How to clarify a bay of muddy water?

Gerardo 2022-04-20 09:01:44

This is the only movie I want to rewatch the next day.

As an adult, I am more willing to think about the deep problems behind social chaos. There have been too many comments on the use of violence by elite troops (extorting confessions by torture and killing gun suspects), so I won't repeat them. What I'm more concerned about is in a corrupt environment, what do you want to do with integrity?

In other words, how to clarify the muddy waters of a bay?

Without protection fees, even trivial things like repairing a police car can’t be done... In an environment where police officers are all corrupt, you can reason with them?

Talking about the law, criticizing the bad times, meeting face-to-face, loving each other, caring for the poor and young, full of love, but taking drugs, selling drugs, and getting used to it... In the face of a group of ordinary people who look like angels but do evil things, do you reason with them?

What's more, they have guns in their hands, who dares to reason?

The reality of the film is suffocating, and any moral framework we have now seems unreasonable. The children who let go of the wind were killed by drug dealers. What do you do in this situation? love?

=================================================

Andre eventually became a member of the elite army and used violence to control violence. This is the way he finally chose "integrity".

"I always ask myself, how many kids do we have to get caught up in the drug trade so the dummies can get their hands on marijuana?"

"I think the people here are too shallow and ignorant. They are misled, you are really misled, you know? I believe there is corruption, but most police officers want to behave with integrity and do a good job. About being at the checkpoint. A body search, I think it's necessary. They have to suppress, it's logical, they're going to impede. Really? I bet you have marijuana or something, you don't know how many children get caught in the drug trade and die. In You don't see that in your elegant south-facing apartment. You're misled by the newspapers and the news."

=================================================

Of course, the film is not taboo at all, and deliberately arouses the doubts of the audience:

Will the elite troops fight violence in vain? Will it lead to fear among the people? Will there be no corrupt elements in elite troops?

But anyway, as a viewer, I couldn't find any other way. Putting ourselves in our shoes, we might just be one of those dudes...

View more about Elite Squad reviews

Extended Reading
  • Trent 2022-04-24 07:01:08

    Why is the score so harsh, it's good, the sensory impact is extremely strong and effective, and it is reasonable, amazing and thought-provoking. It's a fantastic political movie embedded in a commercial format.

  • Kaitlin 2022-04-22 07:01:31

    D+ / Still feel that the choice of the narrator of the film is too closed due to lack of room for thinking. It is neither conducive to rhythm control nor close to the most abundant character in fact (what about discipline and punishment?). It is one thing to put forward a sufficiently "real" position, and it is another to finally open up to the possibility of reaching "ideal" beyond this simple position. Now it's like standing firm on unbreakable pragmatism, rejecting almost any outside judgment. The seemingly "real" hand in the system of genre films doesn't seem to erase that layer of violent game meaning, which inevitably makes people doubt this kind of chic and straightforward...?

Elite Squad quotes

  • Capitão Nascimento: [as the police squad arrives at the bottom of the slum, regular policemen starts to prepare to follow them] Nobody's going up! Nobody's going up!

  • Trainee officer: Men in black what is it that you do?

    Student: I do things that scare even Satan himself!

    Trainee officer: Men in black what is your mission?

    Student: Get into the slam and leave corpses on the ground!