Ida Comments

Darion 2022-03-28 09:01:07

It has been infinitely approaching the modeling consciousness of the silent film era (the beginning part), but it is difficult not to fall asleep when I see it at the end, all the historical information and the emotional relationship of the characters are flowing eastward, diluting into the...

Perry 2022-03-28 09:01:07

There is a temperament called "determination" that permeates the whole film, including the film itself, the heroine characters, and the creators of the film. They all know what they...

Scot 2022-03-28 09:01:07

7/10. The theme of uncovering the scars of the nation often cannot be directly portrayed, and the most commonly used and often cliché narrative technique is to excavate a dusty and cruel memory from the side to explore the influence of the dead on the living. The academic technique is very eye-catching, the scenes of emotional foreshadowing and atmosphere are minimized, and the reflection of the film is also hidden like Ida's beautiful red hair, and the oral confession is no better than a news...

Charity 2022-03-28 09:01:07

There is a lot of white space, perhaps because the topics covered are too complicated. Photography is the highlight, whether you like it or not varies from person to person. The film has the same calm temperament as Ada, and it is easy for the audience to immerse in it. For Ada: Her growth is not addition, but...

Santina 2022-03-25 09:01:13

From this film to "Cold War", director Paviu Pawlikowski's parents' era and their experiences have always been a source of inspiration for his creation. There is so much to say about Poland in that era. Watching these two films cannot be separated from the background of reality. "Sister Ada" is even more obvious. A large number of fixed shots seem to be intentionally alienating the audience, always maintaining a distance of observation without intervention, which is difficult to capture from...

Dave 2022-03-25 09:01:13

From this film to "Cold War", director Paviu Pawlikowski's parents' era and their experiences have always been a source of inspiration for his creation. There is so much to say about Poland in that era. Watching these two films cannot be separated from the background of reality. "Sister Ada" is even more obvious. A large number of fixed shots seem to be intentionally alienating the audience, always maintaining a distance of observation without intervention, which is difficult to capture from...

Fidel 2022-03-23 09:02:30

The black and white images are beautiful, but they fail to advance the...

Chesley 2022-03-23 09:02:30

Okay. The first time I went to the old house to reveal that the couple was hidden by the family was quite dramatic, and other scenes were too peaceful. The heroine inexplicably looks very spring and...

Eldridge 2022-03-23 09:02:30

The distorted composition of the characters accumulates a visual sense of a different world, and forms an incongruous contradiction between the plain text and the individual and leaps to measure the historical backflow. Like a dying soul roaming the ruins of a city, abandoning the far-flung homeland feelings and cultivating a universal thinking greenhouse is a misstep of choice; while refusing to communicate with the audience, it also refuses to explain redemption and...

Brice 2022-03-23 09:02:30

Paradoxically, what I feel deeply is not the heaviness of history/religion or anything else, but the emptiness of the city that floats around. When I used composition to express the relationship between people and space, I did not "move" me from any dimension. There is only a sense of confusion in time and space as if watching an urban movie, which may be because it is too hard to carve so that there is no...