Ivan's Childhood Comments

Josie 2022-09-08 00:17:09

4.5 Ivan's peace dream and war reality are switched in two different worlds. The dream is full of quiet and vigorous life, like the slow-flowing river, and the war part is almost filled with dialogue (I realize that if you remove the lines, you can't see it. Got the feeling) The gunshots and flares almost never stopped. Strong contrast. The run on the beach at the end was so moving... Absolutely amazing! I just feel like talking too...

Dax 2022-09-06 03:25:51

A section of birch forest is so beautiful. The film is full of tension in the time dimension, or magic. The first time I saw the old tower, I was firmly attracted. . . . Is this called engraving...

Jamil 2022-04-24 07:01:17

The melody of the opening chapter is reminiscent of Zhao Jiping's "Reed Dang", which is too similar; the star in the well, the kiss in the air; the mirror; the inclined cross; The production team should be quite strong, and sorrow and beauty can be controlled easily; "They told Masha not to cross that river, they told Masha not to fall in love with that young...

Addison 2022-04-24 07:01:17

I dreamed of that scene, apples and horses rolling down the river beach on the truck. Recalling that I went to the abandoned windmill on the Dnieper River last spring, this was the first shot of the...

Bailee 2022-04-24 07:01:17

Three and a half. Probably due to the subject matter, it is lighter than the later works. The photography, dreams, and ending are amazing, nothing else to like. Finally finished the feature film... Mirror > Sacrifice > Nostalgia > Stalker > Flying to Space > Andrei Rublev > Ivan's...

Ulises 2022-04-24 07:01:17

The cruelty of the dream real war is reflected in the child. The content of the children's game in the dark is also...

Crawford 2022-04-24 07:01:17

① In the 3rd dream, Ivan's child image is highlighted under the image of his mother. After waking up, the cruel war reality beat him back to the image of a "warrior". The contrast between the dream and reality is strong. ② The imaginary battle in the dark ③ After the victory of the war, The time and space echo of the ruins of the prison induces the audience to imagine the infinite beautiful scene at the end, mother, partner, beach, sea water, sunshine. The marshland scene is...

Bernadette 2022-04-24 07:01:17

The reality and dreams of the young Ivan are intertwined, and the structure is unconventional. He told the scouts that he fought until the last moment to hang himself, and there was no fierce battle or killing, nor did he preach the final victory of World War II, but profoundly reflect on the war. It can be noted that the tracking camera of the guide tower, the first vision cuts into the nurse Masha's heart, and her love is completely permeated in the birch forest. You can also see Ivan's...

Rosemary 2022-04-24 07:01:17

The representative work of Tarkovsky, the representative work of Soviet cinema. Poetry film representative, a lot of long shots, I think it's not...

Lane 2022-04-24 07:01:17

Perhaps because this is a work of Tarkovsky in his early years, the plot is still very strong, but we can already see his later classic mirror movements and the way of expressing some images, especially the dreams intertwined with memories , with the same strong expressiveness as Hitchcock but more poetic. Ivan's story itself is simple, and Tarkovsky just used it as an...