Did you notice the title of the movie is Crazy Asian and not Chinese or Singaporean

Montana 2022-04-19 09:01:51

The film is aimed at an American audience, and Americans don't have much of a breakdown of Asians.

Not going to watch the movie in its entirety, but read a lot of reviews from Asian and other ethnic audiences.

The author of the original book, Kevin, ranked East Asians according to their old money, from high to low: Indonesian Chinese, Singaporeans, Hong Kong people, Malaysian Chinese, Eurasian mixed race, Asian Americans in New York and Los Angeles, and private equity in Connecticut. Asian Americans, Asian Canadians in Toronto and Vancouver, Chinese Australians living in Melbourne and Sydney, Thais, Filipinos in Forbes Park, American-born Chinese, Taiwanese, Koreans, Mainland Chinese, ordinary Indonesians people.

Not sure where he would rank Indians in Singapore. Eighty percent of Singapore is Chinese, but there are almost no Malay and Indian characters in the film, except for security guards, which is even more serious than the monopoly of white Americans in Hollywood.

A Malay-Singapore playwright said, "What kind of Hollywood movie is this all-Asian starring? It's obviously replacing white actors with East Asians/white people wannabes?"

I can't hear Singlish in the movie, the accents are all British.

There are also comments that in some social circles in Singapore, if you marry a Malay, you have to break away from the family of origin. As for intermarriage with whites, there is certainly no discrimination.

Actor Henry Golding's father is British and his mother is Malay. Maybe a pure Asian male as the protagonist will affect the US box office? A newspaper in Singapore commented: "Hollywood thinks one drop of Asian blood is enough to be Asian."

The film and the author have been emphasizing the concept of old money. But if you've read The Style, The Unspoken Rules of What Brits Do or Divide: A Social Critique of Judgment, you'll see that the films were made entirely in the style of a working-class football star who grew up in East London. This explanation is a long story. If friends are interested, I will write an explanation of the old money in the movie later. Private jets, mansions, servant security, designer dresses, crazy shopping for bags and jewelry, pompous weddings and dress parties, bling bling, is the Asian version of Gatsby.

View more about Crazy Rich Asians reviews

Extended Reading

Crazy Rich Asians quotes

  • Rachel Chu: Thanks for meeting me here.

    [Eleanor eyes the other two women at the mahjong table]

    Rachel Chu: Don't worry about them. They're half-deaf and they only speak Hokkien.

    [Long pause as Eleanor reluctantly settles into her seat]

    Rachel Chu: My mom taught me how to play. She told me mahjong would teach me important life skills: Negotiation. Strategy. Cooperation.

    Eleanor Young: You asked me here, I assume it's not for a mahjong lesson.

    [Shows her tiles]

    Eleanor Young: Pong.

    [Snidely remarks]

    Eleanor Young: My mother taught me too.

    Rachel Chu: I know Nick told you the truth about my mom, but you didn't like me the second I got here. Why is that?

    Eleanor Young: There is a Hokkien phrase 'kaki lang'. It means: our own kind of people, and you're not our own kind.

    Rachel Chu: Because I'm not rich? Because I didn't go to a British boarding school, or wasn't born into a wealthy family?

    Eleanor Young: You're a foreigner. American - and all Americans think about is their own happiness.

    Rachel Chu: Don't you want Nick to be happy?

    Eleanor Young: It's an illusion. We understand how to build things that last. Something you know nothing about.

    Rachel Chu: You don't know me.

    Eleanor Young: I know you're not what Nick needs.

    Rachel Chu: [pauses] Well he proposed to me yesterday.

    [pauses]

    Rachel Chu: He said he'd walk away from his family and from you for good.

    [pauses]

    Rachel Chu: Don't worry, I turned him down.

    Eleanor Young: [sighs] Only a fool folds a winning hand.

    Rachel Chu: Mm no. There's no winning. You made sure of that. 'Cause if Nick chose me, he would lose his family. And if he chose his family, he might spend the rest of his life resenting you.

    Eleanor Young: [after a long pause] So you chose for him...

    Rachel Chu: I'm not leaving because I'm scared, or because I think I'm not enough - because maybe for the first time in my life, I know I am.

    [Choking back tears]

    Rachel Chu: I just love Nick so much, I don't want him to lose his mom again. So I just wanted you to know: that one day - when he marries another lucky girl who is enough for you, and you're playing with your grandkids while the Tan Huas are blooming, and the birds are chirping - that it was because of me: a poor, raised by a single mother, low class, immigrant nobody.

    [Shows her tiles. Gets up. Walks to her mom, who turns and glares at Eleanor]

  • Astrid Young Teo: It was never my job to make you feel like a man. I can't make you something you're not.