Soul change, status reversal

Kiera 2022-04-22 07:01:05

The most excessive thing about this film is that there is only Motoko pheasant, only electronic human beings, and lacks the corresponding pure machine consciousness. In the movie version, there are puppet masters, in the TV version there is Tachikoma, and of course in the comics. Only when these characters exist, can the understanding of Ghost be more comprehensive. In the "live-action version", ghosts have become the exclusive use of human beings, which is obviously inferior. The performance of Ghost is also one-sided, losing the depth shown by comparison in other works.

The electronic prosthesis that Pheasant Motoko has become is also very similar to "Robot SWAT", and the erasure and implantation of memory is mixed with "Total Recall". The same is not enough for ghost, but it falls into the discussion of what is the "self". But those who have seen other works should know that this is definitely not the focus of the series, but it is very strange that this is the main conflict in "Live Action".

One thing that is commendable for the adaptation is that this film truly has a "punk" spirit. Nine Sections is a secret agency directly under the Prime Minister, an official violence agency with roots. If it is replaced in another work, the nine lessons should be the negative characters, the villains that the puppet master, the smiling man, and the hero Kuze are going to fight, and these marginal talents are more likely to become the protagonists of the story. However, in the "live-action version", what Suzi has to fight against has become a big company, and he is in a disadvantaged position, which means more "punk".

View more about Ghost in the Shell reviews

Extended Reading

Ghost in the Shell quotes

  • Batou: [Batou just got new eyes] Say something nice.

    Major: You chose those?

    Batou: They're tactical.

  • Major: Tell me who you are.

    Kuze: I am that which you seek to destroy. In this life, my name is Kuze.

    Major: What are you doing to me?

    Kuze: I have connected you to a network of my own creation. When I am finished in this world, my ghost can survive there and regenerate.

    Major: What do you want from me?

    Kuze: I became fascinated with you, reading your code while you were inside that geisha. Like nothing I had felt before and yet so... familiar. We are the same.

    Major: We are not the same. You kill innocent people.

    Kuze: "Innocent", is that what you call them? I am as they made me.

    Major: Who made you?

    Kuze: What have they told you? That you were the first? The first cerebral salvage? You were born of lessons took from my failure.

    Major: What are you talking about?

    Kuze: I was conscious while they dismembered my body and discarded me like garbage. I was lying on a table, listening to doctors talk about how my mind had not meshed with the shell that they had built, how Project 2571 had failed, and they had to move on to you.

    [removes a piece of Major's face]

    Kuze: What a beauty you are. They have improved us so much since they made me. They thought we would be a part of their evolution, but they have created us to evolve alone... beyond them.

    Major: "Evolution", that's what you call killing everyone who made you?

    Kuze: You're not listening to me.

    Major: You're a murderer.

    Kuze: They tried to kill me first. It is self-defense; defense of self! More will die until they tell me what they took!