Shelby:
[the North Valley cheerleaders put on a play for the pep rally; with Shelby as the narrator; exposing the truth about Sam's "Cinderella" identity]
Thank you!
[Shelby narrates the story]
Shelby:
"Once upon a time, there was a big, strong Fighting Frog."
[Brianna appears, as Austin, hopping like a frog on top of the cheerleaders]
Shelby:
"He had a beautiful girlfriend, and his dad owned the biggest pond in all the land. But, he still wasn't happy."
[Caitlyn and Madison hold up the cue cards, and the crowd goes "Aww!". Shelby continues narrating]
Shelby:
"If only he could find a princess, then she could kiss him, turn him into a prince and they would run away together."
[the cheerleaders carry in Gabriella, as "Cinderella" in her dress, and they put her down and the crowd starts laughing. Shelby continues narrating the story]
Shelby:
"One night, after the slimy Frog ditches his super-hot, senior-poll, most popular girlfriend, he meets his princess."
Brianna:
[as Austin, putting his hand out to Gabriella, as "Cinderella"]
Your Highness!
[Gabriella does a silly bow, as "Cinderella" in her dress until her underwear shows, and the crowd laughs]
Shelby:
[continues narrating]
"Alas, it turns out, that not only did our Prince have a secret identity, but also had an online relationship with a pen-pal named "Princeton Girl"."
[the cheerleaders do a handstand, showing the wall between "Austin" and "Cinderella"]
Carter:
[to Sam]
This isn't good.
Brianna:
[as Austin, texting on the phone]
"Dear Princeton Girl, I can't wait til we finally get to meet. You're the only one who understands the real me."
[the crowd laughs in the background]
Brianna:
"The man who doesn't want to play USC football. But who wants to be at Princeton, with you."
[the crowd continues laughing, with Shelby smirking, nastily]
Austin's Dad:
[to Austin, about the impersonation]
What are they talking about?
Austin:
Nothing.
Gabriella:
[as "Cinderella", texting back to "Austin"]
"Dear Nomad, I want you to know who I am but, I'm scared!"
[Sam looks at her stepsisters, and the cheerleaders, horrified, embarrassed and upset]
Gabriella:
"I'm scared that you'll reject me! And... I've never had a
[whispers]
Gabriella:
real kiss before!"
[Caitlyn and Madison hold up the cue cards and the crowd goes "Aww!"]
Sam:
[horrified and upset]
I can't believe that they're reading my emails!
Carter:
[to Sam]
Sam, let's go!
Shelby:
[continues narrating]
But our princess had a secret too. She wasn't royalty at all,
[Gabriella comes onstage wearing a waitress outfit with roller-skates, and skating badly]
Shelby:
but a geek, a loser; a servant girl.
[Gabriella roller-skates and lands into a pie, splattering herself on top of the cheerleaders with the crowd laughing loudly]
Austin's Dad:
[to Austin]
Any ideas about this?
[Austin shakes his head]
Shelby:
[chuckling nastily to herself, and finishes narrating]
And, who may you ask, is this impostor?
[motions to Sam, sticking her hand out]
Shelby:
Give it up for the pretend princess, Diner Girl, Sam Montgomery!
[the crowd laughs really loudly, and starts chanting "Diner girl!" and continues chanting. Austin looks at Sam, horrified that he found out the truth about Sam]
Carter:
[to an utterly embarrassed and humiliated Sam, in tears]
Come on.
[Sam and Carter leave the pep rally; embarrassed and in tears, as the crowd continue chanting "Diner girl" with Shelby smirking victoriously]
