Religion is not enough, emotion is the real magic

Mattie 2022-04-19 09:02:26

In this film, only Stanley is the protagonist, and the other main characters can be regarded as a specific symbol.
I saw the conflict between two sets of forces within Stanley. The first group is the conflict between reason and religion: from Stanley's disdain for religion, to the gradual disintegration of his faith by Sufi's lifelike tricks, to the moment when his aunt was saved by a doctor rather than God. Reaffirmed his original belief; the second group is the confrontation between reason and emotion: Stanley's love for his fiancée is completely a love of reason and reason. (Fiancée is synonymous with rationality at its best, as evidenced by the fact that she feels "disappointment" rather than "sadness" about the breakup—she finds Stanley's knowledge and intellect to make the decision absurd. ) is like the transition from admiring a person's talent, to having the person, which is as practical as owning a fortune, to this steadfastness to reason in his later attempt to debunk Sufi spiritism He was gradually shaken by the mystery that shocked him and couldn't explain it, and it was because of this that he gradually turned his attention to Sophie herself instead of her psychic skills. In the end, although he exposed Sophie's Deception, but his concept of feelings has also been changed by this wonderful journey - he no longer uses reason to measure love, but begins to believe in his own feelings.
These two sets of conflicts are like two horses in a race, and are the driving force behind the development of the entire film. In the beginning, reason and religion competed, the former won, but ultimately lost to emotion. Religion and emotion are two similar things, because they both carry some kind of unexplainable mystery, but religious issues have been falsified by modern technology, but emotions are always unclear. After all, the experience of the heart is difficult to quantify. But maybe this is what humanity is working towards? Or it has already started.

View more about Magic in the Moonlight reviews

Extended Reading

Magic in the Moonlight quotes

  • Stanley: The comparison makes me laugh! Olivia is a person of accomplishment and charm. Sophie's a street finagler who makes her way living off one bit of hokum to the next.

    Aunt Vanessa: Well, I don't see how you can compare the two.

    Stanley: Well, don't put ideas into my head!

    Aunt Vanessa: Well, far be it from me!

    Stanley: Of course, she does come from dire circumstances. I mean, it's very easy to be judgmental about people who are born into circumstances less fortunate than one's own.

    Aunt Vanessa: Well, life is harsh. One must do what one must to survive.

    Stanley: Well put. And people do sometimes make the wrong choices, which they regret, even though no serious harm was done.

    Aunt Vanessa: Which of us has not made some blunders in life?

    Stanley: And there is a rather appealing quality about Sophie. Despite her disgusting behaviour.

    Aunt Vanessa: Yes, her smile is rather winning. Of course, it depends how much value you put on the purely physical.

    Stanley: Well, no, I... I, for one, esteem the higher virtues.

    Aunt Vanessa: Hmm... Beauty of the soul...

    Stanley: Although her eyes are rather pleasant to look into. And that she can be amusing, under the right circumstances.

    Aunt Vanessa: Oh, but Olivia is an educated, cultivated woman. One that befits a man of your artistic genius.

    Stanley: Yes, now, my genius must be factored in. On paper, there's really no reason to prefer Sophie to Olivia.

    Aunt Vanessa: Well, I would say the opposite.

    Stanley: ...And so your, your suggestion that I, I be honest with Olivia and tell her that as irrational as it seems, I've fallen in love with, with Sophie - that's a preposterous notion.

    Aunt Vanessa: It's lunacy.

    Stanley: ...Yet I can't help feeling that...

    Aunt Vanessa: ...That you love Sophie. Yes, I understand. You're puzzled and bewildered; because your foolish logic tells you that you should love Olivia.

    Stanley: Foolish logic?

    Aunt Vanessa: And yet, how little that logic means when placed next to Sophie's smile...

    Stanley: What are you saying?

    Aunt Vanessa: ...That the world may or may not be without purpose, but it's not totally without some kind of magic.

    Stanley: ...I have irrational positive feelings for Sophie Baker. It's like witnessing a trick I can't figure out.

  • Aunt Vanessa: Which of us has not made some blunders in life?