Are Rose and daughter Sharon dead in the movie Silent Hill?

Davonte 2022-04-23 07:01:31

Rose left the church with her daughter Sharon, walked out of the town, and came to her car. She carried her daughter into the back seat of the car and then sat herself in the driver's seat. Rose started twice and the car didn't start. The camera cuts to a bird's-eye view, and the car moves, turning around and heading out of town. The car drove to the edge of the cliff of the dead end road, did not slow down, and drove directly over, the cliff disappeared, and it became a normal road. Seeing this, the audience may be relieved for Rose and her daughter, thinking they escaped Silent Hill.

On the way home, the thick fog in the air has not yet cleared, and those familiar with Hollywood horror movie routines know that the story is not over yet. Rose and her daughter returned to the "home", the house was empty, and there was still a thick fog outside. The camera cuts to Rose's husband Christopher. After a night of waiting, Christopher woke up from the sofa. He was alone in the room. There was only a noisy electric current on the recording phone, and there was no message from Rose. The sky outside the room was clear and the rain continued to fall. At this point, the video ends. Are Rose and daughter Sharon dead? Is it only their souls that return home? Some people think so, Rose and her daughter, as well as the female policewoman Siebel who followed, they are all dead, and the experience behind them is just that their souls are wandering in hell, trying to find their daughter. The reason is that Rose was in a car accident when she entered Silent Hill with her daughter. When Rose drove into Silent Hill, a figure flashed in front of the car. Rose was worried about hitting the other side and hurriedly turned the steering wheel. The car slid sideways and hit the cliff by the side of the road. died. The policewoman chased Rose on a motorcycle and had a car accident not far from where Rose crashed. At the end, when Rose drove away, a scene showed that the policewoman's motorcycle fell to the ground, and the guardrail on the side of the road was hit with a gap, and the policewoman may have fallen off the cliff and fell to her death. The policewoman chased Rose on a motorcycle and had a car accident not far from where Rose crashed. At the end, when Rose drove away, a scene showed that the policewoman's motorcycle fell to the ground, and the guardrail on the side of the road was hit with a gap, and the policewoman may have fallen off the cliff and fell to her death. There are too many logical holes in such an explanation to be clearly unconvincing and not what I would like to see. From several details of the movie, we can infer that Rose is not dead. Rose woke up after the crash and couldn't find her daughter who was sitting in the passenger seat. She walked into the town shrouded in thick fog and found that the town was empty, with ashes floating in the air like snowflakes. Just when Rose was puzzled, a figure in a blue dress flashed in the distance. She thought it was her daughter Sharon, and rushed over calling Sharon's name. The figure kept running, and Rose chased all the way to a basement. The air raid siren sounded outside, and many monsters appeared in the basement, surrounding Rose, who was so frightened that she escaped from the basement and returned to the car. At this time, the policewoman Siebel came over. Siebel believed that Rose was suspected of kidnapping the little girl, and handcuffed her and planned to take her back to the police station. A monster appeared on the hillside and came towards them. Siebel took out a pistol and pointed at the monster. Shots were fired and the monster was brought down. Seeing this, please imagine, if the policewoman Hibel is dead, how can there still be a pistol, and how can she still shoot? There were several places in the back where Hibel shot was fired, proving that Hibel was not dead at the time. In another scene, Rose's husband Christopher and another police officer also came to Silent Hill to find the missing policewoman Siebel. When Christopher and the police walk into a deserted restaurant, Christopher smells the scent left over from Rose's perfume, which he thinks she's been here before. The film tells us through alternate shots that Rose and policewoman Siebel have just visited this restaurant and left again. So the perfume that Christopher smells is real. If Rose dies, the scent of perfume will only stay around her body, indicating that Rose is not dead. Are Rose and Sharon alive? No, they are neither alive nor dead, rather, they are between life and death, trapped in a space. From the conversation between husband Christopher and the police after they reached Silent Hill, we can infer that they did not see Rose's car and policewoman Siebel's motorcycle on their way there. In addition, Silent Hill, where Christopher and the police are located, is sunny and sunny, and does not seem to be the same place as the foggy Silent Hill where Rose is. From this, we know that the place where Rose and policewoman Siebel had a car accident was not in the real world, they entered another dimension. In the second half of the film, Rose finds Eliza in the basement of the hospital, who is unrecognizable on the bed. Elissa is both Sharon's biological mother, Sharon herself, and the blue-dress figure Rose saw when she first entered town, and she is the cause of all this. Thirty