't face it, but we, our relatives, don't know how to face it, how to face the fragments of life that make up us, which will be forever incomplete.

After all, no one ever taught us how to face death, adults only told you to "live"...

Coming back to this film, I don't think the director doesn't understand China, let alone what "black" China is. Her emotional expression is indeed not that Chinese, unlike a very Chinese person who talks about Chinese affairs, and some stand on the sidelines. The feeling of thinking and asking questions. But in her eyes, these things are really happening in China's daily life. Maybe some exaggeration and interpretation, but this is not a documentary. Everyone has a "real China" in their hearts. Why do we think that a Chinese is trying to Is it "fake" in the eyes of Chinese Americans who seek self-recognition in their homeland? Otherwise, how do you shoot so that it is not "black"? Do you shoot like that in Xiao Shi? Everyone lives in urban high-rises and spends a lot of money. Are parents short-lived without firewood, rice, oil and salt?

View more about The Farewell reviews

Extended Reading
  • Mackenzie 2022-03-26 09:01:09

    Garbage... Sitting in a movie theater full of white people, hearing all kinds of strange laughter, I really want to beat the director, you don't like the Chinese culture so much, so don't use the Chinese as a tool to make money Well... Chinese people have no status, probably because you people only try to please white people by stepping on Chinese people... The plot is really embarrassing... Your family is like that doesn't mean Chinese people are so good, I have seen many rich people just want their children After reading the book, go back to China to inherit the family property and don't want your children to go to places you can't see... And when I compare a world-class city like New York with Changchun, I also say that the American passport has a sense of superiority... I really don't know Westerners What do you think, director, why don't you compare Beishangguang with any large rural city in the United States... This is probably a story that only the older generation will experience, and it is a bit out of time now... The theme is good, but the script is really written Bad...don't say anything, just look at Ang Lee.

  • Roselyn 2021-12-28 08:02:14

    #2019圣丹斯# 4.5 Very humane. The director's perspective is very cordial and sincere, and his inspection of life details and cultural differences is no less than that of Li Ang back then. Some of the over-comedy processing is slightly distorted, but the overall sense of reality and imagery of the lens is very good, very pungent. Showcasing the style of small cities in China, which is very timid and not deliberately slanderous, makes people really like it. The soundtrack uses western style but is not blunt. Awkwafina's Chinese acting skills did not slow down either. Sundance is currently the biggest surprise this year.

The Farewell quotes

  • Billi: [frustrated] Are you going to tell Nai Nai?

    Haiyan: I can't, Billi. I won't go against my family.

    Uncle Haibin: Billi, there are things you misunderstand. You guys moved to the West long ago. You think one's life belongs to oneself. But that's the difference between the East and the West. In the East, a person's life is part of a whole. Family. Society.

    Uncle Haibin: You want to tell Nai Nai the truth, because you're afraid to take the responsibility for her. Because it's too big of a burden. If you tell her, then you don't have to feel guilty. We're not telling Nai Nai because it's our duty to carry this emotional burden for her.

  • Jian: You're broke again? Are you always going to live like this?

    Billi: Poor but sexy? I hope so!