too much pain

Emerson 2022-04-23 07:01:37

This is the shadow of thousands of broken families, and
this is a choice that thousands of people cannot give up.

I don't know the political system of Iran, and this
film is the most objective evaluation so far without reference to major film critics.

The role of a man in the family is a link, perhaps, so to speak.
For the sake of his daughter, he could lie and say that he didn't know about the volunteer's pregnancy; for the
sake of his father, he resolutely let his daughter go with her mother.
He couldn't give up his daughter, and he had to take care of his father with filial piety.

Perhaps, he is a qualified father.
After being questioned by his daughter in every possible way,
he said that he knew that the volunteer was pregnant,
and asked her daughter's opinion.
If his daughter agrees,
he can go to the judge and say that
he does know that the volunteer is pregnant.

The film seems to put morality very low.
When the volunteer told his wife that it was because of his father that he was hit by a car and had a stomachache and the child died,
the brilliance of morality seemed to be very high.

The background of the film seems to be only in the Arab countries.
Their fidelity to the Koran is much higher than the Bible,
so it is impossible for such a film to be remade in China.

Ordinarily, the protagonist's family economy is still good,
at least in comparison with the Celestial Dynasty, it is considered a moderately prosperous level.
The husband and wife each have a car to drive, and they
dare to open their mouths and spend money when something goes wrong.
But relative to the protagonist,
the family financial situation of the volunteers is worrying.
Her husband's performance is testing the bottom line of morality again, with
a stance of breaking the jar, and not afraid of wearing shoes with bare feet.
In this way, it performed very well.
This is the performance of a poor family!

Talk to the lady.
quite pretty.
Yearning for a more free life,
although her husband complained about being afraid of things and being inactive,
she definitely loves her husband.
When she learned that her husband was in difficulty, she immediately spent money on bail, and
even if she left with her luggage, she just returned to her parents' home.
I learned from my daughter that
as long as her husband is willing to ask her, she will come back, and the
luggage is already in the car and waiting to be picked up.

The role of the daughter is the sunshine of the film, and
no one wants the ties in life to be entangled in the children who are studying hard and in adolescence.
The little girl performed well, she was the director's daughter!

The fuse of this film, grandpa.
Although there are not many lines in the film,
what affects the whole plot is the emotion that is more valued by the Orientals.
Or, this is a "filial piety" word.
In the film, I always have a question,
is there no nursing home in Iran?
Or deliberately shape the story to omit the table?
The male protagonist fell on his father's back and cried bitterly.
This part is very touching.

Finally, the daughter's answer.
I personally prefer her to choose father.
Of course, this is also a portrait of my heart.
But I don't seem to be as good as the daughter's mind in the film.
Maybe they hope that their parents will go in and look for her when they haven't been out for so long
!

View more about A Separation reviews

Extended Reading

A Separation quotes

  • Termeh: Didn't you say it's not serious?

    Nader: It got serious.

  • Simin: Does he even realize you are his son?

    Nader: I know he is my father!