years ago, a sinister event occurred in Silent Hill. The little girl Alisa is an illegitimate daughter who is often bullied by her classmates. Her aunt, Chris Bella, the bishop of a cult, thinks Alisa is a witch. Chris Bella deceived Elissa's mother, saying she would exorcise Elissa and take Elissa away. In the church, Chris Bella conducted the exorcism, and a large crowd of cultists watched. Elissa was tied to the stake, and a fire was set up below. At this time, an accident happened, and a strong wind blew in, causing a fire, and the scene was in chaos. Elisa was rescued by kindhearted people and taken to the hospital. Although Eliza was rescued, her whole body was scorched, there was no intact skin on her body, and her whole body was covered with bandages. There will also be pistols, how can you still shoot? There were several places in the back where Hibel shot was fired, proving that Hibel was not dead at the time. In another scene, Rose's husband Christopher and another police officer also came to Silent Hill to find the missing policewoman Siebel. When Christopher and the police walk into a deserted restaurant, Christopher smells the scent left over from Rose's perfume, which he thinks she's been here before. The film tells us through alternate shots that Rose and policewoman Siebel have just visited this restaurant and left again. So the perfume that Christopher smells is real. If Rose dies, the scent of perfume will only stay around her body, indicating that Rose is not dead. Are Rose and Sharon alive? No, they are neither alive nor dead, rather, they are between life and death, trapped in a space. From the conversation between husband Christopher and the police after they reached Silent Hill, we can infer that they did not see Rose's car and policewoman Siebel's motorcycle on their way there. In addition, Silent Hill, where Christopher and the police are located, is sunny and sunny, and does not seem to be the same place as the foggy Silent Hill where Rose is. From this, we know that the place where Rose and policewoman Siebel had a car accident was not in the real world, they entered another dimension. In the second half of the film, Rose finds Eliza in the basement of the hospital, who is unrecognizable on the bed. Elissa is both Sharon's biological mother, Sharon herself, and the blue-dress figure Rose saw when she first entered town, and she is the cause of all this. Thirty years ago, a sinister event occurred in Silent Hill. The little girl Alisa is an illegitimate daughter who is often bullied by her classmates. Her aunt, Chris Bella, the bishop of a cult, thinks Alisa is a witch. Chris Bella deceived Elissa's mother, saying she would exorcise Elissa and take Elissa away. In the church, Chris Bella conducted the exorcism, and a large crowd of cultists watched. Elissa was tied to the stake, and a fire was set up below. At this time, an accident happened, and a strong wind blew in, causing a fire, and the scene was in chaos. Elisa was rescued by kindhearted people and taken to the hospital. Although Eliza was rescued, her whole body was scorched, there was no intact skin on her body, and her whole body was covered with bandages. There will also be pistols, how can you still shoot? There were several places in the back where Hibel shot was fired, proving that Hibel was not dead at the time. In another scene, Rose's husband Christopher and another police officer also came to Silent Hill to find the missing policewoman Siebel. When Christopher and the police walk into a deserted restaurant, Christopher smells the scent left over from Rose's perfume, which he thinks she's been here before. The film tells us through alternate shots that Rose and policewoman Siebel have just visited this restaurant and left again. So the perfume that Christopher smells is real. If Rose dies, the scent of perfume will only stay around her body, indicating that Rose is not dead. Are Rose and Sharon alive? No, they are neither alive nor dead, rather, they are between life and death, trapped in a space. From the conversation between husband Christopher and the police after they reached Silent Hill, we can infer that they did not see Rose's car and policewoman Siebel's motorcycle on their way there. In addition, Silent Hill, where Christopher and the police are located, is sunny and sunny, and does not seem to be the same place as the foggy Silent Hill where Rose is. From this, we know that the place where Rose and policewoman Siebel had a car accident was not in the real world, they entered another dimension. In the second half of the film, Rose finds Eliza in the basement of the hospital, who is unrecognizable on the bed. Elissa is both Sharon's biological mother, Sharon herself, and the blue-dress figure Rose saw when she first entered town, and she is the cause of all this. Thirty years ago, a sinister event occurred in Silent Hill. The little girl Alisa is an illegitimate daughter who is often bullied by her classmates. Her aunt, Chris Bella, the bishop of a cult, thinks Alisa is a witch. Chris Bella deceived Elissa's mother, saying she would exorcise Elissa and take Elissa away. In the church, Chris Bella conducted the exorcism, and a large crowd of cultists watched. Elissa was tied to the stake, and a fire was set up below. At this time, an accident happened, and a strong wind blew in, causing a fire, and the scene was in chaos. Elisa was rescued by kindhearted people and taken to the hospital. Although