A story about "love" and "listening"

Victoria 2022-04-23 07:02:20

Kate has leukemia, and her mother did everything she could to keep her in the world, which is the source of all the contradictions.
With the firefighter dad busy at work and rarely at home, mum quit her job as a lawyer to devote herself to caring for Kate. The focus of the family was all on Kate: in order to prolong Kate's life, they deliberately "created" a young daughter Anna who matched Kate's antigen through test-tube babies to provide Kate with "necessities" for life. The family's son, Jesse, has a language barrier, and his parents have no time to take care of it. Jesse was sent to a special education school when he was a child, and has never been given due attention at home.

However, the long-term torture of the illness, coupled with the death of her boyfriend who was sympathetic to the same illness, made Kate already lost her enthusiasm for life. When her mother insisted on letting her sister Anna donate her kidney to help Kate continue her life, Kate, who wanted to die, persuaded her sister Anna to file a lawsuit in court, accusing her mother of abusing her power and using Anna's body at will.
The lawsuit was won, and the mother "give in" and finally respected Kate's wishes and accepted Kate's death.

Behind this indictment is a story about "listening".
The "dictator" mom insists on continuing Anna's life. This obsession made her unable to listen to anyone persuading her to give up, such as aunt Harley's advice, such as Anna's defense at the dinner table, and her brother Jesse's speech barrier, perhaps the most direct manifestation of his deprivation of the right to speak.

Where on earth can this family communicate on an equal footing? Under what circumstances can a child's words be heard? This final conversation takes place in the courtroom: in order for mothers to "listen" to their children, a third party is needed, a courtroom that understands what children are going through - the judge just came out of the pain of losing her daughter , she knew the fear that death brought people; and the lawyer suffered from epilepsy and suffered from uncontrolled physical pain, which made him understand Anna's feelings deeply.

This is also a story about "love".
Mom's love is too selfish, and other family members are accommodating her. It is under this kind of "hegemony" that although the family seems to be full of warmth and under the dark cloud of illness, they still work together to deal with difficulties, but the fact is that the "captain" who leads the voyage drags almost everyone. Broken: Kate couldn't choose to die on her own, Anna was "planned" to be born into the world, even if the ultimate goal of all this was her mother's persistent "protection" for Kate, but this protection is too heavy, this selfish love It's a plunder.

PS Of course, another point to feel more deeply should be that each of us is not an appendage of others, nor is we born for others.
I hope everyone who is more or less "controlled" can speak out like Anna in court: "If this is my body, I have the right to make a decision."

View more about My Sister's Keeper reviews

Extended Reading

My Sister's Keeper quotes

  • Jesse Fitzgerald: Jesus Christ, Anna, just tell them.

    Andromeda 'Anna' Fitzgerald: You shut up.

    Jesse Fitzgerald: Tell them why we're here. Tell them what we're doing here in court...

    Andromeda 'Anna' Fitzgerald: [cuts in] You promised me that you wouldn't do this!

    Jesse Fitzgerald: God, you people are so stupid!

    Andromeda 'Anna' Fitzgerald: [shouts] You promised!

    Jesse Fitzgerald: Kate wants to die!

    Andromeda 'Anna' Fitzgerald: Stop it!

    Jesse Fitzgerald: She's making Anna do all this 'cause she knows she's not gonna survive another operation.

    Sara Fitzgerald: [yells] That's a lie, Jesse.

    Jesse Fitzgerald: Mum, no, it's not. Kate's dying and everybody knows it! You just love her so much that you don't want to let her go!

    Campbell Alexander: Your Honor?

    Jesse Fitzgerald: [continues] But it's time Mum, Kate's ready.

    Sara Fitzgerald: That's not true. Kate would've told me!

    Campbell Alexander: Your Honor, I...

    Jesse Fitzgerald: Mum, she did tell you.

    Brian Fitzgerald: She did. She told you million times, you didn't want to hear it.

  • [first lines]

    Andromeda 'Anna' Fitzgerald: When I was a kid, my mother told me that I was a little piece of blue sky that came into this world because she and Dad loved me so much. It was only later that I realized that it wasn't exactly true. Most babies are coincidences. I mean, up in space you've got all these souls flying around looking for bodies to live in. Then, down here on Earth, two people have sex or whatever, and bam, coincidence. Sure, you hear all these stories about how everyone plans these perfect families. But the truth is that most babies are products of drunken evenings and lack of birth control. They're accidents. Only people who have trouble making babies actually plan for them.

    Andromeda 'Anna' Fitzgerald: I, on the other hand, am not a coincidence. I was engineered. Born for a particular reason. A scientist hooked up my mother's eggs and my father's sperm to make a specific combination of genes. He did it to save my sister's life. Sometimes I wonder what would have happened if Kate had been healthy. I'd probably still be up in heaven or wherever, waiting to be attached to a body down here on Earth. But coincidence or not, I'm here.