Ida Comments

Jamil 2021-12-26 08:01:32

From the perspective of the creativity of the play, it is doing a great anti-narrative attempt, removing the usual narrative techniques in the drama, abandoning the things that are in the plot, and choosing to use the head-up camera angle to present it, even the psychological pavement of the characters The scenes of the movie have been weakened, even facing the historical figures who slaughtered the Jews, they were calm and calm. In the end, even the growth of the nun Ida finally chose to go...

Eloy 2021-12-26 08:01:32

Photography is so...

Matilda 2021-12-26 08:01:32

Was the photography successful? How did I feel that it was a failure, the core of the whole film was taken away by it. I probably saw a little real simplicity in the end, but it was immediately extinguished by the background piano music. This is actually an interesting aesthetic paradox: Simplicity is based on the sublation of complexity. If simplicity is represented by simplicity, it may not only be empty but also...

Green 2021-12-26 08:01:32

The photographic composition is really breathtakingly beautiful, and many traces of old films have been found, but the plot is as pale as...

Hester 2021-12-26 08:01:32

Insulted and damaged Poland. After the Nazis and communism were cut off, secular happiness became more valuable. Quiet and calm, the lens promotes the narrative, which can become a model for film composition, but it is not necessary to be black and...

Trystan 2021-12-26 08:01:32

Photography is only limited to the concept of "composition", and the large amount of top space that appears is actually meaningless, purely for good-looking and cool (I thought it only appeared in the nun space, but later found out that it was used casually), basically nothing New ideas, posturing is...

Letha 2021-12-26 08:01:32

The characters are deliberately arranged in the lower third of the frame. The large amount of blank space creates desolate and solemn visual and emotional; the composition is very particular, and even tends to be obsessive-compulsive, which always echoes religious metaphors and current events; the nature in the black and white pictures The light is very comfortable to see; I won’t pursue the pale of the...

Alia 2021-12-26 08:01:32

Typical opaque film. Just like using a fixed lens, what is in the lens and what is outside the lens; what do you hear and what you didn't hear; what did the director shoot, and what is there in history? Perhaps, at the end, the two heroines exchanged a bit of mundaneity and sacredness. However, all the people criticized "photography overwhelming the audience", which made me feel that I must have a five-star rating. To transpose to the perspective of the creator, it is better to say "carving"...

Kyra 2021-12-26 08:01:32

The director is indeed suspected of speculation, and there are naked metaphors, but the effect of the film is not bad: the composition and lighting of the black and white photography have been carefully considered, and the fixed position is the same as the still life photography, until the final two movements are used. At the end of the lens, there is a hint of thunder on the ground; the wounds and healing of war, the collapse and reconstruction of faith, and the stories inside and outside the...

Jonatan 2021-12-26 08:01:32

A masterpiece of subtle, restrained but profound connotation. Black and white photography + 4:3 frame, all cameras are still camera except for the end; the composition is beautiful, the characters are off-center and marginalized as normal, which not only reflects the fragility and smallness of the human heart under the weight of history and reality, but also has ink paintings. White charm; excellent soundtrack; slow rhythm, little dialogue but large amount of information; it is recommended to...