Eliza was rescued, her whole body was scorched, there was no intact skin on her body, and her whole body was covered with bandages. Jingling, the police are looking for the missing policewoman Siebel. When Christopher and the police walk into a deserted restaurant, Christopher smells the scent left over from Rose's perfume, which he thinks she's been here before. The film tells us through alternate shots that Rose and policewoman Siebel have just visited this restaurant and left again. So the perfume that Christopher smells is real. If Rose dies, the scent of perfume will only stay around her body, indicating that Rose is not dead. Are Rose and Sharon alive? No, they are neither alive nor dead, rather, they are between life and death, trapped in a space. From the conversation between husband Christopher and the police after they reached Silent Hill, we can infer that they did not see Rose's car and policewoman Siebel's motorcycle on their way there. In addition, Silent Hill, where Christopher and the police are located, is sunny and sunny, and does not seem to be the same place as the foggy Silent Hill where Rose is. From this, we know that the place where Rose and policewoman Siebel had a car accident was not in the real world, they entered another dimension. In the second half of the film, Rose finds Eliza in the basement of the hospital, who is unrecognizable on the bed. Elissa is both Sharon's biological mother, Sharon herself, and the blue-dress figure Rose saw when she first entered town, and she is the cause of all this. Thirty years ago, a sinister event occurred in Silent Hill. The little girl Alisa is an illegitimate daughter who is often bullied by her classmates. Her aunt, Chris Bella, the bishop of a cult, thinks Alisa is a witch. Chris Bella deceived Elissa's mother, saying she would exorcise Elissa and take Elissa away. In the church, Chris Bella conducted the exorcism, and a large crowd of cultists watched. Elissa was tied to the stake, and a fire was set up below. At this time, an accident happened, and a strong wind blew in, causing a fire, and the scene was in chaos. Elisa was rescued by kindhearted people and taken to the hospital. Although Eliza was rescued, her whole body was scorched, there was no intact skin on her body, and her whole body was covered with bandages. Jingling, the police are looking for the missing policewoman Siebel. When Christopher and the police walk into a deserted restaurant, Christopher smells the scent left over from Rose's perfume, which he thinks she's been here before. The film tells us through alternate shots that Rose and policewoman Siebel have just visited this restaurant and left again. So the perfume that Christopher smells is real. If Rose dies, the scent of perfume will only stay around her body, indicating that Rose is not dead. Are Rose and Sharon alive? No, they are neither alive nor dead, rather, they are between life and death, trapped in a space. From the conversation between husband Christopher and the police after they reached Silent Hill, we can infer that they did not see Rose's car and policewoman Siebel's motorcycle on their way there. In addition, Silent Hill, where Christopher and the police are located, is sunny and sunny, and does not seem to be the same place as the foggy Silent Hill where Rose is. From this, we know that the place where Rose and policewoman Siebel had a car accident was not in the real world, they entered another dimension. In the second half of the film, Rose finds Eliza in the basement of the hospital, who is unrecognizable on the bed. Elissa is both Sharon's biological mother, Sharon herself, and the blue-dress figure Rose saw when she first entered town, and she is the cause of all this. Thirty years ago, a sinister event occurred in Silent Hill. The little girl Alisa is an illegitimate daughter who is often bullied by her classmates. Her aunt, Chris Bella, the bishop of a cult, thinks Alisa is a witch. Chris Bella deceived Elissa's mother, saying she would exorcise Elissa and take Elissa away. In the church, Chris Bella conducted the exorcism, and a large crowd of cultists watched. Elissa was tied to the stake, and a fire was set up below. At this time, an accident happened, and a strong wind blew in, causing a fire, and the scene was in chaos. Elisa was rescued by kindhearted people and taken to the hospital. Although Eliza was rescued, her whole body was scorched, there was no intact skin on her body, and her whole body was covered with bandages. The smell will only stay around her body, indicating that Rose is not dead. Are Rose and Sharon alive? No, they are neither alive nor dead, rather, they are between life and death, trapped in a space. From the conversation between husband Christopher and the police after they reached Silent Hill, we can infer that they did not see Rose's car and policewoman Siebel's motorcycle on their way there. In addition, Silent Hill, where Christopher and the police are located, is sunny and sunny, and does not seem to be the same place as the foggy Silent Hill where Rose is. From this, we know that the place where Rose and policewoman Siebel had a car accident was not in the real world, they entered another dimension. In the second half of the film, Rose finds Eliza in the basement of the hospital, who is unrecognizable on the bed. Elissa is both Sharon's biological mother, Sharon herself, and the blue-dress figure Rose saw when she first entered