The understanding between people is only based on imagination

Kay 2022-04-23 07:01:54

If you were asked to make a movie about depression, what would you do? Telling how depressed people are miserable, pitiful, and ununderstood? Too ordinary.
I don't know if you have heard the saying: the understanding between people is only based on imagination.
For example, to get someone who has never had a baby to understand how painful it is to have a baby, I can only ask him to imagine the pain of cutting his hand with a knife.
What if you want to explain what snow looks like to someone who has never seen it? All I could tell him was that it was something as white as sugar.
So, when it comes to having babies or snow, they say, oh, I know, it's a knife that cuts through the palm of your hand and it's the same as sugar.

But is it really the same?

It reminds me of the plot of Yukishui instructing Ryoji to rape all the women who oppose her in Baiye Xing.
It's not a revenge,
it's a different emotion:
Hey! Don't say anything about being strong, so pitiful, one way or another.
Want to understand me? Then go experience what I've experienced, experience what I've experienced. Then you can understand me and you will become another me. Ah~~~, I can finally be understood, I am so happy.
So, to understand depression? Become a depression. The second half of the film is destined to become a classic. The screenwriter uses a supernatural metaphor to turn everyone on earth into a melancholia: with the attack of the Melancholy Star, fear, sadness, and suffocation (The Melancholy Star consumes a lot of the planet. of oxygen), cold (unusual weather such as snow caused by the Melancholy star), suicide. The whole film is turned over at once. The heroine, who has been lonely, helpless, and helpless in the first half, looks at all the people who are lonely, helpless, and hesitant in the second half, with her eyes clearly saying: Look, such a broken star frightened you into this, I suffered a hundred times more than you.
Another interesting aspect of the film is the heroine's brother-in-law. Almost all the comments are about this guy. Because it was too happy, a person who looked down on depression so much, ended up being the first to commit suicide. But in my humble opinion, the film was never made for pleasure, it came from an insight into human nature. In Freud's seven models of conscious-subconscious antagonism, this is called reaction formation, where people act in opposite ways to the subconscious. Because my brother-in-law is a more vulnerable person than anyone else, he can only show special contempt for depression. Just like when Melancholy struck later, all he could do was to constantly and firmly deny any doubt, because it was not for his fragile nerves to bear.

View more about Melancholia reviews

Extended Reading
  • Weston 2022-03-25 09:01:08

    Many similar pictures, such as poetic slow motion and oil painting-like pictures, have been seen in Feng Trier's previous works, but they used to be embellishments, but now they are full of emotional catharsis. Contempt for love, disgust for life, and arrogance, leaving only the pursuit of beauty, the praise of death, and the wanton exaggeration of fear and romance. If the only thing left in the movie is the pursuit of beauty, then it will be more or less like this.

  • Juvenal 2022-04-24 07:01:06

    #SIFF# is most fortunate to see this film for the first time on the big screen, the sacred effect of the cinema magnifies the film's most obvious advantages - soundtrack, camera lens, special effects. Justin is melancholic because he predicts the coming of the Melancholy Star and destroys every relationship with everyone around him, and because of the end of the day, he predicts that there is "nothing but life on earth that is about to disappear". Similarly, thinking about the relationship between the existence of the universe and people, the tree of life is obviously more advanced.

Melancholia quotes

  • Justine: I was just thinking - what if instead we try and sell you to the public, Jack? Well then, surprisingly, I'd arrive right back where I started from - at nothing.

    Tim: "Nothing." It's not such a bad tagline, Jack.

    Jack: Would my newly pledged A.D. please expand a little on her thoughts of the tagline?

    Justine: Nothing is too much for you, Jack. I hate you and your firm so deeply I couldn't find the words to describe it. You are a despicable power-hungry little man, Jack.

    Jack: Is that a resignation? Because they aren't too many jobs out there, I tell you.

  • Tim: The way I see it, you're now short of a boss and a husband, could I, in all humility, offer my services? You have the ideas. I have the head for business. We could be the perfect couple. We've had good sex.

    Justine: I don't think that's a very good idea.

    Tim: No. No.