Missionary endings are intolerable

Lola 2022-04-22 07:01:33

The crazy, neurotic, self-sacrificing heroine is really appealing, a genre that fits my aesthetic, but the ending really ruins half of it.

Maybe it's my own preference. Why use God's apparition to explain everything in the end, and even give it a concrete representation. It seems too low.

If you are in a state where you don't know if the heroine is crazy or if everything is really a miracle, there will be more room for people to ponder, and the tragedy of the whole story will be more prominent. On the contrary, if everything is based on the existence of God, it becomes a cheap religious redemption film that has nothing to do with the tragedy of the characters.

Faith or madness, sometimes it is a very difficult question to answer, why do you have to answer it, director? The best directors ask questions without answering them.

With such an abrupt ending, painted with a false golden warm color, the main theme of the whole film is that only sad people persist in their beliefs, no matter how stupid or unbelievable they are, they have done all kinds of things, and finally moved God to get a good result. , WTF, no sense of responsibility at all. So if my man is smashed into a vegetative state and I'm not paranoid begging God for mercy like a madman, is it that I'm not doing enough? ? This kind of behavior is obviously pathetic, but it is actually praised and encouraged at the end? If it was this belief that saved her man, it would be better to say that this belief destroyed her. Wrapped in the praise of selfless devotion is the contempt for human concern. Finally, the feeling of hearing the holy church bells is different from the feeling of frantically lighting wax and singing praises for the sacrificed firefighters and soldiers when you see countless major disasters in your country. No difference. This missionary feeling makes me sick.

Her ignorance has become piety, her madness has become faith, her tragedy has become earth-shattering sacrifice, and everything is justified. I cannot tolerate this kind of value.

View more about Breaking the Waves reviews

Extended Reading
  • Abelardo 2022-01-02 08:01:35

    I can't stand it when I see half of it, I really hate Emily Watson

  • Lukas 2022-03-27 09:01:10

    This trilogy by the Danish director actually makes me regret watching it. . . The heroines are all a little neurotic, and then a bizarre to paranoid idea pushes them to do what leads to the final tragedy. . . But even if Bess's husband survives and can walk, and Selma's son can heal his eyes, what's the point of losing them? The director has been talking about a kind of perverted female sacrifice. . .

Breaking the Waves quotes

  • Bess McNeill: [as God] Bess McNeill, for many years you've prayed for love. Shall I take it away from you again, is that what you want?

    Bess McNeill: Oh, no. I'm still grateful for love.

    Bess McNeill: [as God] What do you want, then?

    Bess McNeill: I pray for Jan to come home.

    Bess McNeill: [as God, in an impatient voice] He will be coming home in ten days. You must learn to endure, you know that.

    Bess McNeill: I can't wait.

    Bess McNeill: [as God] This is unlike you, Bess. Out there, there are people who need Jan and his work. What about them?

    Bess McNeill: They don't matter. Nothing else matters. I just want Jan home again. I pray to you, oh please. Won't you send him home?

    Bess McNeill: [as God] Are you sure that's what you want?

    Bess McNeill: Yes.

  • Bess McNeill: Have you taken my calendar?

    Dodo McNeill: What? No I have not. What would I want with your calendar?

    Bess McNeill: You've taken it.

    Dodo McNeill: I have not taken it.

    Bess McNeill: Yes you have.

    Dodo McNeill: I don't know what you're talking about. What calendar?

    Bess McNeill: Where is it?

    Dodo McNeill: [returns to the room with Bess's calendar] Bess, you have to stop all this, you know. I mean you've got to go on living when he's not here. I mean he's not dead. You're not dead.

    Bess McNeill: Give it to me.

    Dodo McNeill: You've got to stop it.

    [Bess rearranges the ripped up calendar, staring at the words "I love Jan" on the corner]