Does the Ending Detective's compromise make sense?

Keith 2022-04-20 09:01:49

It was probably a cultural issue. The reasoning part was vague. I didn't understand the passengers' surnames, Christian names, middle names, etc. until the end.

In the plot part, the detective finally decided to let the 12 people go according to the simple plot, which surprised me.

I have always felt that the murderer has no right to enforce the law, even if the crime is monstrous. Judicial punishment of criminals is justice, and individual punishments are private fights.

But seeing the final conclusion of the detective here, the 12 innocent and upright victims were spared. I think the idea of ​​blindly opposing the execution of lynchings is also debatable?

I have always opposed the victim punishing the murderer, simply because it is difficult for the victim to sentence the murderer from an objective point of view.

But if the victim can reasonably sentence the murderer, is it possible to skip the judicial step in some very special cases?

For example, in this case, the murderer deserves the death penalty, skipping the judicial process and punishing it by 12 stakeholders, which I think is reasonable.

View more about Murder on the Orient Express reviews

Extended Reading
  • Jamil 2022-03-25 09:01:10

    Even with so many details cut out from Granny's book, the adapted movie still feels too complicated. But I think this level of adaptation is really successful. In addition to the old drama bones, the scene where the train starts and returns to the "civilized world" after the snow is finally cleared is also amazing.

  • Luciano 2022-03-26 09:01:07

    I really missed this most classic Poirot series. When I watched it for the first time, the translation was super bad, which affected the mood of watching; when I watched the Mandarin version later, because the previous ones were dubbed by the above translation, it was inevitable. I have to compare it in my heart, what is the result, no need to say more, right?

Murder on the Orient Express quotes

  • Dr. Constantine: [touches the back of Beddoes head] Yes, there is an old contusion.

    Beddoes: The result of a slight fracas in the mess, sir, with regard to the quality of the pudding, known as spotted dick.

    Hercule Poirot: Thank you. I think you've been spotted too!

  • Hercule Poirot: Ladies and gentlemen, we now come to my own reconstruction of the night of the murder - or, the night of the red herrings.