an uncertain world

Kirsten 2022-04-23 07:01:52

When I was young, I was a fan of physics. From junior high school, I began to figure out the relationship between force, motion, momentum, etc., and I fell into modern physics science books in high school. Although he has not made any achievements in physics, nor engaged in physical research, and even his knowledge will not exceed the scope of popular science books, he naturally knows Schrödinger's uncertainty principle and the famous problem of cat life and cat death. The film is not esoteric in physics, once again confirming that Hollywood directors have no deeper knowledge of science and technology than the average science enthusiast. . .

Well, let's talk about the uncertainty principle of quantum theory first. We know that Isaac Newton developed modern physics through the "theorem" obtained through calculus and some experiments. This theory can explain the motion of carriages, the whereabouts of iron balls, trains pulling carriages, and even the movement of the earth around the sun. . But the premise is that those "theorems" are summed up by scientists' experiments on the "earth". When people observe the wider universe or study tiny atoms, particles, etc., those "theorems" will be discovered. Be applicable. Scientists then admit that those so-called "theorems" are not "truths", but are actually just the experiences that people have tried on the earth. In the magnitude of the earth, these experiences and truths can almost be drawn on the same sign. But in order to study the life and death of the universe, we must use the theory of relativity of the cosmic dimension; in order to study the microscopic world, we need to use the quantum theory. A major feature of quantum theory is uncertainty. This theory believes that anything can happen. For example, the water in one cup may move into another cup without any force, but this probability is small. From the birth of the universe to the destruction of the universe is unlikely to happen. If we observe the motion of a specific particle, we are never sure where the particle will appear in the next step, but there is a certain tendency to count all particles, just like when we play dice, we never know which number the next time will be. If we experiment a million times, we will find that the six numbers appear about the same frequency.

Let's talk about the movie, the tone of the movie is the solemn color, and the narrative method and logic are obviously different from other commercial films in Hollywood. The dark humor of the film was glimpsed at the beginning with an unrelated episode, so I continued to watch it with a feeling corresponding to this narrative style. To be honest, after watching the brief introduction to the film, I thought it was a very man-told story of struggle. After reading it, I realized that it was a very "elegant" story. Without saying too much, I admit that I am not sure if I understand the movie, but I just shared my thoughts with everyone: the master uses mathematics in class to constantly prove to the students that the world is uncertain, but when the second When the priest (let's call it a priest, or a prophet?) told him an uncertain story, he was at a loss to know the answer, and wanted to know the doctor's later, the pagan's later, which implied the master's cup. Perhaps it has nothing to do with himself, the director just showed the fact, and it happened; three priests appeared in the film: the young, the old and the boss-level. The young priest has not enough experience and practice, trying to answer the protagonist and let him see the problem from a different perspective; the older one gives him some hints, trying to explain the protagonist that the world is disordered and unpredictable, so that he can accept it calmly; the boss The seniors just avoided it, and finally asked my son a question: When life takes all your hope away, what should you do? There is absolutely no meaning to the question to be answered. I think this is what the director wants to convey to us: life has no reason, no purpose, only life itself. It happens, we fix it, accept it, but we are unlikely to understand why. When the master was dreaming, his wife's concubine said that mathematics is an art of probability. In fact, what the director wanted to say was: life is the helplessness of probability.

But I personally still think that mathematics should not be the art of probability, mathematics is just a tool for people's logical reasoning. Probability belongs to the category of physics, while mathematics is only the description and reasoning of probability, and mathematics belongs to the summary and use of human's own way of thinking. It's the first time I've written such a long film review. I don't know if I can make it clear. Thank you.

View more about A Serious Man reviews

Extended Reading
  • Alan 2021-11-28 08:01:18

    I can't appreciate the limited level

  • Tyrel 2022-04-23 07:01:52

    What is the meaning of glasses? I'm playing with IQ again

A Serious Man quotes

  • Larry Gopnik: She seems to be asking an awful lot. But then, I don't know. Somebody has to pay for Sy's funeral.

    Rabbi Nachtner: Uh-huh.

    Larry Gopnik: His own estate is in probate, but why does it have to be me? Or is it wrong to complain? Judy says it is. But I'm so strapped for cash right now, carrying the mortgage, and paying for the Jolly Roger, and I wrecked the car, and Danny's Bar Mitzvah coming up, I...

    Rabbi Nachtner: Something like this... there's never a good time.

    Larry Gopnik: I don't know where it all leaves me, Sy's death. Obviously it's not gonna go back like it was.

