Liu Yuling, I don’t understand Why do so many people have negative comments about her? Have you watched Lucy's sister's film seriously? When there were not many Asians, they worked hard in Hollywood. She was strong, beautiful, and rp was no problem. I have starred in several major Hollywood productions, but I haven't seen that is a question of your insight. As a Chinese man,
I support Sister Liu. When I published the news in the United States, I also had very opposed opinions . I watched the first out of curiosity. The American version of the episode, the short evaluation is as follows:
1. The production level, the soundtrack, etc. are obviously not as good as the BBC, and the script is also relatively weak. But considering that this is an American drama, it can be accepted.
2. As expected, Lucy performed better than Miller. Better. Of course, in general, the role of Holmes is definitely more challenging than Watson. Lucy's performance is qualified but not excellent. Miller... I think so, no matter how it is adapted, Holmes is a genius. There is no doubt about which version it is in. But I don’t think Miller has the kind of wisdom to perform, but feels that he is showing off...You can say that this is a style, anyway, I can’t accept it. .
question of the play:
1 US drama style and the original obviously do not take, at the time of this adaptation does not fit well, feel neither fish nor fowl
2 is not to say the script is a matter of style or setup issues Miller performing the role of Sherlock's very OOC, very much. !!!! I won’t talk about the details, whether it’s the original fan, BBC fans, I believe they all have the same feeling...
In fact, setting Watson as a woman, although everyone did not accept it at the beginning, it is actually a good idea , The problem is that it is obvious that CBS has not handled it well. I personally see that Lucy's performance is no problem, but it is still a problem with the entire play structure...
I think since this is an American version, and it is a modern version, it is unfair to treat it as the original or the British style of the BBC. It’s just a matter of how to grasp this degree, let’s watch a few episodes. I heard this drama want The reaction during the filming was "I rely on these people to ruin Sherlock Holmes." Look at the previous feelings. See what the CBS film looks like. "After watching it, I think "It's very thunderous!! But it's a bit interesting. You can pay more attention to it." See how long you can endure"(.
I don’t think when you read it, don’t think about the original, don’t think about the BBC, and watch it as an original American TV show. If you look at Miller’s face, it’s still a little fancy--I believe there is no Audiences who have watched the BBC watch this drama directly, their evaluation should be ok. It can be expected that BBC fans and audiences who watch CBS directly may cause a fight...
I give 3 stars, I think I can’t give it higher = = 1 star to Liu Yuling's sister, a Chinese actor who can play a major role in a European and American drama, deserves support, not to mention her performance is pretty good
View more about Elementary reviews
