Maybe I knew I would be scolded for writing this title, but let me analyze this movie from a fair and objective point of view, and first state that I am sure that this movie is not as useless as others say.
First, let’s talk about why the polarization is serious. There are several reasons: 1. Half an hour was cut when the mainland was released, which caused the characters’ emotions to be inconsistent. 2. The ending was reconciled. Movie 4 The heroine is both shaking m and the Virgin
The above points can probably be used to summarize why the bad reviews are serious. Let’s talk about the first point first. In fact, the first point and the fourth point are related. In the full version, the male protagonist and the female protagonist fought. The heroine's true feelings are revealed, so the image of her Virgin can only be said to be incomplete.
Then I will talk about why I reconciled because just imagine if Ishida did his best to atone for his sins and he was isolated, then if there are people who feel the same way, they will also hope that they will reconcile, and in the full version Ishida once reminded Nishinomiya to be smart Otherwise, they will be isolated, and many people don't understand the real reason why Nishinomiya was bullied. In the original comics, it was said that it was because Nishinomiya's "trouble" 1. The teacher was afraid of trouble, so Ueno took Nishinomiya to learn 2. You can only use a notebook to speak. Come to write 3 sign language teachers to let everyone learn sign language, but Ueno saw Nishinomiya's hearing aids and felt that he was being played. And the reason why it evolved into bullying is also a foreshadowing. Ueno also told the head teacher that he didn't want to care, but the head teacher did not agree, and Nishinomiya had a hearing aid but let everyone learn sign language for her, but at the beginning, Ueno was not too much. At most, he just didn't get along with Nishinomiya. Speaking, it was because Nishinomiya stalked them that they were bullying. Of course, I am not blaming Nishinomiya, just saying that whether it is a teacher who doesn't care about things, or an indifferent classmate is an indispensable part of the tragedy.
And then that's why Nishinomiya felt that it was his fault when he was bullied. This point of view is the usual trick of many black fans, and they all scold the director for this. I can only say that it is really unnecessary. Just imagine if you have a disease and cannot be cured, your ears will gradually degenerate, how your parents divorced or even no one wants to regroup with your family, your mother changed from laughing to a cold person, and then you were bullied by your classmates because of your health. Tell your mother that you will not be bullied if you cut your hair like a boy, so your sister cut your hair for you and even be treated as a boy, and because of physical reasons, my sister dropped out of school to take care of you, and always photographed animals The corpse is because you are afraid that you will not want to commit suicide. Grandma is retired or looking for odd jobs. Everyone is working hard for you and the boy who bullied you in elementary school wants to be your friend. You actually never blamed him for growing up. You see everything your family does for you and you think it's your own fault. After you become friends, you see the boy being scolded for being friends with the bully, and then you start to think it's your fault, even the guy The child would rather accompany you not to reconcile with other people, making you feel that he and his sister dropped out of school and photographing corpses are of the same nature, and the thought of self-blame swept through the whole body, and finally thought of suicide. So I'm asking you again why you can't have suicidal thoughts in such an environment.
Another point that many people have overlooked is the dividing line of bullying. In fact, bullying in China is different from that in Japan. I will give you an example and you will understand. Bullying in China means that you will be scolded or bullied by everyone. I should play with you or play with you, but Japan is different. Once you are bullied or gossip, those bystanders will avoid you like a disaster, so everyone should analyze rationally in different situations.
And then why should we make movies from the perspective of the bully? We can't think about it with conventional thinking, because you think if you shoot with the victim's mind, how can you make atonement? And shooting from the victim's point of view has a particularly big drawback, that is, do you focus on being bullied or how you accept redemption? Of course, aside from the limitations of anime movies, I don't think that movies can't be made from the perspective of victims, so everyone makes a rational analysis.
Why is the ending a family fun? From an objective point of view, the ending of the family fun is not so happy. It is understandable for the male protagonist to be forgiven, but I don’t think it is so easy to forgive a character like Kawai. It hurts that the character Kawai is really disgusting without reading the original book, and there are those classmates who used to bully Nishinomiya together, but even the explanation given by the original book is that Kawai has not apologized but has been using actions to change himself. But from the perspective of a bystander, I really don't want Kawai to be forgiven, and the final insight actually made Kawai come to tell Nishinomiya that this is forcibly whitewashing, of course, the original works of Huang Mao and Fatty when I was a child also have a little bit of drama. The two of them saved, but Nishinomiya didn't tell Ishida, because they felt guilty, so they didn't ask for peace. I don't think they have to forgive, but they can do it.
In general, this movie is still very good. Except for the ending of forcing everyone to whitewash for commercial elements, there is nothing wrong with it. As for some people saying that hearing aids are expensive, I just want to say that this is an anime and is disabled in Japan. People can enjoy half price of disabled aids. Although I don’t agree with Nishinomiya concealing the damage of hearing aids, we don’t need to deduct details so much. I should watch the thought behind the movie. So don't be black for black's sake. Like me, you can objectively analyze the advantages and disadvantages. For example, Ueno's use of villains to promote and forcibly whitewash the plot is also a flaw in this movie. After all, you will find Ueno's The character design has completely collapsed, so the regret of this movie is the length. The director wants to express too much, so there is no way to take it all into account, but this still does not prevent it from being a phenomenal excellent movie.
View more about A Silent Voice: The Movie reviews
