between lies and truth

Giles 2022-04-21 09:01:40

This is a somewhat offbeat Iranian film: hand-held camerawork, ditching the soundtrack, and a lot of dialogue to advance the plot, with a touch of the Danes and Ken Loach; but it's a typical Iranian film, still keeping its focus The precious spirit of reality. The cultural contradiction between the East and the West, the moral dilemma between religion and modern society, the alienation and misunderstanding of interpersonal relationships in society and the family, and the resulting anger and harm, as shown in the film, have a profound impact on fans of the transformation and transformation of the third world. For the Chinese people in the bureau, they all have the same experience.

"A Separation" begins with a middle-class couple who are about to divorce, and corresponds it to another poor couple who come to their family to help. The director only omitted two scenes, and calmly constructed a simple and trivial family life story into a Hitchcock-style suspense: how did the pregnant woman who came to be a maid fall and miscarry? Did she take the owner's money? As the director moves meticulously and slowly, we see the protagonists struggling against each other, thinking there is no harm, thinking they can break free. Almost everyone is caught between the lie and the truth, as if the hero taught his daughter that she would rather offend the teacher and read the right words, but he himself lied to the judge: everyone has a good reason to tell a lie, Feeling like a victim who should be sympathized with. Under the lens of peaceful life, a breath of anxiety, doubt, calculation, and despair in the society secretly came.

"Separation" in the English title means separation and isolation. The film shows a separation between belief and modernity, a separation between the middle class and the common people, and a separation between law and morality. But the director uses the most authentic documentary style to let the audience participate in it, to experience it, and to think about it, so that it is possible to break the isolation.

View more about A Separation reviews

Extended Reading
  • Lorine 2022-03-21 09:01:37

    A storm of personal relationships caused by a separation. Concise and powerful, popular and smooth, it tells a story that seems ordinary and contradictory and complex that can happen to everyone. 2 hours to hold on tightly to the person. Another GREAT DRAMA in film history, a great melodrama!

  • Dion 2022-03-22 09:01:31

    The last scene of Iranian movies always makes me feel lost and stunned for a long time. The depths of the scene are full of people in this country who are still struggling to defend their own living space due to the gap between the rich and the poor, religion and race, anxiously waiting for a broken mirror while the baby is crying. At the end of , a few sad piano sounds rose silently with the subtitles. Oscar has no reason to reject a good third-world low-budget film, and it is worth reflecting that our top production can be easily won without bloodshed.

A Separation quotes

  • Hodjat: [to Nader] Shame on you! You call yourself a man?

  • Nader: I went there cause I have a sense of humanity.

    Hodjat: where was your sense of humanity when you were hitting her ?