Deliberately provocative, lacking emotional core

Godfrey 2022-04-24 07:01:07

It's a good movie that moves people to tears, but it's not the one that evokes tears deliberately. This film has a great idea, using the perspective of a little boy to reflect the scars left by the 9/11 incident in the hearts of Americans. The Oscar nomination also proves that his bad reviews on Metacritics and Rotten Tomatoes are slightly biased, but it's definitely not a classic movie.

Several highlights of the film: 1. About the effect of "8 minutes" on children. 2. Using quick editing, the boy's continuously strengthened tone fully brought out people's fears. 3. The way to deal with the end.

What's bad: 1. The tear gas feels so obvious that a 9/11 side story feels more sad than anything else (I think, poor Brazilian slums and war-torn families in the Middle East are much more tragic than this bourgeois loss Bar). 2. The characterization is not enough. Except for the little boy, other characters are superficial (especially Sandra Bullock's mother image). 3. The boy's perspective is not changed enough. Everyone knows that Dedley likes to use little boys to tell stories (this is the third time he has done so), so the novelty is not enough.

View more about Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close reviews

Extended Reading

Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close quotes

  • Oskar Schell: It's just a box! An empty box!

    Linda Schell: I know it's an empty box! I know this. But I did it for me, and I did it for you so we can at least try and say goodbye to him. Because he's gone, Oskar, he's gone and he's not coming back. Never. I don't know why a man flew a plane into a building. I don't know why my husband is dead. But no matter how hard you try, Oskar, it's never gonna make sense because it doesn't. It doesn't... make... sense!

    Oskar Schell: Fukozowa you! You don't know anything!

  • [first lines]

    Oskar Schell: There are more people alive now than have died in all of human history, but the number of dead people is increasing. One day, there isn't going to be any room to bury anyone anymore. So, what about skyscrapers for dead people, that are built down. They could be underneath the skyscrapers for living people, that are built up. We could bury people 100 floors down. And a whole dead world could be underneath the living one.