I don't quite agree with "Manslaughter from the Sky" far surpassing the national version of "Manslaughter"

Mireya 2022-04-19 09:02:10

Each has its pros and cons. I don't agree with the Indian version that far exceeds the domestic version. Although the domestic plot is somewhat unreasonable, the Indian version also has some problems. (It's not one-handed, one-stepped, one-handed, one-stepped, not one-handed and one-stepped) First, let's talk about the shortcomings. ① Domestic production pays more attention to depicting the psychological changes of the characters and close-up of expressions, while the printing plate pays more attention to the plot. There is no deliberate emphasis on these psychological changes. The fear of the mother and daughter, and the policewoman's anger at the loss of her son were not fully reflected. It doesn't highlight the mother's role too much, but the domestic version portrays it very well. The printing plate mother and daughter are more like sisters? ②The length of the printing plate is too long, and the plot is a bit dragged. Watching at double speed has no effect at all, just like watching "The Tuner", it's tiring to watch. ③The acting skills of the actors in the printing plate are obviously not as good as those in the Chinese version (personal feeling), which is fully reflected in the role of the female sheriff. Let’s talk about the advantages ❶ The rigor of the plot is much better than that of the domestic version. For example, at the end of the printing plate, it explained that the body was buried in the police station, but the national version did not explain where the body was buried at the end. The sheep buried in the national version is a little out of sight. What do you want to do by burying a sheep in someone's ancestral grave? force a metaphor. And no one saw the scratches on the coffin? It is more reasonable to bury the dog in the fertilizer pit of the printing plate. ❷ The ending of the printing plate did not surrender, did not surrender! In general, in terms of my personal perception of the movie, the Chinese version is more watchable and more enjoyable to watch, but the plot logic is relatively poor. The plot of the printing plate is rigorous, but I'm tired of watching it, it's too long and not very interesting.

In general, in terms of my personal perception of the movie, the Chinese version is more watchable and more enjoyable to watch, but the plot logic is relatively poor. The plot of the printing plate is rigorous, but I'm tired of watching it, it's too long and not very interesting.

View more about Drishyam reviews

Extended Reading

Drishyam quotes

  • Meera Deshmukh: Cinema.

    Meera Deshmukh: That's an important link.