The Tribe

By Dallas 2022-12-25 23:21:49

A great plate filled with overnight vegetables-I might still use cooking oil

MoMA
New Directors/New Films 2015
March 18-29, 2015


"The Tribe | Deaf Tribe" should be the hottest and coldest part of the "New Directors/New Films 2015" series that MoMA just concluded. The story takes place in a depressed boarding school for deaf teenagers in Kiev, Ukraine. The film has no dialogue, no subtitles, and no soundtrack. The advancement of the story and the communication of characters are all based on dazzling sign language expression.

Nearly half...

By Elmira 2022-12-17 16:25:56

The director’s author style is the strongest

This film strongly proves that film, as a kind of image art, can definitely overcome language barriers, which is unmatched by literary works. Just imagine, if you don’t understand French, where do you start reading a Camus novel? But in the face of the unique and wonderful art form of film, even if you don't understand the language in the film, you can still roughly understand the plot through the body posture and facial expressions of the characters in the play. The Ukrainian director can...

By Albert 2022-12-17 13:20:19

After stripping the language

Although there are no subtitles, I can understand it, but I feel like I'm just wearing the gimmick of deaf and dumb, and the content in it seems a little empty and poor. The director's expression is very novel, so all three points are given the form of expression. The director attempts to discuss the repression and violence of human nature in a calm tone. This is not the world of deaf-mute people, but the original appearance of the world, the original appearance of people, but when there is no...

By Enos 2022-12-15 10:27:52

Too quiet hustle and bustle

(Fifty-ninth issue) Dayin niche film group viewing meeting

-Deaf-mute tribe

Too-quiet hustle and bustle, 130-minute documentary-style images, calm, straightforward, and naked, a “tribe” of deaf-mute people, using the most...

By Troy 2022-12-05 18:26:32

Too noisy loneliness

I have been curious about a question since I was very young

Is the world in the eyes of others the same as mine?

I still believe that the world that everyone sees is different

For example, Van Gogh is a lunatic, his world should be a mental hospital, right?

People with Alzheimer's disease see a new world every time they open their eyes, right?

I'm a weak color. Isn't...

By Hermann 2023-09-09 09:25:18

Suppressed sex, silent violence, and voice are not the determinants of desperation in a...

By Guiseppe 2023-09-08 12:30:18

5. I was frightened by the cruel camera, and my head hurt at the end. The setting is a bit funny, and it also brings out a little style. But it didn't make me feel everything I should have felt through this lens. It may be sign language and complete speechlessness by the camera or separated by a layer. It is quite embarrassing to watch third-level movies in...

By Ladarius 2023-09-06 15:31:22

"In the deaf-mute world, as long as you open your eyes, what you see is the truth", "Most of the cameras are on the side and back, and most of the time it's a distant view. There is always some gap between the movie and the audience. More like an observer, the good thing is that the long shot lengthens the inner torment of the characters to the greatest extent, and the atmosphere without dialogue or soundtrack expands its blank space, which is solemn and...

By Dell 2023-08-10 08:10:07

An experimental movie worthy of praise. All emotions are amplified silently, love and hate are extreme and violent. The title "Tribe" is particularly clever-when the teacher and school symbolizing order withdrew from sight in the first 10 minutes, all that was left was the cruel tribal ecology. The abrupt end is like a cone of ice piercing the heart, making people feel...

By Syble 2023-07-17 14:52:08

No subtitles, can't read. The crowd is...