This is touching literature and art, but it is not a touching literature and art film

Malvina 2022-04-19 09:02:07

A detached director should be a very smart person. He knows exactly what he wants to express and how to express it, so he bravely abandons the drama mode, and expresses a story that is not very complete through poetic words, emotions, and paragraphs. . Doing so can attract many audiences with profound literary and artistic plots, and I am one of them. But the only feeling I have after watching the movie is that this is an experimental film, but not a movie. It has the form of a movie, but it doesn't have the completeness that a movie should have.

The whole movie feels like a preaching. Although there are many parts that are well handled, it is generally too literary. Even at some moments, I feel that it is a mixture of literature and video, or it is a video to express literary works. At most, he is an innovative and subversive literary creation. However, the language of the film is too symbolic. With the narration, every detail becomes an adjective and slowly enters our brain.

Behind such a huge amount of information, what we actually see is an incomplete plot and fragmented emotional expression, which makes people feel that it is not coherent and refreshing enough. Especially the paragraph of the cake at the end is very strange, the foreshadowing is only a little bit, and the suicide of the girl at the end is reduced to a conceptual expression and a pure emotion.

This kind of hybrid style, I think it should be carried out around a main line. The characters at least need to have a purpose and a turning point, and the detachment is too straightforward, so stripping off the narration will appear a little empty. After removing the gorgeous pictures inside, the details that express emotions are even more empty. I think a good movie is complete. Even if all the adjectives in it are removed, it should still be a good movie. In this regard, detachment has not been achieved.

View more about Detachment reviews

Extended Reading
  • Michel 2021-12-18 08:01:09

    It brought me into a kind of mental distress that was affected by emotions, but it didn't release me until the end of the film. No detachment.

  • Jeanne 2022-03-27 09:01:09

    The mode of interspersed animation is like rewinding life; the density of dialogue and the dispersion of characters, and the intertwined pictures of fantasy and reality are like a half-dream and half-awake life; the form of Uncle Loli is like the killer Leon; only the final collapse of the Old House of Usher, everyone No, it's Tony Kaye from the American X-Files. The five stars for this film in this genre are mainly due to two people, one pays tribute to the director's persistence after 14 years, and the other hopes that Sammy Gale - the future superstar will be born.

Detachment quotes

  • Henry Barthes: Whatever is on my mind, I say it as I feel it, I'm truthful to myself; I'm young and I'm old, I've been bought and I've been sold, so many times. I am hard-faced, I am gone. I am just like you.

  • Henry Barthes: Y'know you can't... you can't keep living on the street...

    Erica: I'm not, I mean, I'm staying here with you.

    Henry Barthes: Well, you can't continue to stay here with me. I'm not good for you...

    Erica: That's not true. You're like, the only family I've ever had...

    Henry Barthes: Well, I can't be your family, I can't give you what you need. You have to understand, you should be...

    Erica: You're good and gentle, you're the most kind... I love you Henry. Don't let them take me, please nooooooooo, you're all I have, please don't let me go.

    [Social workers take her away still protesting]