A Star Is Born Comments

Kasandra 2022-04-22 07:01:55

Judy Wonderful...

Rosetta 2022-04-22 07:01:55

The story of La La Land feels a bit like this one, but this one has a lot more depth. The heroine turned out to be Judy Garland. She didn't recognize her at all, and her personal experience was quite similar to this...

Augustine 2022-04-22 07:01:55

Although James Mason is also brilliant in the movie, George Cook's version of "A Star Is Born" is more of a solo show for Judy Garland, an actress born for musicals , as long as it enters the singing and dancing stage, it becomes radiant and inspiring. Except for a song and dance scene showing the emotional contradictions of the heroine, other song and dance segments in the film focus on this...

Violette 2022-04-22 07:01:55

Maybe the original is the best, and I still prefer the 1937 version, even though there wasn't a lot of singing and dancing in that film. But the witty and lovely story and the bird-like heroine still left a deep impression on me. In this film, Judy Garland's personal characteristics are too prominent, and her age is too old. This makes people feel that the heroine is not vicky, but is still judy. From beginning to end, she is just herself. Of course, you don't have to talk about her about the...

Aniyah 2022-04-22 07:01:55

Can't remember how long ago was the last time I was stirred up by a love story in a movie. I recently read something about Judy Garland, and when I look at her work again, I have a special emotion, like after all the studio tours, I started to pay attention to the studio logo at the beginning of each...

Kieran 2022-04-21 09:03:45

It's been a long time since I saw a long movie with an intermission. A very typical Classical Hollywood Cinema, the gorgeous costumes and props and the tone of singing and dancing pursued by musical films are all there, and then it is a sad love tragedy, an ordinary girl becomes a star but loses the person she loves, and finally 's lines are...

Samson 2022-04-21 09:03:45

Except for the addition of songs and dances, the overall story, and specific details are basically the same as the 37 version. Garland and Mason's performances are also excellent, Garland's show in the living room, which is a star, is the star at all. A frown and a smile, his gestures and gestures are obviously confident and moving, and it is really hard to miss the sadness and suffering in his life. Perhaps this is the price to be paid behind the birth of a...

Madyson 2022-04-21 09:03:45

The song and dance in the movie where the heroine became famous was a bit blunt. In fact, I think that even if there are no singing and dancing clips and it is made into a drama, Judy will completely hold it. The hero and heroine acted so well. James Mason's character lacks context, and the character feels a little incomplete, but he's just too charismatic in it. Judy Garland teaches you to act every second, and the acting blows. And I feel that Judy Garland has a rustic texture in it that...

Maia 2022-04-21 09:03:45

Judy Garland's singing is really not my thing, it would look a lot better if I could play it by another person. All four stars are dedicated to Mason. In "The Country Girl", which competed for the Oscar together that year, Crosby also played a down-and-out man. I really like this kind of tragic male protagonist who can't...

Madaline 2022-04-21 09:03:45

Four and a half stars. Much better than Gaga's version. Not only the success of the female lead role, but the male lead also has a convincing and sufficient emotional portrayal, and the emotions are very moving (what is the gaga version compared to). This is the first movie starring real Judy Garland that I saw after the movie Judy, and I felt her style for the first time. The scene in the living room is unforgettable, the love between the two of them looking at each other is very touching, and...