Land and Freedom Comments

Fatima 2022-09-24 12:12:29

Win with a rich story. Franco's regime reminds me of an all-metal casing, the tin hat the joker wears says born to kill, and the peace pin is pinned to his chest. People change based on what they see and experience, I absolutely believe that. Just like david, his story is also a portrayal of many revolutionaries at that time in the torrent, persecuted by Franco, and torn with Stalinist "red fascists". There is a POUM meeting to discuss the land issue. It is very interesting. I think back to the...

Lois 2022-09-15 02:05:00

8/10. After the militia occupied the church, there was a lot of discussion about whether to implement the public ownership of land. From this scene, the film really entered the core theme of Ken Loch: what kind of social system can achieve equality for all, not a slogan to suppress the opposition. David became the epitome of the Spanish civil war: when the anti-fascism and the same enemy were fighting, the barricades in Madrid were shot all over the world. Those who voted for true freedom and...

Nakia 2022-09-14 22:11:35

Passionate blood and passion are sacrificed at the feet of political...

Abigayle 2022-09-14 03:30:40

"A tribute to Catalonia", the former pride and enthusiasm have been turned into bones, full of enthusiasm and used ruthlessly. Under the complex pattern of the changing king of the city, the "revolution" has long lost its original innocence and reduced to a mutual political power. The superior means of fighting, squeezing, and squeezing out, the so-called "civil war in civil war" is even more chilling and desperate. It is always the naivety of idealists who are defeated. Stalin was hacked...

Durward 2022-09-04 21:22:20

In addition to the embarrassing war scenes in anti-Japanese dramas, the richness and complexity of ideological discussions are very enlightening. The big story goes in and out to see the political landscape of this land in a specific era. I really liked the long table meeting in the church. The quarrel over public ownership had a big impact on me. I couldn’t believe that the ranks of the Communist militia could be so Europeanized, and they could even discuss the issue of public ownership with...

Kaylee 2022-09-02 13:06:18

Not to mention the redundant historical details, the moment the party membership card was torn apart, the male protagonist transformed into a real revolutionary fighter, who fought and sacrificed for the most noble cause of mankind, and was a noble...

Martine 2022-06-06 22:26:56

It doesn't matter to the Stalinists, but even the international column is black, which makes me a little suspicious of the film's tendency. Besides, few people really think that Trotskyist organizations can succeed. Speaking of which, if there is any way to learn, replace the guerrillas of the Ma Tong Labor Party with Tubal Road, the Republican Government with the National Government, and the Franco Fascism with the Japanese Fascism... Xiaoyou will probably have to scold his mother after seeing...

Leola 2022-06-06 18:34:28

7.5 Pure idealists are fragile and powerless before real politics, but it is the light of that precious ideal that illuminates the human society in the corrupted man-made politics and gives it a chance of redemption; history has never Belongs to the "people". The blood of the people nourishes the careerists and becomes a pawn for them to gain power. The sacrifice of the people builds the foundation of power and feeds the flies. People do something not because it is right. Yes, but to prove that...

Scotty 2022-06-06 14:53:43

The excitement, blood and tears, pride and sadness of the revolution are not only history and homesickness, but also the promised and yet to come...

Donnell 2022-06-06 11:35:41

Some plots really resemble Orwell's experience: accidentally joining the Social Labor Party of Horses, child-like training, no war for several weeks, and the two factions confronted each other in high-rise buildings. It was not fascism that defeated the idealists, it was the ugly political...