town, and she is the cause of all this. Thirty years ago, a sinister event occurred in Silent Hill. The little girl Alisa is an illegitimate daughter who is often bullied by her classmates. Her aunt, Chris Bella, the bishop of a cult, thinks Alisa is a witch. Chris Bella deceived Elissa's mother, saying she would exorcise Elissa and take Elissa away. In the church, Chris Bella conducted the exorcism, and a large crowd of cultists watched. Elissa was tied to the stake, and a fire was set up below. At this time, an accident happened, and a strong wind blew in, causing a fire, and the scene was in chaos. Elisa was rescued by kindhearted people and taken to the hospital. Although Eliza was rescued, her whole body was scorched, there was no intact skin on her body, and her whole body was covered with bandages. The smell will only stay around her body, indicating that Rose is not dead. Are Rose and Sharon alive? No, they are neither alive nor dead, rather, they are between life and death, trapped in a space. From the conversation between husband Christopher and the police after they reached Silent Hill, we can infer that they did not see Rose's car and policewoman Siebel's motorcycle on their way there. In addition, Silent Hill, where Christopher and the police are located, is sunny and sunny, and does not seem to be the same place as the foggy Silent Hill where Rose is. From this, we know that the place where Rose and policewoman Siebel had a car accident was not in the real world, they entered another dimension. In the second half of the film, Rose finds Eliza in the basement of the hospital, who is unrecognizable on the bed. Elissa is both Sharon's biological mother, Sharon herself, and the blue-dress figure Rose saw when she first entered town, and she is the cause of all this. Thirty years ago, a sinister event occurred in Silent Hill. The little girl Alisa is an illegitimate daughter who is often bullied by her classmates. Her aunt, Chris Bella, the bishop of a cult, thinks Alisa is a witch. Chris Bella deceived Elissa's mother, saying she would exorcise Elissa and take Elissa away. In the church, Chris Bella conducted the exorcism, and a large crowd of cultists watched. Elissa was tied to the stake, and a fire was set up below. At this time, an accident happened, and a strong wind blew in, causing a fire, and the scene was in chaos. Elisa was rescued by kindhearted people and taken to the hospital. Although Eliza was rescued, her whole body was scorched, there was no intact skin on her body, and her whole body was covered with bandages. The figure in the blue dress, she is the cause of all this. Thirty years ago, a sinister event occurred in Silent Hill. The little girl Alisa is an illegitimate daughter who is often bullied by her classmates. Her aunt, Chris Bella, the bishop of a cult, thinks Alisa is a witch. Chris Bella deceived Elissa's mother, saying she would exorcise Elissa and take Elissa away. In the church, Chris Bella conducted the exorcism, and a large crowd of cultists watched. Elissa was tied to the stake, and a fire was set up below. At this time, an accident happened, and a strong wind blew in, causing a fire, and the scene was in chaos. Elisa was rescued by kindhearted people and taken to the hospital. Although Eliza was rescued, her whole body was scorched, there was no intact skin on her body, and her whole body was covered with bandages. The figure in the blue dress, she is the cause of all this. Thirty years ago, a sinister event occurred in Silent Hill. The little girl Alisa is an illegitimate daughter who is often bullied by her classmates. Her aunt, Chris Bella, the bishop of a cult, thinks Alisa is a witch. Chris Bella deceived Elissa's mother, saying she would exorcise Elissa and take Elissa away. In the church, Chris Bella conducted the exorcism, and a large crowd of cultists watched. Elissa was tied to the stake, and a fire was set up below. At this time, an accident happened, and a strong wind blew in, causing a fire, and the scene was in chaos. Elisa was rescued by kindhearted people and taken to the hospital. Although Eliza was rescued, her whole body was scorched, there was no intact skin on her body, and her whole body was covered with bandages.

Affected by pain and anger, Eliza developed a powerful resentment and summoned the power of darkness. This force enveloped the entire Silent Hill, forming an abyss all around. Those who have hurt her, are trapped in this space, and for these people, they have disappeared from the real world, their time is always stuck in that moment, and they will always be in fear. This is Silent Hill. It is not the world of the living, nor the hell after death. Perhaps it is what we often call "hell on earth". Rose helped Alisa fulfill her wish and took revenge on all those who had hurt Alisa. She took her daughter Sharon out of Silent Hill, but they couldn't leave the space that Alisa made. At the end of the film, although Rose and her daughter Sharon and her husband Christopher are in the same home, they can feel each other's presence, but they can't see each other. This is the most terrifying part of this horror movie.

View more about Silent Hill reviews

Extended Reading

Silent Hill quotes

  • Rose Da Silva: You've darkened the heart of an innocent and now you cower in the face of Alessa's revenge.

  • Dark Alessa: When you're hurt and scared for so long, the fear and pain turn to hate and the hate starts to change the world.