Nancy Kulp

Thomas 2022-02-02 08:08:15

(First published on WeChat public account: Gilda's Hong Lingyan)

Hollywood has always been keen to tell the story of redemption and redemption, and the redemption between lovers is a common theme - two people fall in love and develop an intimate relationship, at the same time, one-way or two-way...

Junius 2022-02-02 08:08:15

At that time, Hollywood movies didn't show up, they didn't come out, they only told stories in a down-to-earth way. Every line, every scene is exquisite. Theatrical turns are all stuck on point. Emotional pushes follow professional skills without showing off.

The valuable thing about this movie is...

Madaline 2022-04-21 09:03:45

Four and a half stars. Much better than Gaga's version. Not only the success of the female lead role, but the male lead also has a convincing and sufficient emotional portrayal, and the emotions are very moving (what is the gaga version compared to). This is the first movie starring real Judy Garland that I saw after the movie Judy, and I felt her style for the first time. The scene in the living room is unforgettable, the love between the two of them looking at each other is very touching, and the performances of the two are very good. Songs, dances and plots occupy an important weight, 3 hours long but the rhythm is very tight. Finally, Esther stood in the center of the stage and said "I'm Mrs. Norman Maine.", the line of defense broke through tears.

Aletha 2022-03-16 09:01:09

This version feels even more dated than the 37 version, the rhythm is so slow. As an audience with no sense of Garland, this is simply the most boring "musical and dance movie" I have ever seen and the most thoroughly separated from the plot (the stage sense without live is not attractive to me). I really can't appreciate Garland's performance style. The performance is not measured by how many scenes it takes. The protagonist of this story is always N for me