    Rabbi Nachtner: Mm. Would you even want that, Larry?

    Larry Gopnik: No, I- well, yeah... sometimes... or... I don't know; I guess the honest answer is "I don't know". What was my life before? Not what I thought it was. What does it all mean? What is Hashem trying to tell me, making me pay for Sy Ableman's funeral?

    Rabbi Nachtner: Mm.

    Larry Gopnik: And did I tell you I had a car accident the same time Sy had his? The same instant, for all I know. I mean, is Hashem telling me that Sy Ableman is me? Or that we are all one, or something?

    Rabbi Nachtner: How does God speak to us? A good question.

  • Rabbi Nachtner: You know Lee Sussman.

    Larry Gopnik: Doctor Sussman? I think I - yeah.

    Rabbi Nachtner: Did he ever tell you about the goy's teeth?

    Larry Gopnik: No... I- What goy?

    Rabbi Nachtner: So... Lee is at work one day; you know he has the orthodontic practice there at Great Bear. He's making a plaster mold - it's for corrective bridge work - in the mouth of one of his patients, Russell Kraus. The mold dries and Lee is examining it one day before fabricating an appliance. He notices something unusual. There appears to be something engraved on the inside of the patient's lower incisors. He vav shin yud ayin nun yud. "Hwshy 'ny". "Help me, save me". This in a goy's mouth, Larry. He calls the goy back on the pretense of needing additional measurements for the appliance. "How are you? Noticed any other problems with your teeth?" No. There it is. "Hwshy 'ny". "Help me". Son of a gun. Sussman goes home. Can Sussman eat? Sussman can't eat. Can Sussman sleep? Sussman can't sleep. Sussman looks at the molds of his other patients, goy and Jew alike, seeking other messages. He finds none. He looks in his own mouth. Nothing. He looks in his wife's mouth. Nothing. But Sussman is an educated man. Not the world's greatest sage, maybe, no Rabbi Marshak, but he knows a thing or two from the Zohar and the Caballah. He knows that every Hebrew letter has its numeric equivalent. 8-4-5-4-4-7-3. Seven digits... a phone number, maybe? "Hello? Do you know a goy named Kraus, Russell Kraus?" Who? "Where have I called? The Red Owl in Bloomington. Thanks so much." He goes. It's a Red Owl. Groceries; what have you. Sussman goes home. What does it mean? He has to find out if he is ever to sleep again. He goes to see... the Rabbi Nachtner. He comes in, he sits right where you're sitting right now. "What does it mean, Rabbi? Is it a sign from Hashem, 'Help me'? I, Sussman, should be doing something to help this goy? Doing what? The teeth don't say. Or maybe I'm supposed to help people generally, lead a more righteous life? Is the answer in Caballah? In Torah? Or is there even a question? Tell me, Rabbi, what can such a sign mean?"

    [pause as the Rabbi drinks his tea]

    Larry Gopnik: So what did you tell him?

    Rabbi Nachtner: Sussman?

    Larry Gopnik: Yes!

    Rabbi Nachtner: Is it... relevant?

    Larry Gopnik: Well, isn't that why you're telling me?

    Rabbi Nachtner: Okay. Nachtner says, look. The teeth, we don't know. A sign from Hashem? Don't know. Helping others... couldn't hurt.

    Larry Gopnik: No! No, but... who put it there? Was it for him, Sussman, or for whoever found it, or for just, for, for...

    Rabbi Nachtner: We can't know everything.

    Larry Gopnik: It sounds like you don't know anything! Why even tell me the story?

    Rabbi Nachtner: [chuckling] First I should tell you, then I shouldn't.

    Larry Gopnik: What happened to Sussman?

    Rabbi Nachtner: What would happen? Not much. He went back to work. For a while he checked every patient's teeth for new messages. He didn't find any. In time, he found he'd stopped checking. He returned to life. These questions that are bothering you, Larry - maybe they're like a toothache. We feel them for a while, then they go away.

    Larry Gopnik: I don't want it to just go away! I want an answer!

    Rabbi Nachtner: Sure! We all want the answer! But Hashem doesn't owe us the answer, Larry. Hashem doesn't owe us anything. The obligation runs the other way.

    Larry Gopnik: Why does he make us feel the questions if he's not gonna give us any answers?

    Rabbi Nachtner: He hasn't told me.

    [Larry puts his face in his hands in despair]

    Larry Gopnik: And... what happened to the goy?

    Rabbi Nachtner: The goy? Who cares?