A film that asks "what is war?"

Jaquelin 2022-04-20 09:01:47

The film raises the question "what is war", but does not give us the answer.
In the film, the protagonist group of 6 talks to some veterans about this problem, and everyone's answers are vague.
For Paul, they are really young, and they only had a fantasy and a passion for the war at the beginning, and they came to the battlefield for romance. Their thinking is not yet mature, so their concept of war is also very vague. They were inspired by their teachers to come to the battlefield. They are "in this mountain, and the clouds are deep and do not know where to go".
For Carter and the others, they have been baptized by several battles, and they are old horses who know their way, but they don't know why they want to fight. Even the veterans said something like this: "When the war begins one day, let the kings and ministers of the two countries go to one place. Both sides wear the same clothes and pick up sticks. Whoever wins the war will win." It's ironic that they use the mind of a child to explain war.
There are a thousand Hamlets in the eyes of a thousand people, there is no right or wrong, only the distance from the truth. The same goes for the question of why wars are fought. Some people say it's patriotism, some people say it's uncomfortable to see each other, some people say it's impulsive, and some people say it's to experience war. However, I have such a question: "Why do you kill your fellow-people for various reasons?"
After returning to his hometown, Paul returned to the original classroom and saw that his teacher was encouraging students to join the war again. . Paul speaks out about the cruelty of war, but gets an angry answer. Paul said to the teacher, "You don't understand war!"
I think his implication is that for those who have not participated in war, they will not understand what war is! But Paul didn't even know why he wanted to fight, why he wanted to fight!
For most people, it's not clear what war is until the end of the movie. For example, it is difficult for us to say clearly what people live for.

View more about All Quiet on the Western Front reviews

Extended Reading
  • Deon 2022-01-03 08:01:12

    When I watched the first half, I didn’t figure out who the protagonist was (not the one in the movie poster), but I only found out that it was Paul in the second half. I watched "Blood Battle at Hacksaw Ridge" last year and "No War on the Western Front" today. They are all anti-war themes. The actor of "West" is not as special as "Blood". He is passionate and ignorant. After going to the battlefield, there is a shortage of food, poor accommodation conditions, cannonballs flying, and his life is like grass. There is no blood splatter effect, so the shock is less powerful. At the end, Paul returned to his hometown for vacation. He was already disheartened by the war, but the old men in his hometown were still talking about the war, and the old teachers were still agitating the students. On the battlefield, the chilling Paul returned to the battlefield. He stretched out his hand to catch a butterfly while hiding in the trenches, but was killed by the enemy. This ending was somewhat absurd and poetic. Although Westerners have always been militants, at least they still have people who can make these anti-war films, these films that expose the ridiculous and cruelty of war, but our war films still always tout the heroes of the battlefield and put the war on The depiction is both great and tragic. Sad!

  • Brain 2022-01-03 08:01:12

    After the seemingly "fuck" in the first twenty minutes, the scenes of the war are in good condition. The long shots of the war scenes are real and beautiful, and the delicate performance of the friendship of comrades in the war. The second half extends into the anti-war theme. The idiot in the tavern makes the protagonist and the audience together. I feel chilly, the ending is tragic, but I have to admit that it was a classic, but unfortunately the transition editing of the whole film made me straightforward, so it is a small regret in terms of the degree of completion of the whole film.

All Quiet on the Western Front quotes

  • Paul Bäumer: We live in the trenches out there. We fight. We try not to be killed, but sometimes we are. That's all.

  • [last lines]

    Second orderly: Your deal. Get his name and number?

    Medic Orderly: Yeah. Corporal Stanislaus Katczinsky, 306.