Analysis

Kassandra 2022-04-23 07:02:18

The story of "Silence" is quite simple. The two missionaries go to the forbidden area to find the missing priest. The first half of the film is narrated by Father Ferreira, describing the tragic situation of foreign missionaries in Japan, followed by the narration by Lotri Brother took over, and described the local customs and oppression through what he saw and heard when he smuggled to Japan. The oppression of foreign beliefs by those in power is like seeing a cancerous tumor, eager to remove it to avoid future troubles, while Lotrigo’s silence about praying to God, or the silence of everyone when pagans are suppressed, is an illusion. It becomes a silent question again and again, just like the unanswerable doubts that the movie has sprouted in the hearts of the audience. How much torture must people endure before they collapse and give up their beliefs? If you finally succumb to death threats, do you turn your back on God in your heart? Should we protect the ideas in our hearts at all costs? If it is out of intolerance and goodness to renounce faith, does God forgive him out of mercy? Why is the essence of religion a torture of the self? The movie does have the image of Lotrigo and Jesus as a contrast. Lotrigo's preaching journey in this cruel land is like the pagan persecution of Jesus in Rome, especially the reflection in the water. The astonishing image of the brother's face and the portrait of Jesus overlapped, the stream of consciousness intertwined between the real and the virtual, and finally evolved into a scene where Lotrigo was insane.

View more about Silence reviews

Extended Reading
  • Anthony 2022-03-24 09:01:59

    If I hadn't read the original book, I'd be hard-pressed to read it as an atheist. The restoration is actually pretty good, but Garfield is really not suitable for this role... Failure

  • Adalberto 2022-03-22 09:01:55

    "This last priest, in the following days, will no longer pray, will not declare and will no longer take action." Most believers feel that they have a heavy burden on the insult to the faith and are unwilling to blaspheme the Lord. And the priest still listened to Jijiro's confession after abandoning the church, and the cross of his soul. I think maybe the movie wants to preach the creed that "faith in your heart is enough". If you spread the gospel more deeply and effectively, how could the Lord care about your step?

Silence quotes

  • Dieter Albrecht: It was in the year 1641, during the first of my voyages to Japan, that I, Dieter Albrecht, came upon the most extraordinary story in these pages. As a physician in a great Dutch trading company, I traveled widely. But none of the wonders I have recounted in this journal has been so commented on as the curious matter of the apostate priests. I came closer than any European chronicler to the enigma of this country. And to learning of the lives of the lost priests. Inoue, the Inquisitor, would raid homes and search for any objects with hidden Christian images. The two priest were required examine these things and verify their use. I even, on occasion, observed them myself. The Dutch were the only Europeans allowed to trade in Japan. All ships were searched to warrant they were not smuggling religious objects. Nothing bearing the images of the cross, a saint, or rosary could pass. Despite every attempt a few things inevitably were smuggled in. And then it was as distressing to the Japanese as if blood had been spilled. When Sawano Chuãn died, the other priest assumed his duties and performed them with distinction. By this time, I observed he had acquired considerable skill with the language. And seemed to be at peace with his situation. Okada San'emon lived in Edo for the remaining years of his life. Some 10 years later, I was allowed to visit Edo. The Japanese gossiped freely about Okada San'emon. The Inquisitor Inoue, demanded repeated vows of apostasy from him. And they say "The fallen priest supplied them all quickly and vigorously." The Inquisitor continued to insist on periodic examinations of all suspected Christians. Okada San'emon was not exempt from this. Inoue was determined to never let his example be forgotten. Perhaps most particularly by the priest himself. In the year 1667, a religious image was discovered inside an amulet belonging to a servant called Kichijiro. The servant said he had won it gambling, had never looked inside, and could never have gotten the amulet from Okada San'emon since he was always under guard. The servant Kichijiro was taken away. After that, Okada San'emon himself was carefully watched. During my last voyage in 1682, I asked about him, and the Japanese were eager to reply. The last priest never acknowledged the Christian God. Not by word or symbol. He never spoke of Him and never prayed. Not even when he died. The business of his faith was long ended. Three guards stood watch over the coffin until it could be taken away, just to be certain. Only his wife was briefly allowed to view the body, and place there a humble mamorigatana to ward off evil spirits. There was no indication that she wept. The body was treated in the Buddhist manner. And he was given a posthumous Buddihist name. The man who was once Rodrigues ended as they wanted. And as I first saw him, lost to God. But as to that, indeed, only God can answer.

  • Ferreira: We were taught to love those who scorned us.

    Father Sebastião Rodrigues: I feel nothing for them.

    Ferreira: Only Our Lord can judge your heart.

    [pause]

    Father Sebastião Rodrigues: You said, "Our Lord."

    [pause]

    Ferreira: I doubt it.