Talking about the shit scene

Blaze 2022-04-19 09:02:18

Ye Ye told the truth, I was a bit at a loss for this scene. The heroine looked unhappy when she appeared, but she was only unhappy, and she still did not lose her beauty. When the gangsters asked to take off her clothes, the heroine became stubborn and unwilling to do so. This is of course normal. When the jailer beat her, the camera only captured the scene of waving sticks. That speed, that sound, it was hard not to It makes people feel bad for the heroine, but the heroine has endured it silently, and it is really good! But what's next? A group of hooligans brandished a pistol and told everyone below to stay away from the heroine. I somehow thought he was going to use the heroine to practice marksmanship. But he didn't. It was more than that. He emptied the bucket containing the excrement of the prisoners on the hostess. Simply breathtaking. The shots here are switched several times, and the bucket of excrement has been poured for a long time. It can be said that the director showed this... process to the fullest. Then a "knight" appeared, and the British officers representing justice also came. They were unceremonious, and they verbally criticized the group of hooligans. The hostess helped him away, and the hostess said, "I want to leave this place." I have to say that the function of this scene is too strong, and the director's intention to criticize the gangsters is too obvious here. I even feel that since such scenes are rare, both the director and the actors are inexperienced and stiff in handling them. How rigid the gangster's performance is, not to mention the old-fashioned, the heroine just endures the whole process silently, especially after being poured shit, the whole person seems to be stunned, why? Is it because of numbness? But the heroine is distinctly different from those who have been humiliated and tortured to become numb and unresponsive to their own and others' physical suffering. And the heroine was able to say a sentence and express the complete meaning at the end, which also showed that she did not completely lose her self-awareness at this time. At this time, the heroine had no response, just because what the director wanted to express had already been expressed, not to mention that there will be a "knight" coming out soon, and there must be criticism and education to make the theme more distinct. In addition, when the female protagonist came out of the cell, everyone was asked to pour the excrement into a bucket and hung the bucket, which seemed to be prepared for the feces later. It seems that this kind of shit is a regular program planned by the jailers, but it seems like a coincidence that the fat gangster poured shit on the heroine. All in all, the director of this scene must have prepared carefully, but the way it was filmed... how should I put it... It's surprising. I think the reason is probably that it has little to do with the main storyline. The "Knight" doesn't need the heroine to suffer so much to save the heroine, and the idea of ​​the heroine leaving does not need to be poured all over. to make it take shape. This scene was used by the director to criticize the gangsters, and in order to impress the audience, he did it so...excessively. Reminds me of the sentence "Speaking is not astonishing to die endlessly", isn't this a kind of involution?

View more about Black Book reviews

Extended Reading
  • Lexi 2022-03-23 09:02:20

    3.5 The plot comes first, and the characters other than the heroine are too hollow. Compared with Lust and Caution, the two have different paths. Rachel is the absolute center, male/patriarchy is her foil, seduction is also self "reform", luck has helped her avoid many disasters. The ups and downs of its fate are attributed to the current situation, rather than pointing to more complex and rich layers, making it so charming and glamorous that it is less human when it is amazing.

  • Ladarius 2022-01-01 08:02:11

    Known as the European version of Lust Precepts, but I think it is more plot than Lust Precepts. In the context of war, there is no right or wrong, no good and evil, no good and evil, only strengths and weaknesses. I think no one likes war! The heroine is really beautiful, not just her appearance.

Black Book quotes

  • Gerben Kuipers: Ellis, a girl didn't show up today. Would you replace her?

    Rachel Stein aka Ellis de Vries: Work is work, right?

    Gerben Kuipers: Even if it is dangerous?

    Rachel Stein aka Ellis de Vries: What have I got to lose?

    Gerben Kuipers: Your life...

  • Gerben Kuipers: You met that Muntze on the train, right? And he liked you?

    Hans Akkermans: Liked her...? He fell for her!

    Rachel Stein aka Ellis de Vries: He just showed me his stamp collection.

    Gerben Kuipers: How far would you go with him? For Tim and the others...?

    Rachel Stein aka Ellis de Vries: How far...? You mean sleep with him...? I want things to be clear, is that what you mean?

    Gerben Kuipers: How far would you go...?

    Rachel Stein aka Ellis de Vries: As far as that Muntze wants to go... Okay?