Myth, History, Truth, and Wisdom

Wendy 2022-04-20 09:01:27

Five stars. Only shock, and shock.

The title of this man from the earth is very interesting, it turns out that it is true, because from the earth of 14,000 years, that is an age that cannot be confirmed by modern science, and even then there is no modern concept of age and time.

What struck me the most was Jesus. But everything is the myth itself building its temple. There is a sentence in the film that history does not allow the existence of a vacuum.

Because history is not all real, history is memory and imagination, and it is an incomplete record. The difference between the recorder and the purpose of the record will lead to completely different results. Just like the question after question answered by John, the professors of various disciplines present were confused, suspicious, and even angry. Because John's "story" is really unfalsifiable, and it is all about challenging human consensus, ideas, and beliefs.

John's acquiescence that he "was" the part of Jesus is the most shocking part of the movie. Christian Eddie's foundations of faith were loosened, and she couldn't believe it. In the end John had to say he made it up, Eddie apparently went back to her devout Christian state and kissed John on the cheek when he said goodbye, I don't know if Eddie believed part of John's story in the back of his mind here, but This scene is really ironic.

One of the questions I'm most interested in is what wisdom a human being who has lived for 14,000 years will hold in his head. But then I gave myself an explanation that experience does not equal wisdom.

John seems to be saying something to himself, all he has is time. What is time, a product of modern civilization.

What revelation John's existence can bring us, we don't know. Every word of his has a deep meaning and is elusive. When the black brother lamented that humans have made the environment too bad, John said that humans still have time.

Perhaps, time itself is not wisdom, but the long time allowed John to see the laws of history, and grasping the most abstract laws is almost wisdom itself.

The biggest revelation from this film for me is whether, if John stood in front of me, I would believe what he said was inscrutable, or would I deny an unfalsifiable story in order to maintain my convictions.

To be or not to be, that is a question.

View more about The Man from Earth reviews

Extended Reading
  • Wayne 2022-03-24 09:01:30

    I'm not offended by the peculiarity of this idea. The small cost of the film seems to be the entry point for the director to show off his narrative ability, which is disgusting. Judging from a fireplace story, it's the ultimate; for a movie, it's blasphemy. →20.3.11 Review after seven years. The man in front isn't quite right, but it's nice to find him saying it at 13.

  • Newell 2022-04-24 07:01:04

    The male protagonist is very handsome, the ending song Forever is very good, and the story is very exciting.

The Man from Earth quotes

  • Dan: Time... you can't see it, you can hear it, you can't weigh it, you can't... measure it in a laboratory. It is a subjective sense of... becoming, what we... are, in stead of what we were a nanosecond ago, becoming what we will be in another nanosecond. The whole piece of time's a landscape existing, we form behind us and we move, we move through it... slice by slice.

    Linda Murphy: Clocks measure time.

    Dan: No, they measure themselves, the objective referee of a clock is another clock.

    Edith: All very interesting, but what has it got to do with John?

    Dan: He, he might be man who... lives... outside of time as we know it.

  • Dan: A medical test might be a way of proving of what you're saying

    John Oldman: I don't wanna prove it.

    Art: So, you're telling us this the yarn

    [?]

    Art: of the century and you don't care if we believe it or not?

    John Oldman: I guess I should've expected you to... You're not as crazy as you think I am.

    Edith: Amen!

    Sandy: I've always liked you.

    Edith: Well, thank you dear.

    Sandy: Well, that's changing.