Hillbilly Elegy Comments

Halie 2022-03-19 09:01:07

I personally think that the original novel should have a higher conception, and the discussion of American class consolidation should also be more profound; the film does not deal with the "big view" aspect very well, but it is only regarded as a family chronicle, in my opinion I have passed the test in my heart, and Amy is really good at acting, it is still worth...

Melisa 2022-03-19 09:01:07

I feel that many of the problems that people criticize the film are the problems of the original work itself. But lyricism also has the value of lyricism, so there is no need to demand the...

Erna 2022-03-19 09:01:07

This kind of primitive family is terrible, because I have been a soldier, so I know that there are actually many red-necked families with this kind of family background. I was uncomfortable watching the movie, and at the same time I sighed that I was lucky. Then it suddenly occurred to me that the minimum wage in Texas is actually less than eight dollars... not at the bottom of the society, you may never understand the pain of being...

Tess 2022-03-19 09:01:07

The red-necked poor family should be regarded as one of the least filmed subjects in the United States but a large number of subjects in real life. The reason for the lack of filming is probably because the poverty of white people in developed countries is nothing new, and the protagonist is often unable to change anything. After all, poverty is the greatest Evil... This film is a typical example, and everyone seems unpleasant or even disgusting; if the story focuses on showing the positive...

Jarret 2022-03-18 09:01:05

Very good, the grandmother played the best, but aa's performance was not enough for the original taste of the red neck, the theme was not deep enough, and only the drug problem was described. In fact, the book itself does not discuss it in depth. What else can be done? The United States is naked capitalism, and the economy is no longer in the past. This kind of system cannot benefit more people, and there will be no major changes. It is essentially unsolvable. More and more states are making...

Alexandria 2022-03-18 09:01:05

In fact, it is a very routine plot and rhythm, but still can't help crying. If you can understand the historical background and this group of "atypical" whites, you may be able to understand this "elegy"...

Merritt 2022-03-17 09:01:06

Watching this movie is like looking in a mirror, crying many times, and recalling many things at home in the past. I thought of my aunt and told me that she was admitted to the best high school in the city. In order to make money quickly, she chose to go to a vocational school. I think of my cousin, sinking into a computer game, not even finishing high school. I think of myself. At a certain moment in junior high school, I didn't want to be a worker in this small city or get caught up in the...

Dwight 2022-03-17 09:01:06

The overall look and feel is stronger than that of "A Place of Nowhere", which can be regarded as an enhanced version of "Everything is Good." Obviously speaking about the gap between the rich and the poor and the problem of class consolidation in American society, how did you finally make the inspirational film "Harvard Road in Wind and Rain"? Hollywood's discourse system does not have a vocabulary for the red neck. Only when it is transformed into identity politics (feminism) can it be...

Lyla 2022-03-16 09:01:05

This level of biographical photography is indeed disappointing, and it is relatively easy for Ron. The problem of the original family should of course be presented with great effort, but first of all, what is your background? How did the leading actor achieve class leaping through his own efforts? How did his mentality change? How did the lives of mother and grandmother lead to this? These issues have been largely omitted, and the final result is relatively flat, with no emotional strength at...

Casey 2022-03-16 09:01:05

Seeing the death penalty-style bad reviews of Rotten Tomatoes and MTC, the expectations have been reduced to a very low level, but the result is completely moved, and the annual five-best schedule is scheduled. The tragedy of the country folks is the scar literature written by foul language, hysterical screams, and inescapable wounds. Everything about it is about the migration of landscapes and memories: from Yale University and the brightly lit metropolis, to the childhood growing up From...