Alexander's Greek Tragedy

Isac 2022-04-19 09:01:44

I don't understand why the rating is so low. As far as the scenes shown in the movie are concerned, I feel like I'm seeing a tragedy in which Alexander's struggle with fate ultimately fails. First of all, since he was born, his mother Olympias used the legendary god to forcibly endow him with the divinity of "Achilles", forcing him to change from ignorant and simple as a child to an aggressive seizing power Tool of. His feelings for his mother contained family affection, obedience, and disgust and contempt for her merciless thunderbolt tactics. At the same time, he has ambitions himself, and the pure desire displayed by Olympias is also a projection of his own desires, and his dislike of Olympias is more self-loathing.

The most prominent aspect of his mother's love for him is the emphasis on self-interest and the obsession with manipulating Alexander. Olympias is deformed in love for him, because she can get self-fulfilling satisfaction from Alexander's power and will do anything to help Alexander get the throne; because she is full of resentment against King Philip, she sees Alexander as a product of vengeance , kept instilling hatred into Alexander; because she did not believe in things like love and friendship, she commanded her views on life to tell Alexander in the war not to trust anyone but Hephaistion . But Olympias herself, as the queen, has nothing to rely on once she loses Alexander. I think this is also a very sad thing.

About the dream of the battered Alexander, the dream that made and destroyed Alexander. At first due to the mystical richness of the East passed down in the mythology of generations, this dream was a great attraction for all its followers, who felt that glory was calling before them. But when they triumphed and arrived in India, the harshness of the natural environment had struck them, the ferocity of the eastern tribes had shot them, and the glory of words could no longer inspire the heroism in their hearts, they needed the consolation of love, the solace of their homeland soothe. However, Alexander's ambition and rebellion against his mother made him go his own way, insisting on going east, paranoid execution of two former friends for treason. He fell into deep self-doubt and became a vulnerable Alexander again, but without the spirit of his teenage years, the day he tamed the horse is long gone.

Regarding Alexander's love, Alexander is bisexual, has three wives, Roxana is the queen, but there is no understanding and tolerance, and two lovers: Hephaistion and Bagos. Bagos was enchanting and charming, he loved Alexander, but could not fully understand Alexander's lofty ambitions. Alexander and Hephaistion are equivalent to Achilles and Patroclus, they understand each other, support each other, and are closer to spiritual love, platonic love. However, in the second half of the film, the scenes showing Yahe's love are not rendered well enough.

The whole film is narrated by the characters, so we can also see another point of view, the point of view of the soldiers who followed Alexander and the ideas of the filmmakers through the mouth of the characters.

The sadness of no one

View more about Alexander reviews

Extended Reading

Alexander quotes

  • Cleitus: How can you, so young, compare yourself to Heracles?

    Alexander: Why not? I've achieved more in my years. Traveled as far. Probably farther.

    Cleitus: Heracles did it by himself! Did you conquer Asia by yourself, Alexander? I mean, who planned the Asian invasion when you were still being spanked on your bottom by my sister? Was it not your father? Or is his blood no longer good enough?

    Alexander: You insult me, Cleitus. You mock my family, be careful.

    Cleitus: Never would your father take barbarians as friends or ask us to fight with them as equals in war. Are we not good enough any longer? I remember a time when we could talk as men, strait to the eye, none of this scraping and groveling. I remember a time when we hunted, when we wrestled on the gymnasium floor. And now you kiss them? Take a barbarian, childless wife, and dare call her Queen?

    Alexander: [deeply insulted] Go quickly, Cleitus, before you ruin your life.

    Cleitus: Doesn't your great pride fear the gods any longer? This army's your blood, boy! Without it you're nothing!

    Alexander: You no longer serve the purpose of this march! Get him from my sight!

    Cleitus: What was I serving but to save your puppy life at Gaugamela? What if I left you to die in the dust?

    Hephaistion: [holding Alexander back] Alexander... Alexander!

    Alexander: Arrest him for treason! Who's with him? I call father Zeus to witness! I call you to trial before him! And we'll see how deep this conspiracy cuts!

    Hephaistion: In the name of the gods, get him out of here!

    Cleitus: Now look at you! Great Alexander! Hiding behind his guards! Are you too great to remember whose life was saved by me? I am more man than you'll ever be!

    [Cleitus is dragged out of the room]

    Hephaistion: He's gone. He's gone, Alexander, gone! Alexander!

    [Cleitus fights his way back into the room]

    Cleitus: What a tyrant you are! Evil tyrant you've become, Alexander. You speak about plots against you? What about poor Parmenion? He served you well! Look how you repaid him! Have you no shame?

    Alexander: You ungrateful wretch! No one, not my finest enemy has spoken like you to me!

    Hephaistion: Please, Alexander...

    [Alexander stabs Cleitus]

    Hephaistion: NO!

  • Parmenion: I pray to Apollo you soon realize how far you've turned from your father's path.

    Alexander: Damn you Parmenion, by the gods and your Apollo! War was in my father's guts! It wasn't over ripe and reason like yours.

    Parmenion: He never lusted for war, Alexander, or enjoyed it so. He consulted his peers in council, among equals! The Macedonian way. He didn't make decisions based on his personal desires.

    Alexander: I've taken us further than my father ever dreamed! Old man, we're in new worlds.

    Cassander: Alexander, be reasonable! Were they ever meant to be our equal? Share our rewards? You remember what Aristotle said. An Asian? What would a wedding vow ever mean to a race that has never kept their word to a Greek?

    Alexander: [throws Cassander against the wall] Aristotle be damned!

    Hephaistion: Alexander!

    Alexander: By Zeus and all the gods, what makes you so much better than them, Cassander? Better than you really are! In you and those like you is this!

    Hephaistion: [pleading] Alexander...

    Alexander: What disturbs me most is not your lack of respect for my judgment. It's your contempt for a world far older than ours!