A movie that was still complaining at the beginning when I watched it, and then became dumbfounded and worried.
I know this is based on a prison experiment
I also know that there is a discrepancy between movies and reality
However, I still can't do not believe what I see
I've always been confused, why did you say you can't use violence, but you still use it?
Is it an express rule?
Red lights are another matter
The red light is the source of all sanity
The red light represents the bottom line
As long as the red light is not on, I feel it is acquiescence or even encouragement
This red light becomes the sole authority in the end
As long as the guards are not on, there are always so-called legitimate reasons to defend their behavior
Another is common sense
Once you are given that position and operate according to certain rules, will you gradually lose your sense of reason?
It is clear that the person has diabetes and is in danger, but he still acts according to his own experience
This is just the beginning, it shouldn't be lost so soon.
Or, the moral law in our hearts is actually an illusion at all
desert island effect mass event
so many examples
Humanity is really cool
I think of the girls in A Dream of Red Mansions, they are only fifteen or sixteen, at most in their early twenties, and they have to play various roles. Where is the true temperament and the petty temperament?
Occasionally see Li Wan envoy temperament once, and am actually happy for her
Young widowhood, three obedience and four virtues, how to live a life like walking on thin ice
It's all social rules
It's all man-made
Really shooting myself in the foot
Why can't the operation of the social system take into account people's feelings?
At first, I complained about the movie because I felt that the director intentionally added emotional elements to exaggerate the atmosphere.
Let the male protagonist go to the experiment when the love begins
I didn't understand it at the time, I thought it was superfluous
Just shoot the experiment, what are you doing with some sensationalism?
It is certain that there will be trouble later, the male protagonist has a nervous breakdown during the experiment, and the last couple will be separated.
Moreover, it makes me feel that there is a male protagonist halo,
an unreal feeling
The reason he made up for going to the experiment was untrue
too coincidental
However, when I saw the end, I was glad that the director had such an arrangement
experienced such an experiment
Both the experimenter and the audience
It's all torture, a torture
The movie is not long, an hour and a half
But all kinds of violence and cold violence appear in it
despair and conflict
Probably the sum total of all I've seen in my life.
Suppressed to the end is the explosion
When it explodes, all rationality becomes a bubble
right is right
wrong is wrong
no boundaries
irrational
Everyone's locked into their roles
until the alarm sounds and the red light turns on
the gate rises
bright
I love the scene when the door opens
intriguing
It's like seeing the light for the first time
everyone stopped
Everyone suddenly regained their senses
then
Everyone starts to think
start to question
waking up from a dream
incredible
In the end, the male protagonist went to India and hugged his beloved girl on the banks of the Ganges
This is sensational, but I will not reject such sensationalism
Even if it's just imposed by the director
It also gave people some hope at last
There are so many things to think about in the film
For example, about the person who conducted the experiment
They're the ones hiding behind the camera
when they clearly saw the violence
No red light, tacitly allow this to happen
When they are considered by everyone inside as someone who knows what they are doing, someone who is rational, someone who can be depended on, someone who won't ignore it
what did they do
silence
Silence is the greatest affirmation of violence
I remember reading an article by Liu Yu, The Elephant in the Room
Silence is criticized inside
Quoted from Martin Luther King
The greatest tragedy of social transformation that history will remember is not the noise of the bad guys, but the silence of the good guys.
Here again, Chinese in Long Yingtai, why aren't you angry?
always such a cliché
But always so powerless
Also about selection
Said that the selected people are physically and mentally healthy and have no violent tendencies
But in the end
elected fraternity
people with diabetes
Elected people with moral problems in the first place
So, the first half of the movie
I've been ranting
Obviously it's a matter of selection
If you switch roles
If you change a group of normal people
Probably no such problem
However, to the back
I have found
It's not the selection that's the problem.
Rather, it's simply impossible
not so much if
everyone is not perfect
If so many factors are removed
The meaning of this prison experiment is not that big.
It is because of the fickleness of human nature
or the fickleness of human nature
caused everything that happened
Also, the role of institution
Prison is the most extreme example
total institution
completely closed
It's really dangerous at this time
Because no one has full control over everything
individual rationality
collective irrationality
No resistance is seen as acquiescence
However, if there is a voice of opposition, it will be regarded as a bird in the early stage
the rules are there
However, the person who implements the rules can always think of various ways to maintain his own authority
for various reasons
As long as the red light in his heart doesn't come on
I have visited the prison in Qingdao
It was built during German colonization and later used by the Japanese
It is clear that the Japanese are far more cruel than the Germans
They opened the ground, built water prisons, electric chairs
That airtight, gloomy feeling you can feel as soon as you step into the prison
The building itself is enough to destroy the weak-willed
Can't imagine what happened there
But after watching the movie today
Even more unimaginable
if i were guard
what will i do
I will stick to my moral law
still obey the boss
Or take control of your own power
Also, about obedience
When jailers use name calling in the first place
I don't think it's right
How to get into character so quickly
When you see that the jailers are divided into two factions, but the good ones are just civil disobedience, and even follow suit, but not so cooperative
I knew it
Going to start cleaning the interior
But don't they really know what they're doing?
When they keep humiliating no.77
when they forcibly suppressed prisoners
What gave them a reason to do so?
Is it just because that red light isn't on?
Is it just because of that money?
Or, some kind of emotion surged out of people's hearts?
About leadership
Probably the male protagonist is a successful leader
is a charismatic leader
And the black boss is a dictatorial and failed leader
At least that's how it turns out
However, it was to the point of being unbearable, and the black boss was betrayed and left by all the people.
before a certain limit
no one openly confronted him
Reminds me of the evaluation of the Chinese
As long as you live, you can do anything
A group of obedient people
When the Cultural Revolution began, the people were happy
At the end of the Cultural Revolution, it was also a happy day
Which dynasty did not end up with the people dying of starvation
It just kicked up
sometimes i think
In China, reality is what matters
The dispute between capital and society is actually for the common people,
It's not as good as the sweet and salty battle of tofu brain
as long as you can live happily
Who cares about class attributes?
After watching this film
just sigh
Praise the male protagonist and finally get together with the female protagonist
also
I don't know what to say
View more about The Experiment reviews
